Re: [aynrand-8] Some say Ayn Rand was not so "nice": That is out of context

From: Matt
Sent on: Monday, August 13, 2012 6:27 PM
Wow. Why don't you guys all rent a hall together and hash it out in person. I'm a huge Rand fan and subscribed to the group but can anyone tell me how to unsubscribe to these emails filling up my mailbox? Don't know what you guys are trying to prove. Who's right? Who cares?

Matt

Sent from my iPhone

On Aug 13, 2012, at 6:13 PM, stevegam <[address removed]> wrote:


"You've admitted you're willing to initiate force, but you won't give us your very own opinion as to how you infer the right to do so. 

I can explain my actions, can't you? "

Hey, David try using that line the next time you're in a bar and some guy is kicking your ass for "insulting" his girl friend.

Let's forget about page 119 too, who gives a crap.
 
Objectivism is a philosophy that is unproven in the real world. Since it's based strictly on reason, specifically the reason of one person, it is subject to the law of unintended consequences.

One of the problems of using reason in determining truth is that it assumes that all the important facts necessary to make a reasonable decision are known. This may be true in areas of science and engineering where an engineer writing a computer program or building a bridge can know all that needs to be known. He is omnipotent, a god, in his little closed system so his endeavor using reason will work provided, his reason is sound.

The real world is too complex to rely on reason alone to make choices on how we should live (should i marry? have children?) Often it is not possible to have all the facts necessary to make successful decisions without consulting other sources based on the collective experience of others, such as consensus, religion, etc. When we ignore the collective experience of others the law of unintended consequences kicks in, ouch.

I think a group of people trying to implement objectivism in the real world would make a good reality tv show. It wouldn't be much different than a bunch of hippies in a commune trying to rebel against the establishment but instead the law of unintended consequences re-teaches, them amongst other things, the value of good hygiene by inflicting them with long  eradicated  medieval deceases such as the rot and the grunge. This really happened in the Haight Ashbury section of San Francisco in the 1960s.


In an objectivism "commune" or gulch who would have the character, and the wisdom to decide what was reasonable? How would they choose such a person? I wouldn't even trust Michael to do that.

Is the redistribution of wealth always wrong? What could be some of the unintended consequences if we forbid, in a dogmatic, objectivist way, the redistribution of wealth in all it's forms?

Sent from my iPhone

On Aug 13, 2012, at 5:44 PM, Marc Gerstein <[address removed]> wrote:

"But I want to know what YOU say."

I fully endorse what Ayn Rand and the Libertarian Party say on the topic, and to satisfy an understandable quest for specificity, I continue to refer you to page 119 of "The Virtue of Selfishness."

I absolutely positively could repeat that material to you, but I choose not to do so because I'm having way too much fun watching you squeal like a stuck pig as you continue to try to cover up your ignorance Objectivism and Libertariansim and get increasingly frustrated as I continue to refuse to let you off the hook.

"If are pointing a gun at someone and taking them off to jail and they asked you  "by what right do you do this " how would you reply?"

I'd whip out my Kindle, access page 119 of "The Virtue of Selfishness," point to the relevant text, and say "You violated this principal." Then I'd go further. I'd add: "I know it's customary for law-enforcement officers to recite the charges out loud and if you'd like, I'll be glad to do that. But I'm having a lot of fun watching this phony Objectivist-Libertarian named David Wallace twist in the wind trying to pretend he knows this stuff when he really doesn't. So if you'll consent to waiving the out-loud reading and accept my just pointing the text out to you and waiting thirty seconds while you read it for yourself, I'll get the judge to come down with a suspension of jail time and just a week of probation and we can then all sit down together and laugh at David Wallance as he continues to squeal."


From: David <[address removed]>
To: [address removed]
Sent: Monday, August 13,[masked]:55 PM
Subject: Re: [aynrand-8] Some say Ayn Rand was not so "nice": That is out of context

But I want to know what YOU say. 

You've admitted you're willing to initiate force, but you won't give us your very own opinion as to how you infer the right to do so. 

I can explain my actions, can't you? 

If are pointing a gun at someone and taking them off to jail and they asked you  "by what right do you do this " how would you reply? 

Would you reply " I cannot answer, but go to the library and read some books"?. 

Keep in mind that language is not essential only for social interaction but also for the organization of your own thoughts. If you cannot explain to me, quite simply, by what right you get to initiate force on others then  you can of explain it to yourself.

 And that means you literally don't know what you're talking about.  



Sent from my iPhone

On Aug 13, 2012, at 2:38 PM, Marc Gerstein <[address removed]> wrote:

My prior response: " As to debate, that would be quite dull since we're dealing with just a few sentences and about 30 seconds worth of time, but if that's what it will take to get you to consider what Rand says, so be it."

What part of that don't you understand?

It really is a shame -- for you -- that the U.S.S.R. collapsed. I really can see where you'd have been a great editorial writer fro Pravda!





From: David Wallace <[address removed]>
To: Marc Gerstein <[address removed]>
Sent: Monday, August 13,[masked]:10 PM
Subject: Re: [aynrand-8] Some say Ayn Rand was not so "nice": That is out of context

So yes, to a debate? Is that a yes? 

On your obvious evasion: citing a page from the works of another is a response, but not an answer. In fact, not only is it an evasion but a puerile one at that! 

After all, I am asking you of your own convictions. You endorse the initiation of force. YOU! Now by Wendy right do you do so? 

Don't you know the contents of your own mind? 

Sent from my iPhone

On Aug 13, 2012, at 1:16 PM, Marc Gerstein <[address removed]> wrote:

I evaded nothing. I answered you very specifically with a specific cite to Ayn Rand, which is quite valid in a Rand discussion forum. And I've been on line way too long to fall into the trap of trying to cope with someone who pretends to not recognize an answer and keeps repeating fictitious claims of non response-- that's so 1990s!

If you want to come to the next meetup to explain your refusal to consider Rand a legitimate source, I look forward to hearing what you want to say. As to debate, that would be quite dull since we're dealing with just a few sentences and about 30 seconds worth of time, but if that's what it will take to get you to consider what Rand says, so be it.

I am, however, preparing material that will, I hope, generate more interesting discussion interpreting ways Rand's principals might be applied in the real world. So I would expect to move beyond the boring part very quickly.

David <[address removed]> wrote:

Marc, 

I would be happy to meet in person at the next Ayn Rand meet-up. 

We can even schedule an open debate replete with facilitation if the others are willing. 

Would you like to do that? 

Also, 

By your evasion of my simple question you make my point regarding the disingenuous left. You said that I don't know you. But the point is that YOU don't know you. For you endorsed the initiation of force and yet refuse to elucidate the moral system from which you infer that right. 

Everyone else sees this evasion, which is all the more transparent since I am asking what YOU think. Not what you are, or are not. Not what you've read or for that matter what you had for breakfast. But rather the simple verdict of your own mind. 

By what right do you initiate force? 

Sent from my iPhone

On Aug 13, 2012, at 10:01 AM, Marc Gerstein <[address removed]> wrote:

Steve,

I'm still somewhat new to the NYC Meetup and have only been to two of them (the last two). I can't recall the names of everyone (it looks to be a well-attended group, so that will take time) and the attendee lists on meetup.com aren't always 100% accurate.  So i can't say for sure if Michael was there.

What I can tell you, at least from the two meetups I attended, is that it looks to be a good group, one in which there is disagreement but in which the tone is respectful and in which challenges appear not as in invitation to yell and curse but as an invitation to review and sharpen one's position . . . which is as positive as it can get. Obviously, nobody can know who will show up in the future and how they'll act, but generally, the demeanor of the NY group seems like it would be quite inhibiting to anyone (even Michael  if he was or will be there) from resorting to "eat shit and die," "suck on a tailpipe," etc.

Is Michael doing a pre-dynamite Howard Roark thing? I'm not so sure. We have one thing going on here that was outside Rand's experience: internet conversation. I've seen in many contexts how people will act on line in ways they wouldn't dream of acting if face to face. I suspect we've all encountered that. It would seem that anonymous forums are more conducive to this sort of thing than those in which people use real names. But it does happen in the latter instances, too. For all we know, Michael might be a nice guy in real life. All we can do here is react to the identity he chooses to reveal in this setting. (BTW anyone interested in internet behavior may find it interesting to check out "The Face of Another" by Kobo Abe. The writing style isn't my favorite . . . quite heavy on the first-person musings. But it is an interesting meditation on matchups between appearances and identity.)


From: stevegam <[address removed]>
To: [address removed]
Sent: Monday, August 13,[masked]:52 AM
Subject: RE: [aynrand-8] Some say Ayn Rand was not so "nice": That is out of context

Michael,
 
I don't think I can have a meaningful dialogue with you.
 
Marc,
 
You were at the last meetup, did you see Michael there?
 
If so, is he typical of the group? I'm guessing that he isn't, but if he is then he must be in the state of mind of Howard Roark, right before he blew up his building, watch out guys.
 
> Subject: Re: [aynrand-8] Some say Ayn Rand was not so "nice": That is out of context
> From: [address removed]
> To: [address removed]
> Date: Sun, 12 Aug[masked]:30:26 -0400
>
> Do you scrub your sphincter?
> How about asking me why I prefer to mock you? You're complacence toward any meaningful dialogue is apparent to every free mind as the epitome of cowardice. Buck up, old sport (for I suspect you are as old as you are decrepit).
>
> Sent from my iPhone
>
> On Aug 12, 2012, at 6:00 PM, stevegam <[address removed]> wrote:
>
> > I'm trying to determine if you are an objectivist, that's why I asked.
> >
> > Do you attend the meetups regularly?
> >
> > Sent from my iPhone
> >
> > On Aug 12, 2012, at 5:21 PM, Michael Olsen <[address removed]> wrote:
> >
> >> That for you to determine. You're a statist; care to know why?
> >>
> >> Sent from my iPhone
> >>
> >> On Aug 12, 2012, at 5:15 PM, stevegam <[address removed]> wrote:
> >>
> >>> Michael,
> >>>
> >>> Are you an objectivist?
> >>>
> >>> Sent from my iPhone
> >>>
> >>> On Aug 12, 2012, at 2:06 AM, Michael Olsen <[address removed]> wrote:
> >>>
> >>>> Lol. This is some great righteous vitriol.
> >>>> I mean, why even try with fuck face shit chuggers like tweedle Steve and tweedle Marc? I hope they each write a whole goddam paragraph breaking my nasty letters into tiny little bite sized verdicts of tolerant condemnation.
> >>>> Salute/honor @ David & Jim.
> >>>>
> >>>> Sent from my iPhone
> >>>>
> >>>> On Aug 12, 2012, at 1:56 AM, David <[address removed]> wrote:
> >>>>
> >>>>> Ah, now you're running off my little friend. And I was having such fun.
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Perhaps this completes my point regarding Rand's rhetorical style in the face of disingenuous hacks who lick the blood of martyrs from the knuckles of tyrants.
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Sent from my iPhone
> >>>>>
> >>>>> On Aug 12, 2012, at 1:46 AM, Michael Olsen <[address removed]> wrote:
> >>>>>
> >>>>>> Marc, eat shit and die.
> >>>>>> "For starters, nobody forces you to live in civilized society..." Unlike you, supreme shit chugger, I was forced into the USA at the behest o my mother contractions. This is a forum & group of thinkers. I suggest you stick to YouTube trolling.
> >>>>>> Ps. Die. Please. Fast. No jokes, suck a tail pipe you base communist ;)
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> Sent from my iPhone
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> On Aug 12, 2012, at 12:56 AM, Marc Gerstein <[address removed]> wrote:
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>>> For starters, nobody forces you to live in civilized society
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> --
> >>>>>> Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
> >>>>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/
> >>>>>> This message was sent by Michael Olsen ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
> >>>>>> To learn more about Michael Olsen, visit his/her member profile: http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/members/9722183/
> >>>>>> Set my mailing list to email me
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> As they are sent
> >>>>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=1
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> In one daily email
> >>>>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=2
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> Don't send me mailing list messages
> >>>>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=0
> >>>>>> Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>> --
> >>>>> Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
> >>>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/
> >>>>> This message was sent by David ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
> >>>>> To learn more about David, visit his/her member profile: http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/members/12420483/
> >>>>> Set my mailing list to email me
> >>>>>
> >>>>> As they are sent
> >>>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=1
> >>>>>
> >>>>> In one daily email
> >>>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=2
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Don't send me mailing list messages
> >>>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=0
> >>>>> Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]
> >>>>>
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>> --
> >>>> Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
> >>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/
> >>>> This message was sent by Michael Olsen ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
> >>>> To learn more about Michael Olsen, visit his/her member profile: http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/members/9722183/
> >>>> Set my mailing list to email me
> >>>>
> >>>> As they are sent
> >>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=1
> >>>>
> >>>> In one daily email
> >>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=2
> >>>>
> >>>> Don't send me mailing list messages
> >>>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=0
> >>>> Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]
> >>>>
> >>>>
> >>>
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> --
> >>> Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
> >>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/
> >>> This message was sent by stevegam ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
> >>> To learn more about stevegam, visit his/her member profile: http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/members/2817568/
> >>> Set my mailing list to email me
> >>>
> >>> As they are sent
> >>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=1
> >>>
> >>> In one daily email
> >>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=2
> >>>
> >>> Don't send me mailing list messages
> >>> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=0
> >>> Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]
> >>>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >> --
> >> Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
> >> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/
> >> This message was sent by Michael Olsen ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
> >> To learn more about Michael Olsen, visit his/her member profile: http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/members/9722183/
> >> Set my mailing list to email me
> >>
> >> As they are sent
> >> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=1
> >>
> >> In one daily email
> >> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=2
> >>
> >> Don't send me mailing list messages
> >> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=0
> >> Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]
> >>
> >>
> >
> >
> >
> > --
> > Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
> > http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/
> > This message was sent by stevegam ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
> > To learn more about stevegam, visit his/her member profile: http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/members/2817568/
> > Set my mailing list to email me
> >
> > As they are sent
> > http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=1
> >
> > In one daily email
> > http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=2
> >
> > Don't send me mailing list messages
> > http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=0
> > Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]
> >
>
>
>
> --
> Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/
> This message was sent by Michael Olsen ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
> To learn more about Michael Olsen, visit his/her member profile: http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/members/9722183/
> Set my mailing list to email me
>
> As they are sent
> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=1
>
> In one daily email
> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=2
>
> Don't send me mailing list messages
> http://www.meetup.com/aynrand-8/list_prefs/?pref=0
> Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]
>




--
Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
This message was sent by stevegam ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
To learn more about stevegam, visit his/her member profile
Set my mailing list to email me As they are sent | In one daily email | Don't send me mailing list messages

Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]






--
Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
This message was sent by Marc Gerstein ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
To learn more about Marc Gerstein, visit his/her member profile
Set my mailing list to email me As they are sent | In one daily email | Don't send me mailing list messages

Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]




--
Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
This message was sent by David ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
To learn more about David, visit his/her member profile
Set my mailing list to email me As they are sent | In one daily email | Don't send me mailing list messages

Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]






--
Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
This message was sent by Marc Gerstein ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
To learn more about Marc Gerstein, visit his/her member profile
Set my mailing list to email me As they are sent | In one daily email | Don't send me mailing list messages

Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]




--
Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
This message was sent by David ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
To learn more about David, visit his/her member profile
Set my mailing list to email me As they are sent | In one daily email | Don't send me mailing list messages

Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]






--
Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
This message was sent by Marc Gerstein ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
To learn more about Marc Gerstein, visit his/her member profile
Set my mailing list to email me As they are sent | In one daily email | Don't send me mailing list messages

Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]




--
Please Note: If you hit "REPLY", your message will be sent to everyone on this mailing list ([address removed])
This message was sent by stevegam ([address removed]) from The New York City Ayn Rand Group.
To learn more about stevegam, visit his/her member profile
Set my mailing list to email me As they are sent | In one daily email | Don't send me mailing list messages

Meetup, PO Box 4668 #37895 New York, New York[masked] | [address removed]

Sign up

Meetup members, Log in

By clicking "Sign up" or "Sign up using Facebook", you confirm that you accept our Terms of Service & Privacy Policy