Bi-Weekly Discussion - The Implicit Politics of Xmas Movies
Details
This is going to be an online meetup using Zoom. If you've never used Zoom before, don't worry — it's easy to use and free to join.
Here's the link to the event: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86084636311?pwd=OFdrdytKNFVPS1k5R0NUeHVKQjNpZz09
X
***
THE IMPLICIT POLITICS OF CHRISTMAS MOVIES
INTRODUCTION:
In this meetup, we'll analyze some of the characters & plots in Christmas movies, how they've changed over time, and what they can tell us about the social functions of the Christmas holiday. As we'll see, these movies contain common themes derived from a mix of pagan & Christian traditions, but also from 19th-century Christmas stories such as the Brothers Grimm fairy tale "The Elves and the Shoemaker" (1812), E.TA. Hoffman's "The Nutcracker and the Mouse King" (1816), Clement Clarke Moore's poem "A Visit from St. Nicholas" (1823), Charles Dickens' novella "A Christmas Carol" (1843), and Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tale "The Snow Queen" (1844). After the Civil War, Christmas in America gradually became a family-centered holiday with an aura of magic drawn from these Romantic-era fairy tales, and the Catholic St. Nicholas merged with the English "Father Christmas" to become the immortal gift-giving Santa Claus we know today. Other Xmas characters like Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer and Frosty the Snowman came later (in a 1939 story and a 1950 song, respectively.) These precedents established some common themes for Christmas stories like a celebration of childish innocence & wonder, a rejection of selfishness & materialism, a moral obligation to help the less fortunate, the importance of finding true love & forging strong family relationships, the value of forgiveness and reconciliation, and the power of belief in enabling personal transformation.
One of the meta-questions lurking in the background of our discussion will be: "What is a Christmas movie?" For the purposes of this discussion, we'll focus on all genres of films that are set primarily at Christmastime, and for whose plot the holiday has some sort of importance. This means we'll primarily look at fantasy films that engage with Christmas mythology, as well as romantic & family films that focus on relationships over the holidays. We can also consider so-called "Christmas-adjacent movies" that take place over a longer timespan but have key scenes during the holidays, like "Holiday Inn" (1942), "You've Got Mail" (1998), "Bridget Jones's Diary" (2001) and "Rent" (2005), as well as the first "Chronicles of Narnia" film (2005) and the "Harry Potter" series (2001-2011). We may also discuss some Christmas episodes of popular TV shows, although they won't be the focus. Unlike films, Christmas episodes of TV series often have a lower payoff for those who haven't followed the series, and once the series is off the air they become less culturally relevant (unless they're picked up by streaming services & find a new audience).
There are many other films that happen to be set around Christmas but don't include typical holiday themes like "The Thin Man" (1934), "Stalag 17" (1953), "Psycho" (1960), "Lethal Weapon" (1987),"Die Hard" (1989), "Edward Scissorhands" (1990), "Batman Returns" (1992), "The Long Kiss Goodnight" (1996), "L.A. Confidential" (1997), "American Psycho" (2000), "The Ice Harvest" (2005) and "Iron Man 3" (2013), so I don't expect we'll discuss them much, except to note how they avoid or subvert the common Xmas movie tropes, although a few manage to sneak them in. Arguably, films that aren't set at Christmas but have similar themes to traditional holiday films - e.g. "Toy Story" (1995) & its sequels, "Rise of the Guardians" (2013), "Frozen" (2013) & its sequels - could become Christmas films over time if enough people incorporate them into their annual December movie marathons. That's what happened with "The Wizard of Oz" (1939) & "The Sound of Music" (1966). (A similar process turned the songs "Jingle Bells" and "Baby, It's Cold Outside" into Xmas songs even though neither were originally written with the holiday in mind.)
So how should we analyze these Christmas films & shows? As I mentioned in our earlier discussion on horror films back in October, "film theory" began in the early 20th century with a mix of Marxist social analysis and Freudian psychoanalysis. This meant that characters & plot elements were either interpreted in terms of Marxist concepts like class conflict, alienation & false consciousness, or in Freudian terms as signs of repressed sexuality, conflicted feelings towards a mother or father figure, or the fear of death evoked by "uncanny" characters. Since the 1960s-70s, academic film theory has added newer approaches based on Lacanian psychoanalysis, structuralist semiotics, gender studies, and poststructuralist literary theory.
These academic theories tend to assume big priming effects on audiences. Film theorists with left-leaning politics often assume that movies "brainwash" us to accept capitalism, white supremacy, patriarchy, heterosexism, etc, as normative, while conservative film theorists often assume Hollywood is trying to "brainwash" audiences with an anti-religious, anti-family, anti-capitalist message. But these film theories are mostly just armchair psychology & amateur sociology. They typically have no basis in empirical studies with randomized control groups that try to assess how audiences interpret films or whether films change their behavior, so (in my opinion) they're of dubious value. The fact that psychology studies haven't found much effect on violent crime from teens playing violent video games should suggest big priming effects from watching movies are unlikely.
Instead, modern media effects theories suggest that film watching has more subtle effects that are indirect, conditional & transactional - i.e. people seek out different films to satisfy specific desires, and films that don't satisfy those desires are typically either rejected or reinterpreted, quite possibly in a way the director & actors didn't intend. (You can find plenty of conflicting movie reviews that interpreted the same film as depressing & uplifting, pro-capitalist & anti-capitalist, pro-feminist & misogynistic, etc.) Rather than persuading audiences to change their minds, controversial films may play an "agenda setting" role when they become the subject of a public debate, particularly when audiences & critics are divided in their reactions to a film.
We won't adopt a particular academic film theory lens in this discussion, but we will try to interpret Christmas films & Christmas episodes of TV shows as reflections of widespread desires, anxieties & implicit worldviews. This is more justifiable, particularly when the films were blockbusters viewed by many people and their messages were fairly obvious from dialogue in the film, interviews with the director & actors, reviews from big-name film critics, and/or public comments harvested from social media.
Before we start, it may be useful to look at the lists of the highest grossing Christmas movies of all time to get a general sense of what films have been the most succesful in the last 30 years or so. But we have to remember that these numbers aren't adjusted for inflation and so will make older Xmas movies look less impressive, even if - like "White Christmas" in 1954 - they were one of the highest grossing films in the year they were released. Also, the common practice of people rewatching older Xmas films each December has led some films that were box office duds, like "A Christmas Story" (1983) to have a much greater influence today through television's seasonal offerings, as well as video rentals & streaming services. It's also interesting to look at which Christmas movies appear to be the most popular in each state, based on Comparitech's analysis of Google searches in 2021 and Preply's similar analysis for 2022. (Note that only two films among the top 50 highest grossing - the 2017 animated comedy "The Star" and the 2006 live-action drama "The Nativity Story" - deal with the Biblical Nativity story, and neither of them appear to be that popular even in the Bible Belt.)
It's also worth checking out this 2019 article from the Washington Post entitled "We have reached Peak Christmas Movie" which looked at more than a century of movie data and shows how the genre has exploded in the 2000s & 2010s, particularly with new movies being produced for Hallmark, Lifetime & Netflix. At least according to IMDb, there were no major Christmas movies until the 1930s, and in following decades there were only one or two a year, and none in many years. There were no more than five movies with “Christmas” in their IMDb description in any year until 1992, when eight were made, including “The Muppet Christmas Carol.” That was a peak until 2004 brought us 12 Christmas films, including “The Polar Express” and “Christmas With the Kranks.” Then, in recent times, an explosion, with an all-time high in 2015 and 2017, when IMDb shows 32 Christmas movies in each year. Much of this is due to a general increase in all genres of movies, but Christmas movies also increased from less than 0.5% to about 1-3% of the annual movie production.
We can also look at some psychological studies on the effects of watching & re-watching Christmas movies in December, particularly in terms of evoking nostalgia. Dr. Tim Wildschut explains that “Nostalgia compensates for uncomfortable states, for example, people with feelings of meaninglessness or a discontinuity between past and present. What we find in these cases is that nostalgia spontaneously rushes in and counteracts those things. It elevates meaningfulness, connectedness and continuity in the past... It serves to promote emotional equilibrium, homeostasis.”
More specifically to TV shows and movies, the 2012 research paper "The Temporal and Focal Dynamics of Volitional Reconsumption: A Phenomenological Investigation of Repeated Hedonic Experiences", put together by American University’s Cristel Antonia Russell and the University of Arizona’s Sidney Levy, explains that the process of rewatching movies repeatedly often is much more deep-seated than just reliving memories—and is often based on very specific, personal reasons, such as the emotions a film evokes and how we experience it. “The reasoning that people had for their repeat behaviors was far more complex than simply nostalgia,” Levy said of the research. “For people to take time out of their busy lives to do something over and over again, the motivations required were usually deep-seated and poignant.”
We can also look at Pew Research Center & Gallup's polls from the last decade or so to get a sense of Americans' views on the holidays and compare this to the themes we see in Xmas films. While 93% of Americans say they celebrate Christmas, only 55% say they celebrate Christmas as a religious holiday, mirroring the rise in the percentage of Americans who say religion is "not very important" in their life. Overall, 31% of adults say they are bothered at least “some” by the declining emphasis on religion in the way the U.S. commemorates Christmas, including 18% who say they are bothered “a lot” by this. But the remaining two-thirds of the U.S. public either is not bothered by a perceived decline in religion in Christmas or does not believe that the emphasis on the religious elements of Christmas is waning.
RELEVANT MATERIAL FROM PAST MEETUPS:
Back in Dec. 2021, there was a Skeptics discussion entitled "The Origins & Evolution of Xmas". For our purposes here, the most relevant section is the 4th part where they discussed how Christmas changed into a "bourgeois" holiday in the 19th century focused on family get-togethers & heartwarming tales instead of the wilder, drunken celebrations of previous centuries when farmhands were temporarily out of work after the harvest. They also discussed whether there was a "capitalist conspiracy" to encourage the practice of gift-giving to create an annual economic stimulus, or whether it was just an accidental effect of broader social & economic shifts caused by the Industrial Revolution.
Since many of the Christmas movies now considered "classics" were made in the 1940s-50s, it may be worth reviewing the outline from a Braver Angels' discussion in Dec. 2020 on the sociologist Robert Putnam's book "The Upswing: How America Came Together a Century Ago and How We Can Do It Again". Putnam argues that social trust was very low during the Gilded Age in the late 19th century but was rebuilt by progressive reforms and the New Deal, leading to a peak in social trust in the 1950s before it was disrupted by protests over civil rights and the Sexual Revolution in the 1960s, followed by disillusionment and distrust of government in the 1970s due to the loss in the Vietnam War and Watergate.
Back in Dec. 2020, we had a meetup entitled "Thinking About The Holidays" - for our purposes here, the most relevant sections may be the 1st section where we discussed the debates over religious displays on public property and allegedly offensive Christmas songs, and the 3rd section where we discussed how & why the holidays evoke nostalgia & generosity in some people and stress & sadness in others.
The Skeptics had a meetup in Feb. 2020 entitled "Are Generational Theories Bunk?" The 2nd section looked at the "reminiscence bump" that makes us nostalgic for films & music we first saw & heard in our formative years (roughly age 10 to 30). We also talked about how each generation has a unique profile due to a mixing of "personal memories" from things they've personally experienced and "approproated memories" they've learned about from past generations, and these 2 types of memories can coexist in harmony or in tension. This might apply to how audiences interpret films from their youth and films from past eras.
***
DIRECTIONS ON HOW TO PREPARE FOR OUR DISCUSSION:
The videos & articles you see linked below are intended to give you a basic overview of some of the major debates over the social implications of Xmas movies for how Americans think about the holidays. As usual, I certainly don't expect you to read all the articles prior to attending our discussion. The easiest way to prepare for our discussion is to just watch the numbered videos linked under each section - the videos come to about about 59 minutes total. The articles marked with asterisks are just there to supply additional details. You can browse and look at whichever ones you want, but don't worry - we'll cover the stuff you missed in our discussion.
In terms of the discussion format, my general idea is that we'll address the topics in the order presented here. I've listed some questions under each section to stimulate discussion. We'll do our best to address most of them, as well as other questions our members might raise. I figure we'll spend about 30 minutes on each section.
***
I. XMAS MOVIES AS QUASI-RELIGIOUS MORALITY PLAYS & POP PSYCHOLOGY LESSONS:
- WHY AREN'T OVERTLY RELIGIOUS XMAS FILMS MORE SUCCESFUL AT THE BOX OFFICE, CONSIDERING THAT EVEN DESPITE A RECENT DECLINE IN RELIGIOSITY, 64% OF AMERICANS ARE PRACTICING CHRISTIANS & 85% SAY THEY BELIEVE JESUS WAS THE SON OF GOD OR AN IMPORTANT SPIRITUAL TEACHER? IS IT BECAUSE HOLLYWOOD AIMS FOR A WIDER AUDIENCE, OR CHRISTIAN AUDENCIES DISLIKE ADAPTATIONS OF BIBLICAL STORIES THAT ADD MORE ACTION & MORAL COMPLEXITY LIKE "NOAH" & "EXODUS" (2014)? DOES THAT MAKE LOW-BUDGET DIRECT-TO-VIDEO MOVIES THE SAFER BET FOR FILMMAKERS?
- TO WHAT EXTENT IS CHRISTMAS BECOMING A POSTMODERN HOLIDAY, WHERE SECULAR PEOPLE PRETEND TO BELIEVE IN THE SUPERNATURAL FOR A LIMITED TIME BECAUSE THEY DERIVE SOME PLEASURE FROM IT? IS XMAS MOVIE WATCHING A POSTMODERN RELIGIOUS RITUAL, ROUGHLY COMPARABLE TO CHRISTIANS WATCHING PASSION PLAYS BEFORE EASTER?
- HOW DID "IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE" (1946) & "MIRACLE ON 34th STREET" (1947) DRAW UPON ELEMENTS FROM "A CHRISTMAS CAROL", E.G. A SUPERNATURAL AGENT INTERCEDING TO HELP A LOST SOUL AT XMAS? HOW DOES SHIFTING THE SCROOGE-LIKE CHARACTER TO THE ANTAGONIST ROLE & THE BOB CRATCHIT / TINY TIM CHARACTERS TO THE PROTAGONIST ROLE CHANGE THE DYNAMIC?
- WHY IS BELIEF IN SANTA SO IMPORTANT IN FILMS LIKE "MIRACLE ON 34th STREET" (1947 & 1994), "THE YEAR WITHOUT SANTA CLAUS" (1974), "THE SANTA CLAUSE" (1994), "ELF" (2003), "POLAR EXPRESS" (2004), "RISE OF THE GUARDIANS" (2012), "THE CHRISTMAS CHRONICLES" (2018)? IS IT A METAPHOR FOR BELIEF IN GOD, OR MORE AN ANALOGY FOR A VAGUER "CHRISTMAS SPIRIT"?
- ARE MOVIES LIKE THE "GRINCH" ADAPTATIONS (1966, 2000, 2018) BETTER BECAUSE THEY SHOW A PERSONAL TRANSFORMATION WITHOUT A SUPERNATURAL INTERVENTION, BUT RATHER BY WITNESSING THE KINDNESS OF OTHERS & BECOMING INSPIRED?
- WAS THE RISE OF MOVIES WITH GRUMPY ACTION HERO SANTAS LIKE "RISE OF THE GUARDIANS" (2012), "THE CHRISTMAS CHRONICLES" (2018), "FATMAN" (2020) & "VIOLENT NIGHT" (2022) A RESPONSE TO THE MORAL PANIC ABOUT A "WAR ON XMAS" OR JUST PUTTING SANTA IN THE SCROOGE ROLE SO HE CAN BE REDEEMED?
- HAS THE DECLINE IN HOLLYWOOD XMAS MOVIES WITH SUPERNATURAL INTERVENTION THEMES AFTER "ELF" (2003) & "THE POLAR EXPRESS" (2004) BEEN A REFLECTION OF MODERN AUDIENCES BECOMING JADED AND/OR LESS RELIGIOUS, AS JOHN ZUKOWSKI ARGUES? DOES THE TWIST ENDING IN "LAST CHRISTMAS" (2019) OFFER ENOUGH SUBTLETY THAT IT CAN APPEAL TO A MORE SECULAR DEMOGRAPHIC?
- HOW DOES "THE GREEN KNIGHT" (2021) ECHO THEMES FROM "A CHRISTMAS CAROL", WITH A SUPERNATURAL FIGURE TESTING THE PROTAGONIST'S MORAL FIBER ON XMAS DAY BY OFFERING HIM VISIONS OF DIFFERENT WAYS HIS LIFE COULD PLAY OUT BASED ON HIS CHOICES? WHY DID MANY CRITICS CALL IT "POST-CHRISTIAN"? DID ITS JULY RELEASE DATE OBSCURE ITS LINKS TO CLASSIC XMAS STORIES?
- HOW DO TIM BURTON'S "EDWARD SCISSORHANDS" (1990) & "A NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS" (1993) OFFER A GOTHIC TAKE CLASSIC XMAS MOVIE TROPES, LIKE COMPASSION FOR THE LESS FORTUNATE, THE REDEEMING POWER OF LOVE & GRATITUDE FOR WHAT WE HAVE? WHY ARE THEY STILL SO POPULAR TODAY?
- ARE XMAS FILMS THAT ADD HORROR ELEMENTS LIKE "BLACK CHRISTMAS" (1974), "GREMLINS" (1984), "SILENT NIGHT, DEADLY NIGHT" (1984), AND "KRAMPUS" (2015) & THE XMAS EPISODES OF HORROR ANTHOLOGIES BLACK MIRRROR ("WHITE CHRISTMAS" - 2014) AND INTO THE DARK ("POOKA!" - 2018) A SUBVERSION OF THE GENRE, OR ARE THE ANTAGONISTS A DARK REFLECTION OF SANTA THAT PUNISH THE "NAUGHTY"?
- CAN XMAS FILMS REALLY TEACH AUDIENCES ABOUT ASPECTS OF POSITIVE PSYCHOLOGY, AS JEREMY McCARTHY CLAIMS? FOR EXAMPLE, WILL VIEWERS DERIVE THE "GEORGE BAILEY EFFECT" FROM WATCHING "IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE", OR WILL THEY LEARN ABOUT RESILIENCE FROM WATCHING "A CHARLIE BROWN CHRISTMAS"?
1a.) Netflix Film Club, "Take Two: What's the True Meaning of Christmas Movies? Spiritual Transformation & Transcendance vs Everyday Miracles" (video - 17:14 min, listen to 11:40)
*
1b) VOA, "Religious Films: Not All Created Equal" (video - 3:21 min.)
- Russell P. Johnson, "Christmas Movies and the Religious Dimensions of Story Structure"
- Joseph Serwach, "Which 'Miracle on 34th Street' Made You Believe Again?" (Medium)
- Craig McKenzie, "Santa’s Clause: Imagination & Belief in Christmas Fiction" (WeMadeThisNetwork)
- Andy Crump, "The war on Christmas turned Santa Claus into an action star" (Polygon)
- Jeremy McCarthy, "The Positive Psychology of Christmas Stories" (Psych. of Wellbeing)
- S. Brent Rodriquez-Plate, "The psychology behind our love of Christmas movies: Holiday movies offer viewers a glimpse into the world as it could be." (PopSci)
- Emily St. James, “A Charlie Brown Christmas can quote the Bible but not feel like it's preaching - That's the secret to its enduring popularity and beloved status.” (Vox)
- John A. Zukowski, "Hollywood, not the Grinch, ruined Christmas movies by replacing spiritual with mundane" (USA Today)
- Jessica Mason, "Tim Burton Got the Loneliness and Magic of the Holidays" (Mary Sue)
- Emily St. James, "Krampus, the new Christmas horror movie, is undone by one small but fatal flaw" (Vox)
- Darren Mooney, "The Green Knight is this year's best Christmas movie" (Escapist)
- Auguste Meyrat, "‘Spirited’ Falls Flat Because ‘A Christmas Carol’ Doesn’t Work Without Christianity At The Center" (Federalist)
.
II. XMAS MOVIES AS SOCIO-ECONOMIC CRITIQUES:
- WHAT DO "IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE" (1946), "IT HAPPENED ON 5th AVENUE" (1947) & "MIRACLE ON 34th STREET" (1947) SUGGEST ABOUT AMERICAN VIEWS OF CAPITALISM IN THE NEW DEAL ERA?
- ARE MOST XMAS MOVIES - LIKE DICKENS' "A CHRISTMAS CAROL" - TOO RELIANT ON TRYING TO TEMPER CAPITALIST EXCESSES BY URGING RICH PEOPLE TO BE CHARITABLE? OR DO THEY SET UP A FALSE DICHOTOMY BETWEEN GREED & ALTRUISM WHEN IM REALITY ENLIGHTENED SELF-INTEREST ALLOWS THE FREE MARKET TO FUNCTION?
- ARE RANKIN/BASS'S "RUDOLPH" (1964) & "A CHARLIE BROWN CHRISTMAS" (1965) ESCAPIST, OR MEDITATIONS ON DISCRIMINATION & SOCIAL EXCLUSION IN THE 1960s?
- HOW DO "TRADING PLACES" (1983) & "SCROOGED" (1988) REWORK THE THEMES FROM "A CHRISTMAS CAROL"? ARE THEY A CRITIQUE OF REAGAN-ERA CORPORATE GREED? WHAT ABOUT "DIE HARD" (1988) & "AMERICAN PSYCHO" (2000)?
- IS "OFFICE CHRISTMAS PARTY" (2016) AN EFFECTIVE CRITIQUE OF CORPORATISM FOR THE MODERN ERA, OR DOES THE "DEUS EX MACHINA" INNOVATION THAT SAVES THEM FROM LAYOFFS AVOID A SHARPER CRITIQUE?
- HOW DO THE CHEAPER XMAS FILMS MADE BY HALLMARK & NETFLIX IN THE 2010s PORTRAY CORPORATE THREATS TO SMALL TOWN BUSINESSES, ACCORDING TO THE WISECRACK VIDEO & AARON BROWN'S ARTICLE? IS THE TENDENCY TO RESOLVE THESE CONFLICTS WITH ROMANCE - AS IN "YOU'VE GOT MAIL" (1998) - A COP-OUT, OR A GOOD WAY TO SHOW THAT BUSINESS INTERESTS & SMALL TOWN VALUES CAN BE HARMONIZED?
- IS "SANTA INC" (2021) A GOOD WAY OF CRITIQUING PATRIARCHY & CAPITALISM, OR MORE EVIDENCE OF "GO WOKE, GO BROKE"?
- DO XMAS FILMS THAT INCLUDE SOCIO-ECONOMIC CRITIQUES INEVITABLY PROVOKE BACKLASH OR COME OFF AS PREACHING TO THE CHOIR IN OUR CURRENT ERA OF POLITICAL POLARIZATION?
2a) Nerd Writer, "It's A Wonderful Life: Individual vs. Community" (video - 8:52 min, listen to 8:10)
2b) Wisecrack, "Hallmark Movies and The Invention of Christmas" (video - 13:15 min, start at 5:55)
.
- Ben Adams, "Bailey Building and Loan vs. Macy’s Incorporated: The relationship between moral people and moral institutions according to 'Miracle on 34th Street' and 'It’s a Wonderful Life'" (Overthinking It)
- Elizabeth King, "The Chronic Capitalism of Christmas Movies: The way Christmas movies tell it, the generosity of individual tycoons is sufficient to mitigate the harms of class inequality." (PS Mag)
- Michael Levin, "Christmas Movies and Bad Economics" (Mises)
- Aaron Brown, "Netflix Christmas Movies, and Their Appalling Economics" (RCM)
- Tanya Gold, "All I want for Christmas is a film that doesn’t preach capitalism: From The Wizard of Oz to Die Hard, the movies we watch at this time of year have no place for social democracy" (Guardian)
- Blair Davis, "From Rudolph to Charlie Brown, your favorite Christmas cartoons hold political messages: Social status, class struggles, identity politics, capitalism — the themes of these Christmas tales echo those of many a 2020 presidential campaign." (USA Today)
- Mira Fox, "Why did Sarah Silverman and Seth Rogen make a Christmas show [Santa, Inc.] — and why is it so bad?" (Forward)
.
III. XMAS ROM-COMS & SHIFTING ROMANTIC IDEALS:
- WHAT DO THE ROMANCES IN CLASSIC XMAS MOVIES LIKE "HOLIDAY INN" (1942), "MEET ME IN ST. LOUIS" (1944), "CHRISTMAS IN CONNECTICUT" (1945), "A HOLIDAY AFFAIR" (1949) & "WHITE CHRISTMAS" (1954) TELL US ABOUT SEX & GENDER NORMS IN THE 1940s-50s?
- DO MODERN AUDIENCES CORRECTLY PERCEIVE THE "BABY, IT'S COLD OUTSIDE" SKETCH FROM "NEPTUNE'S DAUGHTER" (1949) AS DATE RAPE, OR ARE THEY MISSING SOMETHING ABOUT DATING NORMS IN THE 1940s AND THE ROLE REVERSAL IN THE 2nd VERSION OF THE SONG?
- DID THE AFFAIRS IN XMAS FILMS LIKE "THE APARTMENT" (1960) & "MY NIGHT AT MAUD'S" (1969) APPEAL TO MORE CYNICAL AUDIENCES AMID THE SEXUAL REVOLUTION OF THE 1960s? DOES "THE ICE STORM" (1997) WORK AS A RETROSPECTIVE SUBVERSION OF THESE FILMS - EVEN THOUGH IT'S SET AT THANKSGIVING?
- WHY DID XMAS ROM-COMS EXPLODE IN POPULARITY IN THE 1990s-2000s WITH TITLES LIKE "SLEEPLESS IN SEATTLE" (1993), "YOU'VE GOT MAIL" (1998), "JUST FRIENDS" (2005), "THE HOLIDAY" (2006) & "GHOSTS OF GIRLFRIENDS PAST" (2009)? DO THEIR MEN SHOW MORE SENSITIVITY & LESS "TOXIC MASCULINITY" AND DO THEIR WOMEN SHOW MORE AGENCY & AMBITION THAN IN OLDER FILMS?
- DOES "LOVE ACTUALLY" (2006) CONFUSE LIMERENCE (CRUSHES) WITH LOVE & ENCOURAGE STALKING? WHY DOES IT STILL ATTRACT SO MANY FEMALE FANS? DOES THE STAR-STUDDED CAST, THE PRIME MINISTER REBUFFING A DEAL WITH THE AMERICAN PRESIDENT, AND A DARKER SENSE OF HUMOR MAKE IT MORE APPEALING TO BRITISH AUDIENCES?
- HOW DOES "FROZEN" (2013) CHANGE THE PLOT OF HANS CHRISTIAN ANDERSON'S "SNOW QUEEN" WHERE A GIRL SAVES A BOY FROM AN EVIL SORCERESS & AVOID THE TYPICAL PLOT WHERE A MALE HERO SAVES THE DAMSEL IN DISTRESS? DOES ITS SUCCESS SHOW THAT MODERN AUDIENCES WANT MORE FEMINIST HEROES, DESPITE WHAT CONSERVATIVE CRITICS SAID?
- ARE MOST XMAS ROM-COMS, ESPECIALLY THOSE ON LIFETIME & HALLMARK, MOSTLY JUST A MEANS FOR WIVES & MOTHERS TO TEMPORARILY ESCAPE FROM THE PRESSURES OF SHOPPING & HOUSEHOLD CHORES DURING THE HOLIDAYS? OR DO THEIR PLOTS INDICATE THAT MOST WOMEN SECRETLY LIKE TRADITIONAL GENDER ROLES?
- SHOULD WE CELEBRATE THE RISE OF GAY & LESBIAN XMAS ROM-COMS, LIKE "MAKE THE YULETIDE GAY" (2009), "SEASON OF LOVE" (2019), "THE CHRISTMAS SETUP" (2020), "HAPPIEST SEASON" (2020), "SINGLE ALL THE WAY" (2021), OR DOES IT REPRESENT A COOPTION & TAMING OF QUEER REBELLION FROM HETERO-NORMATIVE RELATIONSHIPS? DOES "CAROL" (2015) WORK BETTER AS A DRAMA ABOUT FORBIDDEN ROMANCE BY SETTING THE PLOT IN THE 1950S?
3a) The Take, "The Hallmark Christmas Movie Craze, Explained" (video - 13:35 min, start at 1:35)
3b) William Tyson-Carlisle, "Disney's FROZEN and Feminism" (video - 9:59 min, start at 1:06)
.
- Kevin Mims, “’White Christmas’ and the Triumphs of the Greatest Generation” (Quillette)
- Caroline Slede, "Celebrate Christmas with the subversive 1940s rom-com that turned gender roles on their head [i.e. 'Christmas in Connecticut']" (AV Club)
- Pat Cerasaro, "Defending 'Baby, It's Cold Outside'" (Onstage)
- Ali Jawetz, "We Need a Reality Check on Unreal Christmas Rom-Coms: It's time to move beyond the twin swaps, the dead spouse who comes back as an angel, the bad blind date, etc., and instead, turn to real-life stories for healthy models of lasting love." (Pop Matters)
- Lynn Yaeger, "Why Are All the Women in Hallmark Holiday Movies Portrayed as Soulless Money Machines?" (Vogue)
- Megan Garber, "The Holiday-Rom-Com Fantasy Has Nothing to Do With Romance: The ultimate Hallmark film is not about finding love. It is about finding relief from the demanding work of Christmas." (Atlantic)
- Caitlyn Flynn, "'Love Actually' Has A Gender Role Problem" (Bustle)
- Belinda Luscombe, "Why Jordan Peterson Thinks Frozen Is Propaganda, But Sleeping Beauty Is Genius" (Time)
- Andrew Court, "Woke wannabe film critics cancel Christmas classics over ‘toxic masculinity’" (NY Post)
- Hans Fiene, "For The LGBT Mob, Lesbian Ads On The Hallmark Channel Are Just The Beginning" (Federalist)
- Stephen G. Adubato, "Gay Hallmark Movie Outs the Farce of 'Christian Values'" (Patheos)
.
IV. XMAS MOVIES & CHANGING VIEWS OF THE AMERICAN FAMILY:
- DID CLASSIC XMAS FILMS LIKE "MEET ME IN ST. LOUIS" (1944), "IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE" (1946), "MIRACLE ON 34th STREET" (1947) & "THE BISHOP'S WIFE" (1947) PORTRAY FAMILY DYNAMICS IN AN IDEALIZED PATRIARCHAL "FATHER KNOWS BEST" LIGHT, OR WERE THEY SKILLFUL AT EXPOSING FAMILY TENSIONS?
- IS THE SHIFT TOWARDS FOCUSING ON DYSFUNCTIONAL FAMILIES AT XMAS THAT WE SEE IN THE '80s-90s WITH "A CHRISTMAS CAROL" (1983), "CHRISTMAS VACATION" (1988), "HOME ALONE" (1990), "THE REF" (1994) & "THE SANTA CLAUSE" (1994) AND CONTINUING INTO THE 2000s-2010s WITH "THE ROYAL TENENBAUMS" (2001), "CHRISTMAS WITH THE KRANKS" (2004), "THE FAMILY STONE" (2005), "FOUR CHRISTMASES" (2008), "LOVE THE COOPERS" (2015) & "WHY HIM?" (2016) A SAD REFLECTION OF THE BREAKDOWN OF THE AMERICAN FAMILY, OR A BETTER WAY TO PORTRAY REALISTIC FAMILY STRUGGLES? IS THERE TYPICALLY AN OPTIMISTIC ASPECT EVEN IN DEPICTIONS OF DYSFUNCTIONAL FAMILIES GATHERING FOR THE HOLIDAYS?
- WHY IS SEXUAL TEMPTATION SO OFTEN PORTRAYED AS A THREAT TO THE FAMILY IN XMAS MOVIES, WHETHER IN A COMEDIC WAY IN "CHRISTMAS VACATION" (1988) OR A TERRIFYING WAY IN "EYES WIDE SHUT" (1999)? DOES THE (USUALLY MALE) PROTAGONIST'S REJECTION OF INFIDELITY PLAY A ROLE IN THE PLOT COMPARABLE TO SCROOGE'S CHANGE OF HEART AND/OR GEORGE BAILEY'S DECISION NOT TO COMMIT SUICIDE?
- TO WHAT EXTENT DO HOLIDAY FILMS REVOLVE AROUND FATHERS & MOTHERS "PROVING THEMSELVES" BY FINDING THE PERFECT PRESENTS FOR THEIR CHILDREN & SPOUSE, PUTTING UP ELABORATE DECORATIONS, COOKING A DELICIOUS FAMILY DINNER, ETC? ARE FILMS LIKE "CHRISTMAS VACATION" (1988), "JINGLE ALL THE WAY" (1996), "DECK THE HALLS" (2006) & "A BAD MOMS CHRISTMAS" (2017) THAT SATIRIZE THIS "KEEPING UP WITH THE JONESES" DYNAMIC BENEFICIAL?
- ARE FILMS LIKE "JINGLE ALL THE WAY" (1996), "THE PREACHER'S WIFE" (1996) & "JACK FROST" (1998), EFFECTIVE AS CAUTIONARY TALES ABOUT THE DANGERS OF MALE WORKAHOLICS NEGLECTING THEIR FAMILIES? ARE THE HALLMARK MOVIES WITH BUSY CAREER WOMEN WHO HAVE TO SLOW DOWN & LEARN "THE TRUE MEANING OF XMAS" THE FEMALE EQUIVALENT?
- DO XMAS MOVIES THAT REVOLVE AROUND GROUPS OF FRIENDS - E.G. "DINER" (1982), "ST. ELMO'S FIRE" (1985), "THE NIGHT BEFORE" (2015), "LET IT SNOW" (2019) - REFLECT AN INCREASING IMPORTANCE OF THE "CHOSEN FAMILY" AT CHRISTMAS? IS THIS A WAY OF COMPENSATING FOR BREAKDOWN OF THE TRADITIONAL FAMILY, A SIGN OF ADOLESCENCE EXTENDING INTO PEOPLE'S 20s, OR A REFLECTION OF NOSTALGIA FOR COLLEGE FRIENDSHIPS? HOW DOES "RENT" (2005) SHOWCASE THE IMPORTANCE OF "CHOSEN FAMILY" FOR LGBT PEOPLE AROUND XMAS? DO "LESS THAN ZERO" (1987) & "RULES OF ATTRACTION" (2002) BELONG TO THE OF THIS GENRE, EVEN THOUGH THEY'RE FAR MORE CYNICAL?
- ARE AFRICAN-AMERICAN XMAS MOVIES LIKE "THE PREACHER'S WIFE" (1996), "EBONY SCROOGE" (2000), "THE BEST MAN HOLIDAY" (2013) & "ALMOST CHRISTMAS" (2016) TOO ASPIRATIONAL BY FOCUSING ON THE FESTIVITIES OF THE MIDDLE & UPPER-MIDDLE CLASS? ARE FILMS LIKE "THE PERFECT HOLIDAY" (2007),"THIS CHRISTMAS" (2007) & "A MADEA CHRISTMAS" (2013) - ALL OF WHICH FEATURE SINGLE-PARENT FAMILIES - AND XMAS EPISODES OF TV SERIES LIKE "FAMILY MATTERS" (1990-1998) & "EVERYBODY HATES CHRIS" (2005-2008) WHICH FEATURE BLUE-COLLAR FAMILIES MORE RELATEABLE?
4a) David Jay Willis, "How to Write a Christmas Movie" (video - 6:22 min.)
4b) The Take, "The Dysfunctional Family Onscreen - The New Normal” (video - 22:32 min, listen to 2:30)
.
- John A. Zukowski, "Christmas on the Screen - Chap. 10: The Third Wave - Embracing Materialism and Accepting Dysfunctional Families"
- Angelica Florio, "How Christmas Movies Swap Gender Narratives: ’Tis the Season for Men to Prove Themselves as Dads" (Medium)
- Susan Wloszczyna, "We Like our Christmas Films Wrapped in Dysfunction: 'Four Christmases' continues tradition made by films like 'Christmas Vacation.'" (ABC)
- David Ehrlich, "Why ‘Eyes Wide Shut’ Is a Bizarro Holiday Classic: Stanley Kubrick’s final movie is filled with orgies and nightmares — and makes for a great Christmas movie" (Rolling Stone)
- Amanda Marcotte, "Hallmark movies are fascist propaganda" (Salon)
- Katya Sedgwick, "No, Hallmark Movies Are Not ‘Fascist Propaganda’" (Federalist)
- Alicia Adejobi, "Black Christmas movies and the importance of positive representation from the stars themselves" (Metro UK)
- Sassafras's Lowrey, "On 'Coco,' 'Olaf's Frozen Adventure' And Chosen Family At The Holidays" (HuffPost)
- Britt Julious, "Who Are Christmas Movies For? As more streaming channels embrace the craze for Christmas movies, they're caught between an audience that cheers more inclusive representations of the holidays and viewers who take a narrow view of what makes a family." (Harpers)
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
