Are You Overthinking… or Underthinking?

Stoicism teaches us that wisdom begins not with answers, but with self-observation.

In our next session, we’ll explore a provocative article by modern Stoic William B. Irvine that examines how we make choices. He contrasts what he calls “Thinkers,” who optimize their lives through structured reasoning, with “Feelers,” who he suggests may be held back by underthinking.

Our goal isn’t to take this framework at face value, but to use it as a mirror for our own lives.

Through guided discussion, we will explore:

• The Truth & The Gaps: What feels accurate in this framework and what feels incomplete?
• The Trap Detection: Identifying our own decision-making habits and the common traps we fall into.
• The Balance: Where do we overthink, underthink, or avoid thinking altogether?

This will be a constructive, practical session focused on communal wisdom. Whether you currently feel like a "Thinker," a "Feeler," or a bit of both, come prepared to add some new tools to your mental toolkit.

📄 Resources: Are You Guilty of Overthinking? by William B. Irvine