Re: [atheists-55] re: Darwin is a fairy-tale

From: user 7.
Sent on: Friday, February 13, 2009 7:21 AM
I received this reply  from Zachary Boss to an email I never sent.  I am 
not the author of the original email.  It must be another Doug or 
Zachary was "replying to all".


Zachary Bos wrote:
> Dear Doug:
>
> I don't know what to make of your hostility. Are you joking? If not, 
> I'll take you at face value and responsd line by line.
>
> <<This is such horseshit, no wonder creationists think we worship 
> Darwin or something.>>
> I didn't invite anyone to a worship service, and am quite outspoken in 
> my opinion that such deification of human heroes is dangerous and 
> indefensible. Don't make the same mistakes many theists do, and see 
> ghosts where none are.
>
> <<Who cares whether it's this guys birthday?>>
> It is as good a day as any to come together to affirm our collective 
> appreciation for the scientific method. Since the celebration of 
> birthdays is a widespread practice, it seemed natural enough to 
> channel our enthusiasm for rationalism into the ready-made cultural 
> template of a birthday celebration. So, I suppose we care less about 
> the birthday qua birthday, and more about having a pretext to 
> celebrate less tangible values.
>
> <<You going to email me me on Einsteins birthday? Newtons? Bohrs? 
> Pastuers?>>
> None of these men is as widely acknowledged as having provided a 
> scientific justification for a purely secular worldview. For millenia, 
> the argument from the apparent design of organisms has been the most 
> accesible and seemingly reasonable argument for the existence of a 
> designer. Darwin's publications helped make that argument obsolete, 
> and for that reason -- the promotion of secularism into palatable 
> terms -- a lot of freethinkers get excited about the symbolic 
> significance of his research and the research it led to.
>
> <<Perhaps there is something to be said about that old Christian story 
> about the golden calf>>
> I appreciate you not wanting to throw the baby out with the bathwater, 
> but let's try to leave Old Testament fables out of this kind of 
> internal BA discussion, eh? Things can get contentious when folks get 
> exegetical.
>
> <<... apparently humans can't go five minutes without bowing down and 
> worshiping something.>>
> No one has done this or suggested this be done. Why are you projecting 
> this kind of sheepish knee-bending template onto what I'd actually 
> describe as a perfectly benign social gathering?
>
> <<There have been many scientists before and since how have made as 
> much or greater contributions to human knowledge>>
> It was the particular contribution Darwin made to the credibility of 
> secularism that so many atheists are concerned with him. And the 
> particularly charismatic nature of his research topic that attracts so 
> many admirers, in general: compare "the grandeur and beauty of the 
> diversity of life" to "the mathematical description of the 
> gravitational relationships among bodies in motion," "the ineffably 
> dualistic flavor of fundamental particles," or "the benefit of heating 
> milk before drinking," and you'll have answered your own question 
> about why the average scientifically literate citizen likes Darwin but 
> is typically indifferent toward Newton, Bohr, and Pasteur. To put it 
> briefly, people like animals.
>
> <<... and even if thier weren't it's the knowledge that's the 
> important part not idolizing the guy that first came up with it.>>
> Had you attended this evening, you would have seen no rites, no idols, 
> no songs of praise, and no tithing.
>
> <<Darwin wasn't even an athiest anyway>>
> I am aware of a great deal of evidence that suggests he was not any 
> sort of theist. I hope you'll provide references for this claim; I 
> know others will be interested to know where you get your information.
>
> <<... screw that fairy tale beleiveing moron.>>
> There is a lot to unpack in this your concluding remark:
> 1. Theism is not a fairy tale. Many components of theistic doctrine 
> are sophisticated, compound, and compelling.
> 2. To call theism "a fairy tale" is to fail to realize the many good 
> reasons many theists believe in gods. Of course, none of them are 
> quite good enough...
> 3. It is useless and furthermore stricly inaccurate to say that 
> thesists believe in fairy tales.
> 4. To call Darwin m a moron is a dismissive ad hominem attack, one 
> that is difficult to reconcile credibily with Darwin's education, 
> insight, and scientific achievement.
> 5. To conclude one's argument with the suggestion that we "screw" the 
> one with whom we disagree suggests that as one lacks the confidence in 
> the intellectual credibility of one's argument, one must resort of 
> physical acts of intolerance and antagonism.
>
> All that aside, which fairy take exactly do you think Darwin believed 
> in? Again, you'll know from reading the mailing list and perhaps from 
> your encounters with other members that we do prefer citations for 
> this kind of assertion; I hope you'll send us to a source for whatever 
> claims you make about Darwin's fairy tale subscriptions.
>
> To read your subtext, it sounds like yoy harbor suspicions that our 
> presence of tonight's Darwin Day festivities betrays an irrational 
> mindset, is that right? I'd welcome the chance to talk you out of that 
> perception, if you are open to such a discussion. Perhaps we can talk 
> about it at Sunday's brunch, if you plan to attend.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Zachary Bos
> Director, Boston Atheists
>[masked]
>
>
>
>
> -- 
> Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone 
> on this mailing list ([address removed])
> http://www.meetup...­
> This message was sent by Zachary Bos ([address removed]) from The 
> Baltimore Atheists Meetup Group.
> To learn more about Zachary Bos, visit his/her member profile: 
> http://www.meetup...­
> To unsubscribe or to update your mailing list settings, click here: 
> http://www.meetup...­
> Meetup Support: [address removed]
> 632 Broadway, New York, NY 10012 USA
>
>

Sign up

Meetup members, Log in

By clicking "Sign up" or "Sign up using Facebook", you confirm that you accept our Terms of Service & Privacy Policy