On Intention and Guilt - Socrates on Trial

The trial of Socrates in 399 BC in Athens is probably the most famous trial in (Western) history. It is also one of the most puzzling trials in history and prompted kilometers of texts printed up to today. Plato’s Apology of Socrates is one of the many apologies written not too long after the trial. Though it doesn’t faithfully recount the exact course of the trial, it is of enormous value for western philosophy, our understanding of Socrates, and Platonism.

Socrates was put on trial for asebeia (impiety) and corruption of the youth.
This evening, we will focus on the latter accusation and put Socrates again on trial: Did he really corrupt the youth? His defense, in short, was that he had no intention of doing so, hence this should be enough to acquit him. The claim of intentions opens onto a much bigger question, one that still occupies courtrooms and ethics seminars and our opinion of others alike: how much should intention matter in judging an action, or someone accused of wrongdoing? Is a well-meant harm less blameworthy than a careless one? Can good intentions excuse a bad outcome — or bad intentions taint a good one?

How will this particular session work? Your two co-hosts give a short introduction of the text, after which we split into two groups: prosecution and defense. Bring your sharpest argument and help your host build the case; they will carry them into the courtroom on your behalf, so nobody has to take the stand themselves.

Prior reading is useful but not necessary, as we will build up the concepts of intention, moral and legal responsibility, and the methodology of solid argumentation as we go. As always, active participation is welcome but there is no obligation or pressure to speak.

Join us for a lively evening of debate and cross-examination of arguably the most famous philosopher the Western world has produced.

Preparation:
Potential pre-reads, pre-watch or pre-listenings:

• Not fully on the Apology but the Apology serves as a basis for Socratic methodology
• The full text can be found here as of page 68
  or there
• Full lecture on the Apology, divided into chapters

For Philosophical Minds Zurich theme events in general:
At our theme events, it’s all about conversation, not just listening. Also, please note, we keep the atmosphere relaxed and informal—there’s no pressure to speak in front of anyone.

Important: When you register for the event, please commit to it and don't be a NO SHOW. Presumably, when the ancient philosophers decided to go to an event, they kept to it.

We look forward to seeing you.

Payment: You can pay at the venue (Twint/Revolut/Cash). Thus, if you want to register at Meetup just click attend - no more needed ;).

We look forward to seeing you.