Skip to content

Details

In February, we discussed J.L. Austin’s ordinary language philosophy and speech act theory. In March, we will discuss a debate over Austin between French deconstructionist Jacques Derrida and American speech act theorist John Searle. The Derrida-Searle debate is frequently cited in discussions of the divide between continental and analytic philosophy.

In 1972, Derrida published “Signature Event Context” (SEC). He begins by considering writing, and the “absence” of the writer when the reader is reading and of the reader when the writer is writing. He argues that all communication is characterized by this kind of absence, which undermines the ability of communication to transmit intended meanings. In the second part, he both commends and criticizes Austin’s speech act theory. He praises Austin for having “shattered the concept of communication” as “the transference of a semantic content.” But he attacks Austin for assuming an “exhaustively determined” context that includes the intended meanings of speakers. Against this, Derrida argues “a context is never absolutely determinable.”

The 1977 English translation of SEC contained a response from Searle. Regarding the first part of SEC, Searle argues that Derrida is wrong that the “iterability” of writing is what makes it possible to communicate despite absence. Rather, interability is shared by both writing and speech; writing is just more “permanent.” Searle says this “confusion of permanence with iterability” lies behind Derrida’s rejection of communication as transmission of intended meaning. Regarding the second part of SEC, Searle rejects Derrida’s criticism of Austin’s treatment of “parasitic” speech, arguing this reflects a “research strategy” in Austin and not a “metaphysical exclusion.” He says Derrida mistakes Austin for making normative claims with the term “parasitic,” and is wrong that Austin denied the possibility of quotation.

In 1977, Derrida gave a lengthy reply to Searle in “Limited Inc a b c.” In 1982, Jonathan Culler commented on the Derrida-Searle debate in the chapter on “Meaning and Iterability” in his “On Deconstruction.” In 1983, Searle weighed in with a review of Culler in The NY Review of Books titled “The World Turned Upside Down.”

The final part of this debate was a letter from Derrida to Gerald Graff, where Derrida more directly addressed Searle’s criticisms. This letter is in “Limited Inc,” a 1998 collection of documents related to the debate, as “Afterward: Toward An Ethic of Discussion.”

Required Reading (~150 pages):

• “Limited Inc” by Derrida. ~$20. Contains SEC, a summary of Searle’s reply, “Limited Inc,” “Afterward,” and Q&A. https://amzn.to/2RYmAMr

Optional Readings, for the full debate (~50 pages):

• “Reiterating the Differences” by Searle. Can view (but not download) on Scribd. https://bit.ly/2CCd1Jp. Also see the summary of Searle in “Limited Inc” p.25-28

• “Meaning and Iterability” in Jonathan Culler’s “On Deconstruction” p.110-134 https://bit.ly/2HLGneo

• “The World Turned Upside Down” by Searle, NY Review of Books
https://bit.ly/2HODGsf

Readings in Order:

1972 Derrida, “Signature Event Context”
1977 Searle “Reiterating the Differences”
1977 Derrida, “Limited Inc a b c”
1982 Culler, “Meaning and Iterability”
1983 Searle, “The World Turned Upside Down”
1988 Derrida, “Afterward: Toward An Ethic of Discussion”

Sources:

Videos
• John Ebert on SEC (2 parts) - https://bit.ly/2CxokCO
• Derrida (School of Life) - https://bit.ly/2s0pYXp
• Derrida (Then & Now) - https://bit.ly/2DRlrPa
• Derrida on “American attitude” - https://bit.ly/2MKDFEA
• Searle on “continental obscurantism” - https://bit.ly/2MnGdZk

Readings
• #MeToo and John Searle - https://bit.ly/2APUhGn
• Wiki, “Limited Inc” - https://bit.ly/2MnLksd
• Review, Moati’s “Derrida/Searle” - https://ntrda.me/2FDrtEV
• SEP, Derrida - https://stanford.io/2R0mBuU
• SEP, speech acts - https://stanford.io/2S2yZ1W
• Austin, How to do things with words (book) - https://bit.ly/2HMdsGR

Related topics

You may also like