Every Saturday (at 2 pm), Good Games hosts a board game demo. We open a new board game and play it. It costs $7 per person and the winner gets to keep the game.
Update: Not sure if Good Games will provide a new game for us to play – on Wednesday evening, they said it was no longer on. But that doesn't mean we can't go and play our own games. If GG don't provide a game, then we'll still be able to play there for free.
I would still like to have a prize, so my suggestion is that we purchase a game that we'd all like to play at Good Games, split the cost and use it as a prize.
Happy to hear other suggestions.