Skip to content

Details

This week asks how a country can act with confidence while admitting it might be wrong. We will see that the idea goes back to ancient Rome, that one founder lived it out, mistakes and all, and that an American philosopher explained why it is the only honest way to live. We end with what this means for us. We begin with Cicero, the Roman writer the founders quoted most. He wrote On Duties in 44 BC, the year Julius Caesar was killed, as a letter to his son. Rome was in crisis, and no one knew if the Republic would survive. His main point is simple: our duties come from the roles we play in life, such as citizen, parent, friend, or public official. A year earlier he wrote the Academica, which argues that we can never be completely sure of anything. So we go with what seems most likely to be true and stay open to changing our minds. Cicero knew people would ask how someone full of doubt could tell others what their duties are. His answer: doubt doesn’t stop you from acting. You act on the best answer you have. John Adams admired him deeply. He wrote that no one in history had been a greater statesman and thinker at the same time.

John Adams shows what this looks like in a real life. In 1770, British soldiers shot and killed five people in Boston. The town was furious, and a fair trial seemed unlikely. Adams agreed to defend the soldiers anyway, even though it could have ruined his career. The captain and six soldiers were found not guilty; two were found guilty of a lesser charge. Adams later said it was one of the things he was proudest of. But in 1798, as president, he signed the Alien and Sedition Acts during a scare about war with France. Newspaper editors who criticized the government were arrested. Most historians see this as one of his worst mistakes, and public anger helped Thomas Jefferson defeat him in 1800. Then Adams did something new: he gave up power. He didn’t attend Jefferson’s swearing-in, but he left. It was the first time in American history that power passed peacefully from one party to its rival. Doing the right thing, making a serious mistake, and stepping aside: the whole lesson in one life.

Finally, William James, a Harvard philosopher and psychologist, shows what this means for us. In “The Will to Believe” (1896), he argued that some decisions can’t wait until we have all the facts. Choosing not to decide is still a choice, and it has consequences too. In those moments, it’s fair to act on our best judgment, as long as we keep learning and stay willing to be corrected. A year later, at the unveiling of a Civil War memorial in Boston, he praised what he called civic courage. He said a country is kept safe not by battles but by everyday acts: speaking, writing, and voting thoughtfully, standing up to corruption, and staying respectful toward the other side. Cicero asks us to hold duty and doubt together. James asks something harder: can we act firmly on what we believe, and still admit we might be wrong, in front of people who disagree with us?

Sources:

Cicero

John Adams

William James

Timezones 6:00 AM Pacific (USA), 7:00 AM Mountain (USA), 8:00 AM Central (USA), 9:00 AM Eastern (USA)
About Our Group We welcome open minded, respectful conversation on Stoicism and its relevance to daily life, personal growth, and modern thought. Our discussions connect ancient philosophy with contemporary science, psychology, economics, and culture with the shared aim of cultivating wisdom together. The meeting begins at 9:00 AM Eastern, with dialogue starting promptly at 9:15.

You may also like