Past Meetup

PWL #34: Feral Concurrency Control

This Meetup is past

54 people went

Location image of event venue

Details

We will be talking about Peter Bailis' 2015 paper "Feral Concurrency Control.

Abstract

The rise of data-intensive “Web 2.0” Internet services has led to a range of popular new programming frameworks that collectively embody the latest incarnation of the vision of Object-Relational Mapping (ORM) systems, albeit at unprecedented scale. In this work, we empirically investigate modern ORM-backed applications’ use and disuse of database concurrency control mechanisms. Specifically, we focus our study on the common use of feral, or application-level, mechanisms for maintaining database integrity, which, across a range of ORM systems, often take the form of declarative correctness criteria, or invariants. We quantitatively analyze the use of these mechanisms in a range of open source applications written using the Ruby on Rails ORM and find that feral invariants are the most popular means of ensuring integrity (and, by usage, are over 37 times more popular than transactions). We evaluate which of these feral invariants actually ensure integrity (by usage, up to 86.9%) and which—due to concurrency errors and lack of database support—may lead to data corruption (the remainder), which we experimentally quantify. In light of these findings, we present recommendations for database system designers for better supporting these modern ORM programming patterns, thus eliminating their adverse effects on application integrity.

Paper Link

http://www.bailis.org/papers/feral-sigmod2015.pdf

The Morning Paper Discussion

https://blog.acolyer.org/2015/09/04/feral-concurrency-control-an-empirical-investigation-of-modern-application-integrity/

SIGMOD '15 Presentation

https://speakerdeck.com/pbailis/feral-concurrency-control-an-empirical-investigation-of-modern-application-integrity

Caitie McCaffrey's Distributed Sagas Talk

This is what inspired us to discuss the paper:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UTOLRTwOX0

I hope to see you there!