Thanks for your comments, I guess I'll just start planning stuff and see how many folks bite.
Roni: sorry to burst your bubble, but we probably won't be showing stuff we've watched recently. Personally, while we love sharing our favorite films with folks, we don't rewatch movies too often. So, there probably won't be a second showing of Beasts of the Southern Wild or Take Shelter (and we're working on planning a night for Tree of Life with another group, so that's probably out as well). Those were mainly just examples to give an idea of our tastes. That said though, we do actually own all of the films I've mentioned (except for Jiro Dreams of Sushi), so if you want to borrow them. Hopefully you have a blu-ray player, as I only have blu-ray copies of a number of them. If you're interested, let me know off-list.