Skip to content

Details

This is going to be an online meetup using Zoom. If you've never used Zoom before, don't worry — it's easy to use and free to join.

Click on the Zoom link below at the scheduled date/time to join the discussion...

***

***

THE IMPLICIT POLITICS OF WESTERNS IN THE 21st CENTURY

INTRODUCTION:

As I mentioned earlier this year, I plan to occasionally take a break from the quantitative, social science topics we usually cover in this meetup and focus instead on more qualitative types of pop culture analysis. And since we're coming up on Thanksgiving when there's often a buzz around political topics related to the colonization of America & its effects today, I figured we could look at 21st-century western films & TV shows, along with some iconic films & TV shows from the 1990s that paved the way for the genre's rebirth after its "death" in the 1970s amid a broader disillusionment after Vietnam & Watergate. As we'll see, this western revival since the '90s has mostly been driven by mid-budget movies & prestige TV shows from a small number of directors who appreciate & understand the western genre (Clint Eastwood, Kevin Costner, the Coen brothers, Quentin Tarantino & Robert Rodriguez, David Milch, Taylor Sheridan).

There's a few questions worth considering before we dive into this topic:

(1) How should we define "westerns"? Genres tend to have fuzzy edges, but for this discussion, we're talking about movies & TV shows set in the wilderness & frontier settlements of the "Old West" during the 19th century. These stories typically depicted the West as an almost lawless region populated with a mix of cowboys, pioneers, railroad workers, miners, gamblers, prostitutes, etc., all seeking their fortune or just trying to survive amidst the harsh environment and a rogue's gallery of rustlers, bank robbers, Mexican bandits, and Indian war parties. We'll also be discussing "neo-westerns" which are stories set in the modern-day - typically, though not always, in the rural West - which contain many of the same images, characters & themes as classic westerns and often portray the difficulties of life on farms, ranches, Indian reservations, and Mexican border towns. We'll also cover "weird westerns" which combine aspects of the classic western genre with science fiction, fantasy or horror. This could merely mean putting monsters, magic or steampunk gadgets into a Wild West setting, or it could mean transposing the western characters & tropes into a post-apocalyptic world, frontier settlements on other planets, a fantasy setting with gunslingers, a virtual reality simulation, etc.

All of these genres can overlap with "revisionist westerns" that subvert the tropes of the traditional westerns in various ways, e.g. blurring the line between heroes & villains, focusing more on psychology than action, or replacing the straight white male cowboy with a gay, non-white or female protagonist. Another subgenre that subverts the tropes of traditional westerns are "parody westerns" which inject comedy into the story with an inept or wisecracking protagonist, historical anachronisms, musical interludes, ridiculously exaggerated gunfights, etc.

* Note: Since we're focused on the American political subtext of these films, we won't address westerns with Australian, Asian & European settings.

(2) How can westerns possibly relate to contemporary politics? Some of these stories may be consciously intended by their authors & directors to be metaphors for contemporary political issues, such as debates about war, religion, capitalism, gender, race, etc. However, even westerns that focus more on action & adventure still have an implicit morality and arguably connect more with our deeper psychology, e.g. themes of exploration, conquest, justice, freedom, rugged individualism, and American identity. One can argue that these archetypal stories are "implicitly political" since politics is downstream from our deeper intuitions about ethics, aesthetics & meaning.

(3) Can we infer anything about the general public's underlying beliefs by looking at box office receipts for western films and Nielsen ratings for western TV shows? The general assumption we'll make is that the larger the audience of a film or TV show, the more it connected with people on an emotional level. This doesn't necessarily mean the audience agreed with the director's intended message, but it suggests something spoke to them - even if it was unintended. However, some films with a weak message may have still attracted large audiences due to the star power of some A-list actors and impressive special effects. Other films with a stronger message may have flopped merely due to bad timing in their release date or some bad editing that got fixed with a director's cut, so we may want to look at streaming numbers for older films & TV shows that have reemerged as "cult classics", as well as western films that were critically acclaimed despite their mediocre ticket sales.

(4) Given that audience reactions to films & TV shows and fan theories can vary quite a bit even among those who saw the exact same story, how can we determine which messages the audience took away from a particular work of fiction? This is the hardest question to adequately answer, particularly because I was unable to find empirical studies that delve into the demographics of who watches westerns today, even as 'Yellowstone' became the most-watched TV show last year. The best analysis I could find came from Parrot Analytics which suggested that the rise in TV westerns is being driven by consumer demand.

We should note that since social scientists don't typically run randomized control trials with movies, we're often left with a "chicken & egg problem" - i.e. it's often not clear whether watching westerns changed people's minds, or whether specific types of people tend to prefer westerns. In many cases, we'll have to make educated guesses about audience reactions by extrapolating from reviews by journalists & bloggers and online discussions. We should probably keep our opinions on the social effects of movies & TV shows somewhat agnostic until we've got better empirical studies -- but that doesn't mean we can't have some fun speculating until then!

RELEVANT MATERIAL FROM PAST MEETUPS:

Since we'll be discussing the conflicts between sheriffs & outlaws in classic westerns & revisionist neo-westerns, it may be good to review a meetup we had back in August on "The Implicit Politics of Police & Crime Dramas". We discussed how these shows influence our views of crime & law enforcement, as well as whether the police, courts & prison system are seen as fair or corrupt. We also discussed theories about why left-leaning audiences tend to dislike vigilantes but like anti-heroes, whereas the reverse is true for conservative audiences. These law & order themes are also common in westerns with a sheriff or outlaw protagonist, as well as in shows that combine aspects of a neo-noir crime drama and a neo-western (e.g. "Breaking Bad").

Since we'll be discussing "weird westerns", it may be useful to refer back to a meetup we had in May entitled "The Implicit Politics of Sci-Fi". In the 1st section, we looked at the ways some sci-fi films like "Star Wars" revolve around rebels fighting against an authoritarian gov't, while others (esp. post-apocalyptic films) showcase the struggle to survive in a lawless environment. In this meetup, we'll discuss the way in which western plots use a struggle against the law or against chaos -- or both. We also discussed the debates about the "white savior" and "noble savage" tropes in sci-fi movies like "Avatar" and Dune", and there's a lot of similarities with westerns that are sympathetic to Native Americans.

In May, Braver Angels hosted a debate entitled "Does Society Need Male Aggression?" They discussed whether modern society still needs the controversial elements of masculinity—the appetite for risk, comfort with physical danger, and aggression that can lead to violence or to taking charge in a crisis. The discussion centered around different visions of what healthy masculinity looks like and whether aggression can be part of being a good man. This is a major theme of westerns, which we'll address in the 1st section.

Back in May, we had a meetup entitled "How Does the American West Affect Our Politics?" and in the introduction we noted that the historian Frederick Jackson Turner's "Frontier thesis" claimed that American democracy was uniquely shaped by the American frontier. He thought the process of westward expansion continually renewed the sense of liberty in the settlers, and he also stressed the effects on American culture: rugged individualism, a sense of "Manifest Destiny", a disdain for high culture, and the use of violence. This is relevant here because these are all common motifs in Western films.

***

DIRECTIONS ON HOW TO PREPARE FOR OUR DISCUSSION:

The videos & articles you see linked below are intended to give you a basic overview of some of the different interpretations of the implicit political themes & social messages behind western films/shows in the 21st century. As usual, I certainly don't expect you to read all the articles prior to attending our discussion. The easiest way to prepare for our discussion is to just watch the numbered videos linked under each section - the videos come to about about 69 minutes total. (If you're pressed for time, just watch the 1st video in each section, which comes to 41 minutes total.) The articles marked with asterisks are just there to supply additional details. You can browse and look at whichever ones you want, but don't worry - we'll cover the stuff you missed in our discussion.

In terms of the discussion format, my general idea is that we'll address the topics in the order presented here. I've listed some questions under each section to stimulate discussion. We'll do our best to address most of them, as well as whatever other questions our members raise. I figure we'll spend about 30 minutes on each section.

***

I. WHITE MALE PROTAGONISTS IN CLASSICAL & SPAGHETTI WESTERNS (1940-1980) VS. THE REVISIONIST ERA (1990-TODAY):

  • TO WHAT EXTENT DID BABY BOOMER MEN MODEL THEMSELVES OFF THE COWBOYS & SHERIFFS IN THE WESTERNS OF THEIR YOUTH? IS THIS LESS APPLICABLE TO MILLENNIALS & GEN-Z MEN, WHO MOSTLY GREW UP WATCHING FANTASY & SUPERHEROES?
  • DID THE WESTERNS OF THE 1940s-50s REPRESENT THE CONFIDENCE & SELF-RIGHTEOUSNESS OF POST-WW2 AMERICA? DID THEIR DARKER ELEMENTS HELP VETERANS PROCESS THEIR WAR TRAUMA THROUGH A FICTIONAL PORTRAYAL OF "HOW THE WEST WAS WON" THRU VIOLENCE?
  • DID THE ANTI-HEROES OF THE SPAGHETTI WESTERNS OF THE LATE 1960s-70s REFLECT A GROWING CYNICISM CAUSED BY VIETNAM & WATERGATE? WERE THESE ANTI-HEROES ANALOGOUS TO THE HIPPIES OR A REACTION AGAINST THEM & PROTO-TYPES OF THE "AVENGER" CHARACTERS CLINT EASTWOOD & CHARLES BRONSON PLAYED IN THE CRIME DRAMAS OF THE 1970s?
    *DOES CASTING THE MALE PROTAGONIST IN A MENTOR & PROTECTOR ROLE IN MODERN WESTERNS LIKE "TRUE GRIT", "CRY MACHO", "CONCRETE COWBOYS" & "THE MANDALORIAN" REFLECT A MODERN DESIRE FOR A SHIFT IN MALE ROLES?
  • DO THE TRAGIC "OLD GUNSLINGER" CHARACTERS IN MODERN WESTERNS LIKE "UNFORGIVEN" (1992), "NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN" (2007), "LOGAN" (2017) "YELLOWSTONE" & ITS SPINOFFS REPRESENT A SUBVERSION OF THE CLASSICAL MALE HERO ARCHETYPE, OR NOSTALGIA FOR IT?
  • DO THE GAY COWBOYS IN "BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN" (2005), "POWER OF THE DOG" (2021) & "STRANGE WAY OF LIFE" REPRESENT A SUBVERSION OF THE CLASSICAL MALE HERO ARCHETYPE, OR ONLY IF YOU ASSUME GAY MEN CAN'T BE MASCULINE OR HEROIC? DO THEY FALL PREY TO THE "BURY YOUR GAYS" TROPE BY KILLING ONE OF THE LOVERS?

1a) Andrew Klavan, "The Evolution of Masculinity in Film" - (video - 18:20 min, listen to 12:30)
.
1b) Fandor, "No Country for Old Tropes: On Genre Subversion in the Western" (video - 6:07 min)
.

II. FEMALE CHARACTERS IN WESTERNS (1990s-2020s):

  • TO WHAT EXTENT DID 'DR. QUINN, MEDICINE WOMAN' REFLECT MODERATE WHITE FEMINISM OF THE CLINTON ERA? HOW DID JANE SEYMOUR'S CHARACTER DIFFER FROM THE FEMALE GUNSLINGER PLAYED BY SHARON STONE IN 'THE QUICK & THE DEAD' (1995)?
  • DO WHAT EXTENT DO THE FEMALE CHARACTERS IN MODERN WESTERNS LIKE 'FIREFLY', 'DEADWOOD', 'JUSTIFIED', 'WESTWORLD' & 'YELLOWSTONE' FALL INTO THE TYPICAL BINARY STEREOTYPES OF THE CHASTE "DAMSEL IN DISTRESS" OR "FALLEN WOMAN" OF OLDER WESTERNS?
  • DO THE FEMALE BRAWLERS & GUNSLINGERS IN MODERN WESTERNS REPRESENT THE SORT OF "STRONG FEMALE CHARACTER" THAT FEMINISTS SHOULD CELEBRATE, OR A MISTAKEN WAY OF BUYING INTO "TOXIC MASCULINITY"?
  • DO THE STRONG ASIAN FEMALE CHARACTERS OF THE SERIES "WARRIOR" REPRESENT A MAJOR ADVANCE FROM THE HELPLESS "CHINA DOLLS" IN OLDER WESTERNS LIKE "YOUNG GUNS" (1988) & "BROKEN TRAIL" (2006), OR IS THIS JUST A REBOOT OF THE OLD "DRAGON LADY" TROPE?
  • DOES THE DECLINING FAN INTEREST IN MONICA, THE NATIVE AMERICAN ACTIVIST IN 'YELLOSTONE', SHOW THE DANGER OF THE "PERPETUAL VICTIM" TROPE, PARTICULARLY FOR NATIVE AMERICAN WOMEN?

2a) Anita Sarkeesian, "True Grit, Mattie Ross and Feminism?" (video - 6:30 min.)
.
2b) CBS, "Thandie Newton on 'Westworld,' character's awakening and nudity" (video - 4:31 min.)
.
2c) Looper, "The Yellowstone Character Fans Simply Can't Stand Anymore [i.e. Monica]" (video - 6:19 min, start at 3:01)
.

III. NATIVE AMERICAN CHARACTERS IN WESTERNS (1990s-2020s):

  • TO WHAT EXTENT DID "DANCES WITH WOLVES" (1990), "LAST OF THE MOHICANS" (1992) & "THUNDERHEART" (1993) REPRESENT A WATERSHED FOR NATIVE AMERICAN REPRESENTATION IN WESTERNS? IN RETROSPECT, DO THEY FALL PREY TO THE "NOBLE SAVAGE" & "WHITE SAVIOR" TROPES? DID WE SEE A MORE NUANCED PORTRAYAL IN "HOSTILES" (2017) & THE SERIES "YELLOWSTONE", BY AVOIDING A WHITE PROTAGONIST THAT "GOES NATIVE" & GIVING THE NATIVE AMERICAN CHARACTERS MORE AGENCY?
  • IS THE TENDENCY FOR NATIVE AMERICAN CHARACTERS TO BE PLAYED BY EURASIAN ACTORS A PROBLEM?
  • SHOULD FILMS LIKE "THE MISSING" (2003) & "BONE TOMAHAWK" (2015) BE CONDEMNED FOR REVIVING THE "BLOODTHIRSTY SAVAGE" STEREOTYPE?
  • DOES TAYLOR SHERIDAN DESERVE CREDIT DESERVE CREDIT FOR CALLING ATTENTION TO THE PLIGHT OF MISSING & MURDERED NATIVE AMERICAN WOMEN WITH HIS FILM "WIND RIVER" (2017) & IN HIS SERIES "YELLOWSTONE"?
  • IS THE PORTRAYAL OF THE INDIAN MASSACRES IN FILMS LIKE "BURY MY HEART AT WOUNDED KNEE" (2007) & "KILLERS OF THE FLOWER MOON" (2023) A NECESSARY WAY TO FORCE AMERICANS TO RECKON WITH THE SINS OF THE PAST OR JUST "TRAUMA PORN" THAT DWELLS TOO MUCH ON THE SUFFERING OF NATIVE AMERICANS?

3a) Stuart Fernie, "Reflections on and analysis of 'Dances With Wolves'" (video - 13:46 min.)
.
3b) Tom van Der Linden, "Hostiles and Wind River – America's Unresolved Grief" (video - 7:00 min.)
.

IV. BLACK, MEXICAN & ASIAN CHARACTERS IN WESTERNS (1990s-2020s):

  • IN RETROSPECT, WERE NON-WHITE HEROES OF WESTERNS LIKE "POSSE" (1993), "ZORRO" (1998), "SHANGHAI NOON" (1998) & "WILD, WILD WEST" (2000) GROUND-BREAKING? DID THEY GIVE VIEWERS ANY INSIGHT INTO THE EXPERIENCES OF EX-SLAVES, MEXICANS & CHINESE IMMIGRANTS IN THE OLD WEST, OR MERELY A RACE-SWAPPED WHITE COWBOY?
  • HOW DOES ANTONIO BANDERAS'S CHARACTER IN ROBERT RODRIGUEZ'S MARIACHI TRILOGY & HIS FEUD WITH A DRUG KINGPIN COMPARE TO THE GRITTIER ROLES THAT BENECIO DEL TORO & MICHAEL MANDO PLAYED THIS SORT OF ROLE IN "SICARIO" (2015) AND "BETTER CALL SAUL" (2015-22)?
  • WHY DO SO MANY NEO-WESTERNS STEREOTYPE MEXICANS AS DRUG CARTEL MEMBERS? IS THIS A BACKSLIDE INTO PORTRAYING MOST MEXICANS IN CLASSIC WESTERNS AS BANDITS?
  • TO WHAT EXTENT DO "MACHETE" (2010), "DJANGO UNCHAINED" (2012) & THE CINEMAX SERIES "WARRIOR" (2019) TAP INTO REVENGE FANTASIES FOR WHITE OPPRESSION IN AMERICA'S PAST? HOW DO WHITE AUDIENCES PROCESS THIS?
  • HOW DOES "CONCRETE COWBOY" (2020) CONTRAST THE OLDER MALE ROLE MODEL OF THE BLACK COWBOY/SHERIFF WITH THE MODERN GANGSTER? IS THIS ALSO WHAT "THE HARDER THEY FALL" (2021) & "LAWMAN: BASS REEVES" (2023) ARE IMPLICITLY DOING?
  • DOES THE MULTI-RACIAL CAST OF THE REMAKE OF "THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN" (2017) REPRESENT A WAY TO PROMOTE RACIAL RECONCILIATION, OR DOES THE INCLUSION OF ETHAN HAWKE'S EX-CONFEDERATE SOLDIER SEEM TOO OUT OF PLACE? DID "HELL ON WHEELS" DO A BETTER JOB DEPICTING RACE RELATIONS IN THE OLD WEST, EVEN AS IT TOO HAD AN EX-CONFEDERATE AS ITS MAIN CHARACTER?

4a) The Writer's View, "Django: Unchained - How Tarantino Handles Race" (video - 7:41 min.)
.
4b) KXAN, "'Machete' to open amid criticism" (video - 2:47 min.)
.
4c) Max, "Becoming Warrior - Part 5: The Warrior" (video - 6:06 min.)
.

.............................................................................................................

Related topics

Books and Movies Discussions
Native Americans
American History
Politics
Crime Fiction

You may also like