Re: [Provocateurs] Fw: Science & God Belief

From: Caleob K.
Sent on: Thursday, March 28, 2013 11:30 PM
"Belief in god" is a big umbrella. Big enough, I'd say, to fit a few dedicated scientists under it. After all there are plenty of ways   to believe in a deity - and some of them are compatible with the universe as we observe it. I can even respect their willingness to put aside their beliefs in order to progress the state of human knowledge. As usual, I'd argue that god isn't the problem - faith is.

I propose that science is completely incompatible with faith as a pathway to knowledge. As long as it is taken seriously, faith will always be a substitute for good evidence and a way to discount evidence already gathered. To the extent scientists do not apply faith to their specialized area of expertise (and researchers are very specialized so this is often possible) than its effect can be minimized, but that is a best case scenario. 

Although a person's professional life might be dedicated to the observation and improvement of winter wheat pesticide resistance, and in this narrow field apply science without the interference of their faith, in their wider lives they take on a variety of roles. This researcher may also be a citizen, a mother, a teacher, a lover, a philanthropist, and an artist. To fulfill these varied roles well this scientist must have a coherent view of the universe - which in my opinion precludes applying reason and evidence in a patchwork way.

People in this
Meetup are also in:

Sign up

Meetup members, Log in

By clicking "Sign up" or "Sign up using Facebook", you confirm that you accept our Terms of Service & Privacy Policy