Thanks… But No Thanks? Philosophical Puzzles of Gratitude

How has gratitude been understood across philosophical traditions, from ancient virtue ethics to modern moral philosophy? In what ways does gratitude shape our sense of justice, obligation, and community? Is gratitude merely a social expectation, or does it reveal a deeper structure of human interdependence and moral awareness? Can gratitude be considered a virtue in itself, or is it always secondary to other ethical principles such as justice, kindness, or love? How does the experience of gratitude inform or challenge notions of autonomy, dignity, and mutual respect? In a world increasingly marked by transactional relationships, can practising gratitude offer a path toward genuine recognition of others’ intrinsic worth? How might reflecting on gratitude help us reimagine ethical life—not just as duty, but as an ongoing, living exchange of gifts, trust, and appreciation?

---

Alright folks! I want to give a little disclaimer - I’m not claiming to be an expert on the topics we’ll be discussing. My aim is to create a judgment-free zone where attendees can share thoughts and experiences openly.

Let’s approach our conversations with open minds and a sense of curiosity, knowing that we each bring unique backgrounds and perspectives. Please feel encouraged to express yourself in ways that reflect who you are, and let’s all keep in mind that our words carry meaning for those around us. The intention of the meetup is to learn from one another, so if anyone feels uncomfortable or misunderstood at any point, please don’t hesitate to speak up. This way, we can address things together and make sure everyone feels valued and included.

The goal is to explore ideas collaboratively, without promoting any particular viewpoint. We may not find simple answers to the questions we face, but by approaching them with empathy, respect, and inclusivity, we can gain new insights and work towards positive change.