addressalign-toparrow-leftarrow-rightbackbellblockcalendarcameraccwcheckchevron-downchevron-leftchevron-rightchevron-small-downchevron-small-leftchevron-small-rightchevron-small-upchevron-upcircle-with-checkcircle-with-crosscircle-with-pluscrossdots-three-verticaleditemptyheartexporteye-with-lineeyefacebookfolderfullheartglobegmailgooglegroupsimageimagesinstagramlinklocation-pinm-swarmSearchmailmessagesminusmoremuplabelShape 3 + Rectangle 1outlookpersonJoin Group on CardStartprice-ribbonImported LayersImported LayersImported Layersshieldstartickettrashtriangle-downtriangle-uptwitteruseryahoo

The Buffalo Boardgames Meetup Group Message Board › September 14th Games

September 14th Games

Laurie
LaurieW917
Lancaster, NY
Post #: 53
1st:
Attika
Ingenious
Fearsome Floors

2nd:
Bohnanza
Bang! Dodge City (never played)
Summer Camp (never played)

3rd:
Princes of Florence (never played)
Nautilus (never played)


GOTM:
Attika
citadels
Ticket To Ride
Louie XIV (never played)
Tikal (never played)
Tower of Babel (never played)
elfenland (never played)
April
arielmt
Buffalo, NY
Post #: 93
You're making my brain hurt!

1ST
----
Princes of Florence
Attika

2ND
----
Summer Camp
Ingenious

3RD
----
Fearsome Floors
Nautilus
Bohnanza

Note that I didn't even vote for Bang!

1. Citadels
2. Attika
3. Elfenland (I thought this was a hoot!)
4. Tikal
5. Ticket To Ride
6. Louie XIV
7. Tower of Babel
Doug
SuburbnBubbleBoy
East Amherst, NY
Post #: 251
Dont worry April, I'll bring my Bang! cards just in case. I know you had really meant to put that in your #1 slot. I got yer back covered...wink
Lana
puddlediving
East Aurora, NY
Post #: 1
1st:
Attika
Princes of Florence
Bohnanza

2nd:
Bang! Dodge City
Fearsome Floors
Nautilus

3rd:
Summer Camp
Ingenious


Not voting for GOTM because I've hardly played any of them.
A former member
Post #: 34
Sorry I didn't nominate anything for this week, all I was thinking of last week was going away for a couple of days and totally forgot about the meetup.

1st
===
Bohnanza
Bang! Dodge City
Fearsome Floors

2nd
===
Attika
Ingenious
Summer Camp

3rd
===
Princes of Florence
Nautilus


GOTM
====
1) Ticket To Ride
2) Tower of Babel
3) elfenland
4) Tikal
5) Attika
6) citadels
7) Louie XIV
A former member
Post #: 9
This week:
1st preference: Princes of Florence
Bang!
Summer Camp
2nd: Fearsome Floors
Ticket to Ride
3rd: Elfenland
Ingenious

GOTM:
1 Citadels
2 Ticket to Ride
3 Tikal
4 Louis XIV
5 Attika
6 Tower of Babel
7 Elfenland
A former member
Post #: 110
1st:
Princes of Florence
Summer Camp
Fearsome Floors

2nd:
Bohnanza
Bang! Dodge City
Ingenious

3rd:
Nautilus
Attika

GOTM:
Louie XIV
Tower of Babel
Tikal
citadels
elfenland
Ticket To Ride
Attika
Doug
SuburbnBubbleBoy
East Amherst, NY
Post #: 254
Just because I am bored, I crunched a few numbers.

FYI, as it stands the current rankings for GOTM are:

1) Citadels (Average rating of 3.3)
2) Ticket to Ride (Average Rating of 3.4)
3) Tower of Babel (average Rating of 4.1)
4) Attika (Average Rating of 4.2)
5*) Elfenland (Average Rating of 4.3)
6*) Tikal (Average Rating of 4.3)
7) Louis XIV (Average Rating of 4.4)

Notice that 5 and 6 are tied so I put them in alphabetical order.

Interestingly enough, we have 2 clear winners and then the rest of the pack is very closely tied from there on out. Guess we should be glad we have multiple copies of Citadels. Of course further votes could sway the total. TtR is only .1 behind Citadels! Hotly contended race! I encourage others to check my figures as I did it quickly.

**Edit**
Using a straight average may not be the way Don plans to pick the game of the month. I dont know boo bout statistics so I did some simple arithmatic. Work is slow some times........
Don
dbc00p
Group Organizer
Buffalo, NY
Post #: 218
Here's how the open voting ended up. Now it's onto the GOTM.

1st pref
----------
Attika - 7 - Don, Doug, Isaac, Bobbie, Laurie, April, Lana
Princes of Florence - 7 - Don, Doug, Issaac, April, Lana, Ed, Scott
Bang! Dodge City - 4 - Doug, Isaac, Ben, Ed
Fearsome Floors - 4 - Bobbbie, Laurie, Ben, Scott
Summer Camp - 3 - Bobbie, Ed, Scott
Bohnanza - 2 - Lana, Ben
Ingenious - 1 - Laurie
Nautilus - 1 - Don


2nd pref
-----------
Summer camp - 6 - Don, Doug, Isaac, Laurie, April, Ben
Ingenious - 5 - Isaac, Bobbie, April, Ben, Scott
Bohnanza - 5 - Doug, Bobbie, Laurie, Don, Scott
Bang! Dodge City - 4 - Don, Laurie, Lana, Scott
Nautilus - 3 - Doug, Bobbie, Lana
Fearsome Floors - 3 - Isaac, Lana, Ed
Attika - 1 - Ben
Ticket to Ride - 1 - Ed


3rd Pref
-----------
Nautilus - 5 - Isaac, Laurie, April, Ben, Scott
Ingenious - 4 - Don, Doug, Lana, Ed
Fearsome Floors - 3 - Don, Doug, APril
Princes of Florence - 2 - Laurie, Ben
Bohnanza - 1 - April
Summer Camp - 1 - Lana
Elfenland - 1 - Ed
Attika - 1 - Scott


All prefs [] = 1st pref () = 2nd pref
--------------------------------------­--------
Fearsome Floors - 10 - [Bobbbie, Laurie, Ben, Scott], (Isaac, Lana, Ed), Don, Doug, APril
Summer Camp - 10 - [Bobbie, Ed, Scott], (Don, Doug, Isaac, Laurie, April, Ben), Lana
Attika - 9 - [Don, Doug, Isaac, Bobbie, Laurie, April, Lana], (Ben), Scott
Princes of Florence - 9 - [Don, Doug, Issaac, April, Lana, Ed, Scott], Laurie, Ben
Ingenious - 9 - [Laurie], (Don, Laurie, Lana, Scott), Don, Doug, Lana, Ed
Nautilus - 9 - [Don], (Doug, Bobbie, Lana), Isaac, Laurie, April, Ben, Scott
Bang! Dodge City - 8 - [Doug, Isaac, Ben, Ed], (Don, Laurie, Lana, Scott)
Bohnanza - 8 - [Lana, Ben], (Doug, Bobbie, Laurie, Don, Scott), April
Ticket to Ride - 1 - (Ed)
Elfenland - 1 - Ed
Don
dbc00p
Group Organizer
Buffalo, NY
Post #: 219
And here is the GOTM results. All I did was give 7 points for a 1st rank vote 6 for a 2nd, etc. etc. etc. Citadels and Ticket kicked some serious butt. After that it was a close race. Citadels was a big surprise for me because we haven't palyed that one forever and there hasn't been a lot of talk about it either. Although it has been nominated a few times it never got back to the table, until now that is.

Citadels - 47
Ticket To Ride - 46
Tower of Babel - 39
Attika - 38
elfenland - 37
Tikal - 37
Louie XIV - 36

So the GOTM games for September are:

Citadels
Ticket to Ride
Tower of Babel
Attika

No onto the lineup.
Powered by mvnForum

People in this
Meetup are also in:

Sign up

Meetup members, Log in

By clicking "Sign up" or "Sign up using Facebook", you confirm that you accept our Terms of Service & Privacy Policy