HAT Forum

The Humanist Association of Toronto
http://www.humanisttoronto.ca/

Every Saturday we meet on Zoom to discuss a topic decided upon the previous week. These are topics of humanist interest, from a humanist perspective.

The topic of the discussion will be decided in a prior meeting, usually two weeks in advance. This week’s topic is: The Suppression of News. Introduced by Ambrese Montagu.

Media freedom today sits in a paradox: formally, Canada and many other democracies still rank as “free,” yet the practical space for robust, independent journalism is narrowing. In Canada, the Canada Press Freedom Project has documented a sharp rise since 2021 in physical attacks, online harassment, and access denials targeting journalists, especially around COVID‑19 protests and Indigenous land defence actions such as Fairy Creek (2021–22). The 2023 Online News Act triggered Meta’s 2023–24 decision to block news on Facebook and Instagram in Canada, cutting off distribution for many outlets and citizens’ access to verified information. Proposed legislation like Bill C‑63 (the Online Harms Act, 2024) aims to curb hate and abuse but raises concerns about over‑broad content controls and chilling effects. Add to this the chronic collapse of local newsrooms, the use of police exclusion zones, strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs), and political attacks on public broadcasters, and a pattern emerges: suppression is less about overt bans and more about structural, legal, economic, and rhetorical pressures that make critical reporting harder and riskier.
Globally, UNESCO’s 2022–2025 World Trends report records roughly a 10% decline in freedom of expression since 2012, alongside a 63% rise in self‑censorship and a 48% increase in government or oligarchic control over media. Concrete examples abound: the 2018 murder of Jamal Khashoggi in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul; the jailing of Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich in Russia on espionage charges in 2023; the closure of the Algerian daily Liberté in 2022 amid a hostile climate for independent media; the systematic media capture under Viktor Orbán’s government in Hungary since 2010; and repeated raids and pressure on critical outlets in countries such as India and Turkey. These are not isolated abuses but part of a global strategy by governments and aligned economic elites to manage narratives, delegitimize “mainstream media,” and flood the public sphere with disinformation so that truth itself feels unattainable. For humanists, who ground ethics in shared reality and human dignity rather than dogma, this erosion of a common factual world is existential: without trustworthy information, moral deliberation collapses into tribal loyalty and propaganda.
Digital technology has transformed suppression rather than simply reducing it. The internet, encrypted apps, and even the dark web have enabled whistleblowing, samizdat‑style publishing, and cross‑border solidarity; at the same time, AI‑driven surveillance, automated content moderation, and algorithmic throttling give states and platforms unprecedented capacity to shape what is seen, by whom, and when. Freedom House still rates Canada’s internet as “free,” yet notes growing concerns around platform power, data protection, and the collateral damage of content regulation. Globally, authoritarian regimes deploy AI for facial recognition, predictive policing, and real‑time censorship, while troll farms and botnets manufacture consent or chaos on demand. Suppressors include governments (seeking stability or impunity), corporations (protecting profit and reputation), security services (guarding secrets and capabilities), criminal networks (shielding illicit markets), and, increasingly, polarized publics who harass journalists into silence. The humanist response must be to defend epistemic justice: institutions, laws, and cultures that protect the vulnerable, scrutinize the powerful, and keep the informational commons open enough that ordinary people can reason together about their shared fate.
Discussion questions:

1. Power and truth: When governments and corporations control information flows, can citizens still give genuinely informed consent to be governed?
2. Security and secrecy: What does the history of suppression of news, e.g. UAP secrecy and recent American disclosures, tell us about how states balance security, embarrassment, and the public’s right to know?
3. AI as gatekeeper: Should algorithm design and AI moderation be treated as a matter of democratic oversight, like elections or courts?
4. Ethics of exposure: When, if ever, is it ethically justified to suppress information (e.g., to prevent panic, protect privacy, or avoid harm)?
5. Humanist practice: How can humanist communities concretely support threatened journalists and independent media—locally in Canada and globally?

Meet our diverse group, trade perspectives in a free and open forum and learn from others as they learn from you!

BTW: don't be concerned if there are not many RSVP’s. Many HAT members attend regularly but don’t sign up on Meetup. Our online meetings have been very popular with 20-30 attendees.

NOTE: The HAT Forum adheres strictly to the City of Toronto Policy on Non-Discrimination (http://www.the519.org/public/content/policy-files/The519SpaceUsePolicy.pdf)

Our Website (http://www.humanisttoronto.ca/)