Skip to content

Details

This is going to be an online meetup using Zoom. If you've never used Zoom before, don't worry — it's easy to use and free to join.

Click on the link above at the scheduled date/time to log in...

***

***

WHAT ARE THE POLITICAL IMPLICATIONS OF ADVANCES IN HUMAN GENETICS THAT REINFORCE (OR CHALLENGE) HEREDITARIANISM?

INTRODUCTION:

This meetup will discuss the political implications of "hereditarianism" - i.e. a school of thought in the social sciences asserting that genetics and heredity play a primary role in determining human behavior and explaining differences. It's often contrasted with "environmentalism" - i.e. a school of thought in the social sciences that asserts that social, cultural, economic, and physical surroundings play the dominant role in determining human behavior and explaining differences. We'll assess the extent to which hereditarian arguments have been reinforced or challenged by recent advances in human genetics, such as "Genome-Wide Association Studies" (GWAS) and the resulting "polygenic risk scores" (PRS) that estimate a person's inherited genetic liability to a specific trait by combining the cumulative, small effects of hundreds to millions of genetic variants. Initially, an individual's PRS was mostly used to estimate risks of developing a hereditary disease, but advances in the field of "behavioral genetics" have begun to identify complexes of genes that influence intelligence, personality traits, sexual orientation, mental health, and antisocial behavior.

With the demise of the American eugenics movement after the revelations of Nazi atrocities in WW2, conservatives and progressives have mostly debated social issues based on different assumptions about the effects of our environment, i.e. parental upbringing, educational methods, peer influences, media effects, economic incentives, the legal system, etc. However, the return of hereditarianism thanks to twin studies, adoption studies, psychometrics and behavioral genetics presents problems for both sides by challenging the extent to which their proposed social interventions can influence traits or behaviors that are highly influenced by our genes.

For example, conservatives may be forced to accept that some people are naturally inclined to be same-sex attracted or gender non-conforming, that strict parenting & religious education don't provide many of their proposed benefits, and a lot of people who sink into poverty & crime are not just freely choosing to be lazy or violent. Conversely, progressives may be forced to accept that some people are naturally less intelligent or more inclined to violence, that gentle parenting & DEI trainings don't provide many of their proposed benefits, and that poverty & crime are not just the negative effects of discrimination and underfunded social programs. We may find that once the more extreme forms of material privation & social exclusion are removed, that most social interventions begin to run into diminishing returns and produce unintended consequences. Or with more insight into our innate strengths & weaknesses, we may discover better types of social interventions that nip potential problems in the bud and nurture our hidden talents.

Of course, as we'll see, complex social phenomena are hardly every the product of 100% nature or 100% nurture - rather, many cognitive & behavioral traits appear to be somewhere between 30% and 70% genetic. Culturally-specific aspects of a person's identity like a person's native language, religious denomination, or political affiliation are 100% environmental, although they are all affected by a person's verbal fluency, religiosity, and inclination to altruism which do show a genetic influence. Behavioral genetics still finds that many environmental factors play a role in how a person's innate tendencies manifest, for good or ill. Research also shows that it's often difficult to disentangle genetic & environmental factors due to "epigenetics" and "gene–environment correlation".

This topic seemed especially timely due to two things that happened over the summer... Back in July, the neuroscientist-cum-New Atheist-cum controversial podcaster Sam Harris had the geneticist Kathryn Paige Harden on his podcast to discuss her new book Original Sin (2026). They also discussed her perspective on the 2017 controversy over Sam Harris having the political scientist Charles Murray on his podcast to rehash the race-IQ debate from Murray's infamous book The Bell Curve (1994, co-authored with the psychologist Richard Herrnstein) and Murray's deplatforming at Middlebury College in March 2017. At the time, Harden had coauthored a Vox article criticizing Murray's claims and taking Harris to task for platforming him, but she later appeared on Harris's podcast in July 2020 to hash out their differences.

As Sam Harris noted in their most recent podcast discussion this summer, despite her past criticisms of Charles Murray's claims about the racial IQ gap & his policy conclusions, Harden faced left-wing accusations of promoting eugenics and of being akin to "Charles Murray in a skirt" for her 2021 book The Genetic Lottery. This is despite the fact that her book explained some of the more recent findings emerging from behavioral genetics and then tried to harmonize them with her progressive political principles like equal opportunity and compassion for the less fortunate.

Also in July, the Ghent University philosophy professor Nathan Cofnas published an article on his Substack entitled "DEI Fraud and Cover-Up at Cambridge" that alleged that Cambridge University sociologist Jason Arday had committed multiple acts of academic fraud. Arday had in 2023 become the youngest black professor in the University's history. Cofnas wrote that he had run Arday's doctoral thesis through plagiarism detection software and found that "many passages are lifted with minimal editing, sometimes retaining copy-editing mistakes from the original source". He also cast doubt on some other dubious claims Arday had made about his life, like not speaking until age 11, being unable to read & write until age 18, but later overcoming these deficits to become not only a top Oxford scholar but also an ultramarathoner who ran 300 miles in 3 days (close to the world record). By August, Cofnas's allegations were followed by reports in major British media outlets. Arday initially denied the accusations but later resigned as a result of the scandal, and then was found dead at his London home a few days later from an apparent suicide.

Nathan Cofnas's allegations were especially controversial because he describes himself as a "race realist" and had been involved in a controversy in 2024 over a Substack post entitled "A Guide for the Hereditarian Revolution" where he said that without affirmative action black people "would disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment", which led to his firing from Emmanuel College at Cambridge. Because of the renewed controversy, Cofnas's current employer Ghent University suspended him, only allowing him to work remotely and stripping him of his teaching position while they undertake an investigation for academic misconduct. In the mean time, Nathan Cofnas has appeared on the podcasts of several heterodox black intellectuals like Coleman Hughes and Glenn Loury & John McWhorter to discuss & debate the implications of his research.

So what should we make of all this, particularly the underlying arguments about the recent advances in behavioral genetics and what they tell us about the "nature vs nurture" debate that's connected to almost every discussion of social problems? Do they shed any light on our ongoing debates over the effects of racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination? That's what this meetup will aim to evaluate.

In the 1st section, we'll review Sam Harris's 2017 podcast discussion with Charles Murray, his subsequent debate in 2018 with Vox editor Ezra Klein, and how this opened up a broader debate over the implications of genetics research turning into modern-day "race science" or "eugenics" that could reverse all the societal gains of the Civil Rights era.

In the 2nd section, we'll review some of the claims made on the "hereditarian right", focusing on Charles Murray's 2021 book Facing Reality: Two Truths About Race in America and Nathan Cofnas's arguments in his Substack article, "A Guide to the Hereditarian Revolution", about why the taboo on genetic explanations for racial inequality props up "wokeness" - i.e. the idea that racial inequality stems purely from present-day discrimination and the legacy of historic injustice.

In the 3rd section, we'll review some of the claims made on the "hereditarian left", focusing on Kathryn Paige Harden's book The Genetic Lottery: Why DNA Matters for Social Justice (2021) and Original Sin: On the Genetics of Vice, the Problem of Blame, and the Future of Forgiveness (2026), along with Freddie deBoer's book The Cult of Smart: How Our Broken Education System Perpetuates Social Injustice (2020).

In the 4th section, we'll look at some parallels between the 1997 science-fiction film Gattaca and the real-world implications of recent advances in genome-wide association studies (GWAS) that could enable genomic profiling that can be used in various ways, perhaps even enabling "designer babies" when paired with IVF.

WHAT'S THE DISTRIBUTION OF OPINION AMONG EXPERTS ON PSYCHOMETRICS & BEHAVIORAL GENETICS?

As usual, I want to ground our discussion by referring to the current distribution of experts opinions on the "nature vs nurture" debates, and that means looking at polls of experts and highly-cited literature reviews coming the fields of psychometrics and behavioral genetics. We may also refer to introductory concepts found in textbooks that appear to be generally accepted, but as you can see from the 3rd article below they can be too simplistic or even misleading. Unfortunately, a lot of the surveys and papers I wanted to examine are stuck behind paywalls, but I did find several good sources that summarize some major concepts and indicate levels of consensus:

I. Eric Turkheimer, "Three Laws of Behavioral Genetics and What They Mean" (Oct. 2000):
* First Law: All human behavioral traits are heritable. Genetic differences account for a measurable portion of variation in psychological traits like intelligence and personality
* Second Law: The effect of being raised in the same family is smaller than the effect of genes. Shared home environment has less long-term influence on behavioral differences than genetic inheritance
* Third Law: A substantial portion of the variation in complex human behavioral traits is not accounted for by the effects of genes or families. This remaining variance is attributed to the "non-shared environment"—unique, individual experiences
NOTE: Christopher Chabris has proposed a "Fourth Law" - i.e. “A typical human behavioral trait is associated with very many genetic variants, each of which accounts for a very small percentage of the behavioral variability.”

II. Robert Plomin, et al., "Top 10 Replicated Findings from Behavioral Genetics" (Jan. 2017):
1. All psychological traits show significant and substantial genetic influence.
2. No traits are 100% heritable.
3. Heritability is caused by many genes of small effect.
4. Phenotypic correlations between psychological traits. show significant and substantial genetic mediation.
5. The heritability of intelligence increases throughout development.
6. Age-to-age stability is mainly due to genetics.
7. Most measures of the ‘environment’ show significant genetic influence.
8. Most associations between environmental measures and psychological traits are significantly mediated genetically.
9. Most environmental effects are not shared by children growing up in the same family.
10. Abnormal is normal - i.e. disorders studied by psychologists are not qualitatively different from the normal range of behavior.

III. Russell T. Warne, et al., "What Do Undergraduates Learn About Human Intelligence? An Analysis of Introductory Psychology Textbooks" (2018)
- From the abstract: "We conclude that most introductory psychology students are exposed to some inaccurate information and may have the mistaken impression that nonmainstream theories (e.g., Sternberg’s [triarchic theory] or Gardner’s [multiple intelligences] theories) are as empirically supported as g theory."
- Textbook Themes - Environmental Bias (page 44-45): "Several textbooks gave a distorted or oversimplified view of test bias to readers. Indeed, test bias was the most common topic of the inaccurate statements, and readers of nearly half of the textbooks in our study would receive the impression that intelligence tests are prima facie biased against diverse examinees. This flatly contradicts mainstream opinion about the topic, which is that 'the issue of test bias is scientifically dead'.”
- "Although some books provided a balanced explanation of the existence of inter-individual intelligence differences, textbook authors almost always favored environmental explanations for the differences."
- "Probably the most surprising theme we observed in the introduction was the tendency of some authors to minimize the importance of individual differences in intelligence. Most frequently this appeared in the form of a tacit acknowledgment that IQ test scores correlate with academic success, followed by a quick denial that the scores are important for anything else in life."
- "The attitude that some authors had toward the importance of intelligence in determining life outcomes is a noticeable contrast to the opinions of scholars of intelligence, who often explain that 'measures of individual differences in... intelligence... are the most accurate predictors that we have of success in academic achievement, industrial and professional competence and military performance'."

IV. Heiner Rindermann, et al., "Survey of expert opinion on intelligence: Intelligence research, experts' background, controversial issues, and the media" (Jan-Feb., 2020)
- Section 4.4. - Opinions about the g factor, intelligence, and controversial issues (page 12):
- "76% of EQCA experts favored a g factor model of intelligence (rather than a specific abilities model). In contrast, 58% of the earlier ICQS sample (1988) favored a g factor model."
- "In sum, experts in the EQCA and ICQS surveys generally did not endorse a position of strong test bias for examiner attributes (e.g. race, ethnicity, culture) or test content."
- "A controversial topic is the cause of past and current US Black-and-White difference in IQ test results. In the ICQS survey, a plurality (45%) of experts noted the influence of both genetic and environmental factors. In contrast, monocausal positions (i.e. genetic or environmental) were rare but much more likely to be environmental (15%) than genetic (1%). In the current study, EQCA experts were asked what percentage of the US Black-White differences in IQ is, in their view, due to environment or genes. In general, EQCA experts gave a 50-50 (50% genes, 50% environment) response with a slight tilt to the environment position (51% vs 49%). When EQCA experts were classified into discrete categories (genetic, environmental, or 50-50), 40% favored an environmental position, 43% a genetic position, and 17% assumed 50-50."
- "EQCA experts showed a balanced view of the causes of SES differences in Western societies (45% due to IQ, 55% due to non-IQ factors). The positive effects of intelligence on SES were implicated in a meta-analysis of longitudinal studies, which indicated that intelligence was a stronger predictor of later income (r = .21) compared to parental education (r = .15), parental income (r = .16) and parental SES (r = .15)."

NOTE: I asked ChatGPT to evaluate the controversial parts of the Rindermann survey cited above, and it said the following: "My read is: the paper is legitimate and useful, but it is not a clean survey of 'what psychometricians believe.' The sample has a serious self-selection problem, and that problem becomes especially important on the most controversial questions. I would trust it much more as corroboration for already well-established positions on g and psychometric test bias than as evidence of consensus about the genetic contribution to Black–White IQ differences. The g, heritability, predictive-validity, and technical test-bias findings can help establish what mainstream intelligence research looks like. The Black–White genetic-causation percentages should be presented as evidence of substantial disagreement among intelligence researchers, not as a consensus estimate. And the 45/55 SES figure should be labeled explicitly as an expert judgment rather than an empirical causal estimate."

==> ChatGPT also suggested this older paper as a counterpoint:
V. Richard Nisbett, et al., "Intelligence: new findings and theoretical developments" (Feb. 2012)
Abstract: "We review new findings and new theoretical developments in the field of intelligence. New findings include the following: (a) Heritability of IQ varies significantly by social class. (b) Almost no genetic polymorphisms have been discovered that are consistently associated with variation in IQ in the normal range. (c) Much has been learned about the biological underpinnings of intelligence. (d) "Crystallized" and "fluid" IQ are quite different aspects of intelligence at both the behavioral and biological levels. (e) The importance of the environment for IQ is established by the 12-point to 18-point increase in IQ when children are adopted from working-class to middle-class homes. (f) Even when improvements in IQ produced by the most effective early childhood interventions fail to persist, there can be very marked effects on academic achievement and life outcomes. (g) In most developed countries studied, gains on IQ tests have continued, and they are beginning in the developing world. (h) Sex differences in aspects of intelligence are due partly to identifiable biological factors and partly to socialization factors. (i) The IQ gap between Blacks and Whites has been reduced by 0.33 SD in recent years. We report theorizing concerning (a) the relationship between working memory and intelligence, (b) the apparent contradiction between strong heritability effects on IQ and strong secular effects on IQ, (c) whether a general intelligence factor could arise from initially largely independent cognitive skills, (d) the relation between self-regulation and cognitive skills, and (e) the effects of stress on intelligence."

RELEVANT MATERIAL FROM PAST MEETUPS:

Although we haven't had any past meetups on behavioral genetics & the nature/nurture debate, we have had some past meetups on environmental factors that influence people's success or failure in life:

In a meetup in the fall of 2017 entitled "The Deep Cultures of Violence", we talked about "honor culture" as a factor that contributes to higher violent crime rates among white Southern males, African-American males, and Hispanic males.

We covered the effect of race/ethnicity on economic success in the fall of 2017 called "Deep Culture and the American Dream". We looked at arguments surrounding the alleged "culture of poverty" that holds back both poor urban blacks & poor rural whites, and contrasted this with the cultural traits of "model minorities" like Jews & Asians that allegedly lead them to be successful.

Back in June of 2017, the Skeptic meetup had a discussion entitled "A Skeptical Look at Education" where they discussed how several economists like Arnold Kling, Steven Levitt & Bryan Caplan are skeptical that most educational interventions make any long-term, scalable, replicable difference.

In October of 2017, the Skeptics had a meetup entitled "The (Pseudo)Science of Success" where they looked at various claims about educational interventions discussed in Malcolm Gladwell's books Outliers and David and Goliath where he downplayed the role of innate talent. Unfortunately, Gladwell got a lot wrong, but he appears to be correct that once you have an IQ high enough to graduate from college with a decent GPA (~115) other factors become more prominent in explaining your successes & failures in life.

In May 2018, we had a meetup entitled "Does America Offer Equal Opportunity?" where we looked at the effects of family upbringing & residential factors, college admissions & graduation rates, hiring biases & career decisions, and how all of these factors contribute to the racial & gender wage gaps..

In June 2018, we had a meetup entitled "Moral Politics and the Parenting Wars" where we discussed how a family's parenting style often aligns with their political orientation. In the 4th section, we discussed whether free-range parenting is better because it save the parents a lot of time & energy and since children's life outcomes may be mostly a mix of genetics & random chance.

Back in July 2020, we had a meetup entitled "The Debate Over Reparations", and the first 2 section tried to evaluate the economic & psychological harms that African-Americans today may still experience due to the legacies of slavery & Jim Crow. We also looked at the various factors that could be behind the persistent racial income & wealth gaps in the U.S., such as job discrimination, redlining & other limits on home ownership, different educational & career choices, contact with the criminal justice system, etc.

In June 2023, the Skeptics had a meetup entitled "Sexual Revolution or Social Contagion?" where they discussed the ongoing debates over whether the record-high percentage of young people identifying as LGBTQ+ is due to innate determinants of sexual orientation & gender identity that have always been present but were repressed or to social contagion stemming from the way alternative sexual identities have become promoted in schools and in pop culture. We also discussed the possibility that higher rates of gender dysphoria in young people could be due to rising levels of endocrine disrupting chemicals in our environment.

DIRECTIONS ON HOW TO PREPARE FOR OUR DISCUSSION:

The videos & articles you see linked below are intended to give you a basic overview of some of the major debates over the socio-economic, ethical & political implications of hereditarianism. As usual, I certainly don't expect you to read all the articles prior to attending our discussion. The easiest way to prepare for our discussion is to just watch the numbered videos linked under each section - the videos come to about 65 minutes total. The articles marked with asterisks are just there to supply additional details. You can browse and look at whichever ones you want, but don't worry - we'll cover the stuff you missed in our discussion.

In terms of the discussion format, my general idea is that we'll address the topics in the order presented here. I've listed some questions under each section to stimulate discussion. We'll do our best to address most of them, as well as whatever other questions our members raise. I figure we'll spend about 40 minutes on each section.

***

I. UNDERSTANDING HOW THE SAM HARRIS VS EZRA KLEIN DEBATE IN 2017-2018 KICKED OFF THE MODERN DEBATE ON HEREDITARIANISM:

  • Harris argued that Charles Murray was unfairly portrayed as a white supremacist because The Bell Curve did not claim to know if the Black–White IQ gap was genetic, only that both genetic and environmental explanations remained possible. Is that a fair description of Murray’s position, or does it minimize the implications of his policy agenda?
  • Harris argues science will almost certainly uncover average genetic differences among human groups and liberal politics must become robust enough to tolerate such findings. Is this an important principle of scientific openness, or does it give too much weight to hypotheticals that haven't been demonstrated?
  • Harris says that group averages should have no bearing on how we treat an individual. If this individualist principle is accepted, how much practical importance should research on racial differences have—and are there legitimate policy questions where group averages still matter?
  • Ezra Klein argues that the history of slavery, segregation, discrimination, environmental toxins, etc, cannot simply be bracketed when explaining the racial IQ gap. Is this just historical context, or does this constitute evidence favoring an environmental explanation?
  • Klein says James Flynn told him in a phone call that a 10-point Black–White IQ gap could theoretically consist of a 12-point environmental disadvantage offset by a 2-point genetic advantage for Black Americans. Harris responds that many things are possible but asks what is actually plausible, and goes on to question whether researchers are afraid to speak openly on this topic. Was Harris claiming he could read Flynn's mind (as Brooks argues), or is he making important points?
  • Brooks argues that scientific research can never be entirely separated from human judgment: researchers choose categories, frame hypotheses, select variables, and interpret evidence within a particular historical context. How far should we take that point? Is it an important warning against naïve objectivity, or can it become a way of dismissing inconvenient findings by redescribing them as products of social bias?

1a) Joe Rogan w/ Sam Harris, "Race & IQ Controversy" (video - 12:14 min, start at 2:50)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5r_E0bXF54U&t=2m50s

1b) Michael Brooks, "Sam Harris Lights Career On Fire In Ezra Klein Debate" (video - 21:34 min, listen to 13:40)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qmg5giUaR-c

II. UNDERSTANDING RIGHT-WING HEREDITARIANISM & ITS INTERACTIONS WITH CONSERVATIVE POLITICS:

  • Murray argues that persistent racial disparities in jobs, education, and policing can't be understood solely as evidence of systemic racism, because group differences in crime rates and cognitive ability may contribute to unequal outcomes. Is this a good point, or does Murray move too quickly from “not all disparities prove racism” to “these disparities are largely explained by group traits”?
  • Murray claims that America has made substantial racial progress and may now be undermining the color-blind ideal through racial preferences and identity politics. Is he correctly identifying a shift from civil-rights universalism toward group-based politics, or does this understate the extent to which more subtle discrimination and the legacy of past injustices remains?
  • Murray acknowledges that publicizing racial differences could cause social harm but argues the harm from refusing to discuss them is greater. How should we think about that tradeoff? Is suppressing potentially dangerous truths always bad, or can researchers reasonably decide that some low-certainty findings are not worth emphasizing when the likely social costs are high?
  • Before Cofnas spoke out on the Black-White IQ gap, he wrote a paper refuting Kevin MacDonald's speculations about Jews' overrepresentation in elite fields stemming from a group evolutionary strategy. Since Cofnas is Jewish, does this show he's overly sensitive to someone criticizing his in-group but shows less concern when criticizing out-groups? Or does this merely show he's not afraid to tackle highly controversial topics?
  • Cofnas uses Japan and the Congo to argue that if people assume groups are born with identical average capacities, differences in development must involve oppression. Marshall responds with North and South Korea to show genetically similar populations can produce radically different economic outcomes under different institutions. Does this weaken Cofnas’s argument?
  • Cofnas argues hereditarianism is necessary to defeat "wokeness" because, unless people accept natural group differences, every disparity will be treated as evidence of injustice. Does this neglect the possibility that cultural problems or impersonal economic forces could be at work?

2a) Coleman Hughes w/ Charles Murray, "The Consequences of the Race & IQ Discourse" (video - 12:10 min)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCJFr6zB2NM

2b) Winston Marshall w/ Nathan Cofnas, "The ONE Reason Woke Ideology Gets Everything Wrong" (video - 4:09 min)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_AK6IE8h3eg

III. UNDERSTANDING LEFT-WING HEREDITARIANISM & ITS INTERACTIONS WITH PROGRESSIVE POLITICS:

  • Harden’s seed/soil analogy shows why high heritability within a relatively similar environment does not prove that differences between groups are genetic. Is this a decisive rebuttal to race-IQ arguments?
  • Harden emphasizes that “heritable” does not mean “fixed”, but does this risk becoming too rhetorically convenient? If a trait is highly heritable and resistant to intervention, should that still matter politically even if it is not literally immutable?
  • Harden argues that genetic effects may be environment-dependent and may not “port” from one population to another. Does this undermine the usefulness of polygenic scores for policy, or is it a technical limitation that will shrink as datasets improve?
  • Harden’s argues that genetic luck should be treated much like family wealth or other unearned advantages. If intelligence or conscientiousness is partly genetic, does that give society a stronger obligation to redistribute resources?
  • DeBoer argues that society treats intelligence as almost akin to a measure of human worth, whereas we rightly don't do that musical or athletic talent. Is he right that intelligence has become overvalued - and if so, why does intelligence such a premium in our postindustrial society?
  • DeBoer sees universal college attendance as a false panacea for inequality and favors vo-tech alternatives. Is this humane realism, or does it risk prematurely tracking children based on early academic performance?

3a) Kathryn Paige Harden, "Is success genetic?" (video - 4:08 min)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7TXgPkHlvBk

3b) Thaddeus Russell w/ Freddie deBoer, "The Cult of Smart" (video - 13:17 min)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k9QDXOK5blY

IV. THE POLITIC IMPLICATIONS OF GENETIC SCREENING & GENE EDITING:

  • In Gattaca, Vincent’s genome is treated almost as a résumé at birth. If polygenic scores become substantially more predictive, what is the difference between using them for medical prevention and using them in education, employment, insurance, dating, or criminal justice? Where should society draw the line?
  • Later in Gattaca, Vincent is relegated to working as a janitor and says: "I belonged to a new underclass, no longer determined by social status or the color of your skin. No, we now have discrimination down to a science." Could our genotype matter more than our phenotype in the near future, especially as we move toward a more multiracial society? And if so, is that more or less just than the stereotyping we see today?
  • The Cassidy family uses IVF and genetic testing after losing a pregnancy to a severe inherited disorder. Does this seem morally different from selecting for sex, height, intelligence, personality? If so, what distinguishes “prevention” from “enhancement”?
  • The Collinses argue that state-directed eugenics is dangerous but voluntary parental selection is not, but is that distinction sufficient? Can millions of individually voluntary choices collectively produce coercive or socially harmful outcomes even without government mandates?
  • Should individuals have a legal right to keep their polygenic scores private? Would banning employers, insurers, courts, etc, from using that information be analogous to banning racial discrimination—or would society sometimes have legitimate reasons to use accurate predictive information?
  • The optimistic case for genetic selection is that it reduces enormous amounts of preventable suffering and gives children better health and greater capabilities. The pessimistic argument is that it could create a hereditary caste system. Which danger should concern us more?

4a) Gattaca, "Vincent Childhood Scene" (video - 4:23 min)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wY_0u84DtXY

4b) VICE News w/ Simone & Malcolm Collins, "The Controversial Future of Genetic Testing" (video - 11:35 min)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KthrLReQE70

XXXX

Related topics

Genomics
Political Philosophy
Psychology
Sociology
Racial/Ethnic Diversity

You may also like