Stoicism, Silicon Valley, and Philosophy - Part I

This week we’ll explore the ongoing debate around “Silicon Valley Stoicism”—the modern trend of reducing Stoic philosophy to productivity hacks or stress-management strategies—and contrast it with the ancient Stoic focus on virtue, natural law, and the common good. Our readings present two complementary perspectives: Part 1, by Massimo Pigliucci, critiques the misinterpretation of Stoicism as a self-optimization tool for high achievers; Part 2, by Donald Robertson, deepens the discussion by showing how authentic Stoicism is a moral discipline rooted in character and service rather than ego or endurance.

Both writers respond to Nellie Bowles’ New York Times article “Why Is Silicon Valley So Obsessed With the Virtue of Suffering?” which satirically portrays modern tech Stoics as glorifying hardship for prestige. Pigliucci and Robertson both refute these claims, emphasizing that Stoicism is not about self-inflicted suffering or public toughness. Instead, it teaches that wealth, status, and comfort are “preferred indifferents,” subordinate to the pursuit of wisdom and moral integrity. For the Stoics, true freedom lies in aligning one’s will with reason and nature, as exemplified by Zeno the shipwrecked merchant and Epictetus the freed slave—figures who proved that virtue, not visibility, defines the good life.

We’ll discuss how Stoic natural law—the call to live rationally and justly within the order of nature—differs from Silicon Valley’s instrumental use of Stoic ideas. Can Stoicism be practiced in entrepreneurial or high-pressure environments without losing its moral center? How might the four cardinal virtues—courage, justice, temperance, and wisdom—anchor innovation in ethical purpose?

Next week, we’ll turn directly to Bowles’ article itself, examining key passages and exploring how both Pigliucci and Robertson challenge her portrayal of Stoicism as a culture of performative suffering, clarifying what genuine philosophical endurance truly means.

Reading Material

Silicon Valley style Stoicism
https://docs.google.com/document/d/147odfblWAMckqFt9i5PiYj2e1VefjVzX/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=110947935562396183706&rtpof=true&sd=true

Response: Why is Silicon Valley so Obsessed With the Virtue of Suffering?
https://donaldrobertson.name/2019/03/26/response-why-is-silicon-valley-so-obsessed-with-the-virtue-of-suffering/

Time (USA)
7:00 PM Eastern
6:00 PM Central
5:00 PM Mountain
4:00 PM Pacific
[Convert your time]

Zoom Link
Click to Join Meeting
https://us06web.zoom.us/j/82074238843?pwd=tpSbH2MUvr6gI3KLUxPR2yXmrKna3X.1
Join by Phone
If you do not have a computer with a camera, you can also dial using a phone.

One Tap Mobile
+16469313860,,82074238843#,,,,*313890# US
+13017158592,,82074238843#,,,,*313890# US (Washington DC)

Our group welcomes open-minded, respectful discussion on Stoicism and its relevance to daily life, relationships, and personal growth. We explore how Stoic ideas connect to modern philosophy, psychology, science, and culture with the goal of strengthening our character and living wisely together.

This meeting is free and open to the public.