Book Discussion: Breaking Away by Ryan McMaken

Book Description:
Breaking Away differs from countless other books on secession and decentralization in that it considers examples and benefits of secession and radical decentralization in a much broader historical, geographical, and theoretical context. This book is for anyone interested in how issues of secession and decentralization come up again and again worldwide as communities of human beings seek self-determination, freedom, and economic prosperity. McMaken also examines small states which are often examples of successful cases of secession and radical decentralization.

The reader will come away with a better understanding of how political decentralization continues to be relevant, useful, and important in the modern world.

******UPDATED with Discussion Questions, courtesy of Deepseek******

Here are six discussion questions.
Historical Context and Relevance: McMaken provides a broad historical and geographical overview of secession and decentralization. Which historical examples of secession or decentralization stood out to you, and why? How do these examples challenge or reinforce your understanding of self-determination and freedom?
Small States and Success: The book highlights small states as successful examples of secession and decentralization. What do you think makes small states more effective or prosperous in certain cases? Are there potential downsides to smaller polities that McMaken might be overlooking?
Self-Determination and Identity: McMaken argues that communities often seek secession or decentralization to preserve their cultural, political, or economic identity. Do you think self-determination is a universal right, or are there limits to when and how it should be pursued? How should conflicts between larger states and secessionist movements be resolved?
Economic Prosperity and Decentralization: The book suggests that decentralization can lead to greater economic prosperity. Do you agree with this claim? What evidence or examples from the book or elsewhere support or challenge this idea? How might globalization impact the viability of decentralized or secessionist movements?
Practical Challenges: While McMaken makes a compelling case for secession and decentralization, what practical challenges do you see in implementing these ideas in the modern world? Consider issues like international recognition, military conflict, and economic interdependence.
Broader Implications: McMaken’s work situates secession and decentralization within a broader theoretical framework. How do his ideas align with or differ from other political theories you’ve encountered? Do you think his arguments could gain traction in today’s political climate, and if so, where or how?