Pro-Line is in Ozone Park and gives you two hours w/ rental for $20. Recent Yelp! reviews rank it mostly 5 and 4 stars. Most reviews gave the place high marks, but fairly noted that as a smaller place, it can be a bit cramped.
(I was considering Big Apple (aka Queens), but groups of 9 or more require reservations, and then only at 5:30 or 7:30 on weekend evenings. Also, they're about equally as hard (or easy) to get out to, but they are a back-up in case of anything.)
I took the liberty of pre-signing up the chaps who'd told me previously they were down for this...re-confirm down in the comments and I'll adjust the RSVP's as necessary. :D
If peeps are hungry later, there's a pizzeria across the street, and a little hole-in-the-wall Peruvian joint a block away- but YMMV as to how much you'll like 'em :P.