Encryption Discussion: Privacy, Security & Law Efforcement
Details
Last week, the FBI invoked the All Writs Act of 1789 to compel Apple to assist the FBI in accessing encrypted data on the iPhone of the San Bernadino shooters. Apple is refusing, arguing the request is burdensome and that its compliance would undermine the security of all iPhones and set a bad legal precedent worldwide.
Bills banning the sale of smartphones with full-disk encryption (i.e. both Apple iPhones and Android phones) have been proposed in California and New York. Meanwhile in Congress, the the ENCRYPT Act of 2016 aims to prevent states from passing such bans on encrypted phones.
If the FBI has its way, the next iteration of The Communications Assistance to Law Enforcement Act (CALEA) may require messaging app publishers (Twitter, WhatsApp, Facebook, BlackBerry, etc) to incorporate a "backdoor" or wiretap capability. Most security experts, including former NSA director, disagree and claim such a software 'backdoor' would be a boon to criminals and foreign governments.
A bill in New Hampshire aims to explicitly allow public libraries to run Tor exit nodes, enabling users worldwide to use the library's internet connection anonymously, despite the Department of Homeland Security warning that Tor software is used for illegal purposes like drug trafficking and child pornography. At the same time, Tor development is funded mostly by other US Government agencies to enable free speech and free press worldwide.
Encryption protects innocent people from criminals, victims from abusers, criminals from prosecution, foreign adversaries from security agencies and journalists from repressive governments alike.
What are we to do? Bring your own beer.
