addressalign-toparrow-leftarrow-rightbackbellblockcalendarcameraccwchatcheckchevron-downchevron-leftchevron-rightchevron-small-downchevron-small-leftchevron-small-rightchevron-small-upchevron-upcircle-with-crosscrosseditemptyheartfacebookfolderfullheartglobegmailgoogleimagesinstagramlinklocation-pinmagnifying-glassmailminusmoremuplabelShape 3 + Rectangle 1outlookpersonplusprice-ribbonImported LayersImported LayersImported Layersshieldstartrashtriangle-downtriangle-uptwitteruseryahoo

The Buffalo Boardgames Meetup Group Message Board › August 17th Games

August 17th Games

bobbie8153
bobbie8153
Buffalo, NY
Post #: 132
1st choice
-------------
Filthy Rich
Dungeoneer
Shadows Over Camelot
Who Stole Ed's Pants

2nd chioice
---------------
Werewolf
Guillotine
Gloom

I put 4 in first, so i didn't make a third list.
A former member
Post #: 18
Here are my votes for the week:

1st
------
Hispaniola
Gloom
Zendo

2nd
------
Guillotine
Amun Re
Dungeoneer

3rd
------
Shadows Over Camelot
Filthy Rich
Elfenland

And of course a game or two of Werewolf is always a great way to get everyone together for a bit.
Kevin
kwojtasz
Lancaster, NY
Post #: 50
1st
----
War of the Ring
Euphrat & Tigris
Princes of Florence

2nd
-----
Amun Re
Citadels
Elfenland

3rd
----
Pentacle
San Marco
Attika
Doug
SuburbnBubbleBoy
East Amherst, NY
Post #: 205
I'll make a stab at what I think Ruth may like:

1st Pref
----------
1) Gloom
2) Guillotine
3) Elfenland

2nd Pref
----------
1) Too Many Cooks
2) Who Stole Ed's Pants
3) Filthy Rich

3rd Pref
----------
1) Atlantic Star
2) Werewolf
3) Attika

This is just a guess... Do what you will with it Don.
April
arielmt
Buffalo, NY
Post #: 71
That was crazy hard. Crazy hard.

Ridiculous. I had to take the list, look up each one I didn't know about and then work by process of elimination. Of course, I had to eliminate 4 or 5 I was interested in just to whittle it down to...

1st (also known as possibly intense 90 minute games that seem very similar, all of which I'd like to try)
++++
Amun Re
Euphrat & Tigris
Princes of Florence

2nd (also known as 60 minute games)
++++
Attika
Dungeoneer

3rd (60 minute or less, lighter fare)
++++
Atlantic Star
Who Stole Ed's Pants
Filthy Rich

Filler (all look like a hoot!)
++++
Guillotine
Gloom
Pit
bobbie8153
bobbie8153
Buffalo, NY
Post #: 134
fyi - Gloom isn't a filler
Kevin
kwojtasz
Lancaster, NY
Post #: 51
guess the definition of filler hasn't been established yet, as I'd have to agree with April on Gloom being more a filler game from the description on BG. smile
Doug
SuburbnBubbleBoy
East Amherst, NY
Post #: 206
That depends on yer definition of filler.

If a filler is a game that is played fairly quickly (20 mins or less) then no, Gloom is not a filler.

If a filler is a light game that doesnt require a lot of horsepower, then yes, Gloom is a filler.

Guillotine fits both definitions as a filler. biggrin

**Edit**
Both the above mentioned games are a lot of fun. I bought Guillotine Saturday and have since played prolly close to a dozen games. Its fast, fun, and easy. Kevin would hate it. Gloom is a riot too, but only if you enjoy "take that" games. Its fun and easy (not fast tho--with 4 figure 40 minutes or so). Kevin would hate it. wink
Joel
cuthbert15
Buffalo, NY
Post #: 48
My Votes:

1st Pref
---------
Hispaniola
War of the Ring

2nd Pref
---------
Princes of Florence
Attika

3rd Pref
---------
Shadows over Camelot
Gloom
Guillotine
Don
dbc00p
Group Organizer
Buffalo, NY
Post #: 171
Here's the final vote tally for this week. Surprisingly Ed's pants seemed to have waned in popularity. I'll post the lineup ASAP.

1st Pref
----------
Elfenland - 4 - Don, Scott, Doug, Ruth
War of the Ring - 4 - Scott, Doug, Kevin, Joel
Princes of Florence - 3 - Don, Kevin, April
Hispaniola - 2 - Ben, Joel
Gloom - 2 - Ben, Ruth
Euphrat & Tigris - 2 - Kevin, April
Tower of Babel - Scott
Amun Re - Doug, April
Filthy Rich - Bobbie
Dungeoneer - Bobbie
Shadows Over Camelot - Bobbie
Who Stole Ed's Pants - Bobbie
Zendo - Ben
Guillotine - Ruth
San Marco - Don


2nd Pref
-----------
Attika - 4 - Don, Doug, April, Joel
Amun Re - 4 - Don, Scott, Ben, Kevin
Princes of Florence - 2 - Scott, Joel
Dungeoneer - 2 - Ben, April
Atlantic Star - 2 - Scott, Doug
Hispaniola - Don
Tower of Babel - Doug
Werewolf - Bobbie
Guillotine - Bobbie
Gloom - Bobbie
Guillotine - Ben
Citadels - Kevin
Elfenland - Kevin
Too Many Cooks - Ruth
Who Stole Ed's Pants - Ruth
Filthy Rich - Ruth


3rd Pref
-----------
Shadows Over Camelot - 5 - Don, Scott, Doug, Ben, Joel
Attika - 3 - Scott, Kevin, Ruth
San Marco - 2 - Scott, Kevin
Werewolf - 2 - Doug, Ruth
Filthy Rich - 2 - Ben, April
Gloom - 2 - Don, Joel
Citadels - Don
Zendo - Doug
Elfenland - Ben
Pentacle - Kevin
Atlantic Star - Ruth, April
Who Stole Ed's Pants - April
Guillotine - Joel


All Prefs [] = 1st pref () = 2nd pref
--------------------------------------­-------
Attika - 7 - (Don, Doug, April, Joel), Scott, Kevin, Ruth
Amun Re - 6 - [Doug, April], (Don, Scott, Ben, Kevin)
Elfenland - 6 - [Don, Scott, Doug, Ruth], (Kevin), Ben
Shadows Over Camelot - 6 - [Bobbie], Don, Scott, Doug, Ben, Joel
Princes of Florence - 5 - [Don, Kevin, April], (Scott, Joel)
Gloom - 5 - [Ben, Ruth], (Bobbie), Don, Joel
War of the Ring - 4 - [Scott, Doug, Kevin, Joel]
Guillotine - 4 - [Ruth], (Bobbie, Ben), Joel
Filthy Rich - 4 - [Bobbie], (Ruth), Ben, April
Atlantic Star - 4 - (Scott, Doug), Ruth, April
Hispaniola - 3 - [Ben, Joel], (Don)
Dungeoneer - 3 - [Bobbie], (Ben, April)
Who Stole Ed's Pants - 3 - [Bobbie], (Ruth), April
San Marco - 3 - [Don], Scott, Kevin
Werewolf - 3 - (Bobbie), Doug, Ruth
Euphrat & Tigris - 2 - [Kevin, April]
Tower of Babel - 2 - [Scott], (Doug)
Zendo - 2 - [Ben], Doug
Citadels - 2 - (Kevin), Don
Too Many Cooks - (Ruth)
Pentacle - Kevin
Powered by mvnForum

Sign up

Meetup members, Log in

By clicking "Sign up" or "Sign up using Facebook", you confirm that you accept our Terms of Service & Privacy Policy