Skip to content

Details

This week looks at the founding promise that all men are equal, who it left out, and where our commitment to equality actually comes from. We will see that the founders saw the gap themselves, that it was named right away, and that a later generation closed it. We end, again, with today. We begin with George Mason, who shows that the founders saw the problem. A few weeks before the Declaration, Mason drafted Virginia’s Declaration of Rights, which opened by saying all men are born equally free and independent. Jefferson borrowed from it. When the draft was read, delegate Robert Carter Nicholas objected that the wording could include enslaved people and might even lead to abolition. The delegates responded by adding “when they enter into a state of society,” and argued that enslaved people had never entered society. Mason held over 100 people in slavery and freed none of them at his death. Eleven years later, at the Constitutional Convention, he opposed the compromise that let the slave trade continue until at least 1808, condemning the trade even though he owned enslaved people. The exclusion wasn’t something the founders forgot. They noticed the problem, debated it, and drafted around it.

Lemuel Haynes shows the gap was named almost immediately, from outside the convention hall. Haynes was a free Black man who served in the Revolution in 1774 and 1775 as a Minute Man and in 1776 as a soldier in the march to Fort Ticonderoga. That same year, at 23, he wrote “Liberty Further Extended.” Instead of a Bible passage, as was customary, he took as his text the Declaration’s line that all men are created equal, and argued that an African has as good a right to liberty as any Englishman. He wasn’t looking back on the Revolution. He was fighting in it and using its own words against it. The essay was never published in his lifetime; a historian found it in a Harvard archive in 1983. Haynes and Mason read the same words the same way. They disagreed about what to do with them.

Finally, Kermit Roosevelt III, a constitutional law professor at the University of Pennsylvania, brings the question to today. In The Nation That Never Was (2022), he argues that equality was not part of the founders’ vision. It was stated in Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address and was the hope of Reconstruction. The Reconstruction Amendments, the Fifteenth among them, changed the constitutional order at its foundation. In Roosevelt’s account, Reconstruction did not fulfill the founding’s ideals but repudiated them, making modern Americans heirs of the people who overthrew that political order. Douglass asked that the founding’s promise be kept. Roosevelt asks something harder: are we preserving the founders’ America, or are we heirs to a different nation, created after the Civil War?

Sources:

George Mason

Lemuel Haynes

Kermit Roosevelt III

Timezones
6:00 AM Pacific (USA),
7:00 AM Mountain (USA),
8:00 AM Central (USA),
9:00 AM Eastern (USA)

About Our Group We welcome open minded, respectful conversation on Stoicism and its relevance to daily life, personal growth, and modern thought. Our discussions connect ancient philosophy with contemporary science, psychology, economics, and culture with the shared aim of cultivating wisdom together. The meeting begins at 9:00 AM Eastern, with dialogue starting promptly at 9:15.

You may also like