FWIW, I would vote to kill the Google Group as it's only marginally
better than Meetups lists, IMHO. But that's only my 2¢.
On Mon, Mar 10, 2014 at 10:19 PM, Paul Snyder <[address removed]> wrote:
> Unfortunately, things may be getting even more scattered for the
> discussions of SICP. As was brought up during tonight's SICP 1.1 session,
> some are buried in event discussions, some are on the Clojadelphia meetup
> main discussion list, and some are in the SICP-specific Google Group...and
> posts to the Google Group are not getting responses.
> I just discovered that, when I joined the Google Group, my settings
> defaulted to "no email delivery", so I had no idea that anyone was actually
> sending messages to the list. Simply trying to find my way back to the
> Google Group was a pain.
> I'm not at all a fan of Meetup's approach to discussion...it is difficult
> to navigate, and by its nature it facilitates fragmentation and shallow
> online conversations. This is even worse once the Google Group is added
> into the mix, since many people who may be interested in the SICP
> discussions may not be members of the Google Group. The splintering of some
> of the discussions to sublists also reduces the coherence of the
> I'm much more a fan of having everyone receive everything, and if they
> aren't interested in particular things they can simply delete the messages
> they don't find relevant, create a filter, or set digest mode to wrap
> multiple messages into a single email. The result is that community members
> have an ambient awareness of the types of conversations that are happening,
> along with the personalities of those who are participating in them. This
> helps build a strong community.
> I'm not sure what the solution is, but if we're sticking with the current
> setup I'd suggest:
> (a) Making sure that links to the Google Group are prominent in all SICP-
> related Meetup announcements.
> (b) When someone makes a useful SICP-related post and sends it to the
> Clojadelphia group, someone should suggest that he or she should cc: it
> to the Google Group.
> (c) If you're subscribed to the Google Group and do not regularly access
> the web interface, make sure you've set one of the email notification
> options so you stay abreast of new discussions.
> (d) All discussions of *scheduling* of times for SICP meetups should be
> done through the Meetup site (or at least cc'd to the main Clojadelphia
> meetup discussion list).
> Annoyingly, the awful Google Groups web interface makes it almost
> impossible to figure out how to send messages to it via email. Once you're
> subscribed, email can be sent to
> [address removed]
> For general Clojadelphia discussion, the main Meetup mailing list address
> [address removed]
> Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
> This message was sent by Paul Snyder ([address removed]) from Clojadelphia.
> To learn more about Paul Snyder, visit his/her member profile: http://www.meetup...
> Set my mailing list to email me
> As they are sent
> In one daily email
> Don't send me mailing list messages
> Meetup, POB 4668 #37895 NY NY USA 10163 | [address removed]