Bi-Weekly Discussion - The Implicit Politics of Historical Epics & Fantasy Films
Details
This is going to be an online meetup using Zoom. If you've never used Zoom before, don't worry — it's easy to use and free to join.
Here's the link to the event: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84590270607?pwd=N1ZjVHNWUVRLaEJaSm5RdVd5dDRmZz09
***
THE IMPLICIT POLITICS OF HISTORICAL EPICS, PERIOD DRAMAS & FANTASY FILMS IN THE 21st CENTURY
INTRODUCTION:
As I mentioned earlier this year, I plan to occasionally take a break from the quantitative, social science topics we usually cover in this meetup and focus instead on more qualitative types of pop culture analysis. And since we're coming up on Tolkien Reading Day (March 25) and George R.R. Martin Day (March 29), I figured we could look at fantasy fiction, particularly movies & TV shows, since they tend to have a much larger audience than fantasy books. We'll also look at historical epics & period dramas, since they tend to have a lot of thematic overlap with the fantasy genre.
There's a few questions worth considering before we dive into this topic:
(1) How should we define fantasy, historical epics, and period dramas? Genres tend to have fuzzy edges, but for this discussion, we're talking about fiction set in pre-modern Europe (i.e. before the Enlightenment & the Industrial Revolution), or a fantasy world that is roughly analogous to pre-modern Europe. This is a huge stretch of time, meaning these stories could be set in classical antiquity up through the Middle Ages and into the Renaissance & Early Modern Period. (Some notable exceptions are set later in England's Regency period or - in the case of steampunk - in a fantasy analogue to 19th-century England.) For Europeans, some of these stories can connect deeply with their sense of national identity, but for most Americans these stories tend to feel more like fairy tales set "long, long ago in a land far away." Fantasy can be distinguished by the addition of supernatural elements (magic, dragons, elves, etc.), while epics can be distinguished from period dramas because the former focuses more on battles (and appeals more to male audiences) while the latter focuses more on intrigue & romance (and appeals more to female audiences).
(2) How can stories set in a different country in the distant past, or in a fictional world, possibly relate to contemporary politics? Some of these stories may be consciously intended by their authors & directors to be metaphors for contemporary political issues, such as debates about war, religion, gender, race, etc. However, many of them don't obviously relate directly to modern-day politics. However, every story has an implicit morality, and the archetypal nature of most fantasy & epic stories tends to encourage more suspension of disbelief and arguably connects more with our deeper psychology, e.g. our sense of what constitutes heroism & villainy, our desires for adventure, opulence & romance, our longing for a "re-enchantment of the world" that provokes awe & wonder, etc. One can argue that these archetypal stories are "implicitly political" since politics is downstream from our deeper intuitions about ethics, aesthetics & meaning. (However, it's worth pointing out that we tend to set a much higher bar for leaders in fantasy worlds than in reality. Trump & Biden can get elected president in the real world, but it's dubious that either could convincingly play a wise & noble king in a fantasy film.)
(3) Can we infer anything about the general public's underlying beliefs by looking at box office receipts for historical epics and fantasy films? The general assumption we'll make is that the larger the audience of a film or TV show, the more it connected with people on an emotional level. This doesn't necessarily mean the audience agreed with the director's intended message, but it suggests something spoke to them - even if it was unintended. However, some films may have flopped merely due to bad timing in their release date or some bad editing that got fixed with a director's cut, so we may want to look at streaming numbers for older films that have reemerged as "sleeper hits" or "cult classics" (e.g. Oliver Stone's "Alexander" and Ridley Scott's "Kingdom of Heaven").
(4) Given that audience reactions to films & TV shows and fan theories can vary quite a bit even among those who saw the exact same story, how can we determine which messages the audience took away from a particular work of fiction? This is the hardest question to adequately answer. We can occasionally find empirical studies of audience reactions that also delve into the demographics of who watched it - e.g. see this 2013 study on the political impact of Harry Potter on Millennials and this 2018 study on TV watching preferences by political ideology. There's also some general studies that suggest psychological benefits from watching historical dramas and fantasy, like greater imagination and mental resiliency.
However, since social scientists don't typically run randomized control trials with movies, we're often left with a "chicken & egg problem". The cultural impact of Harry Potter on Millennials has been studied extensively, since 44% of Millennial males & 61% of Millennial females consider themselves fans, and a significant percentage of them read the books as well as watching the movies. And the 2013 study shows that Millennial fans of Harry Potter did grow up to be more politically progressive than their peers who weren't fans. But it's hard to tell if reading & watching 'Harry Potter' made Millennial fans grow up to be more politically liberal, or whether conservative parents were more likely to prohibit Harry Potter, leaving the children of liberal parents to be overrepresented in the fandom. In the latter case, they may have grown up to be liberal due to their parenting & peer group more than their media consumption.
The 2018 study noted differences in media consumption based on people's reported self-efficacy, then hypothesized: "One potential (tantalizing) explanation for this is that people with high self-confidence about their ability to affect the course of a nation are drawn to the type of Machiavellian storylines that typify 'Pretty Little Liars' and 'Empire'. The wish-fulfillment fantasies on display in 'Once Upon a Time' may be more appealing to people who have modest ideas about their ability to make a difference on a national level." This conflicts with the stated intention of Edward Kitsis, the writer for 'Once Upon a Time', who said that it's about "seeing that among all the trials and tribulations of life, you can persevere and find light among the darkness" and "it's that ability to think your life will get better".
The 2018 study also noted that "Game of Thrones distinguished itself as the highest-rated show in our study [as] a fan favorite among Blues, Purples and Reds" but "only about half as many Reds watched 'Game of Thrones' (16%)." The study authors didn't offer an explanation, but they did note later on that Reds "most often enjoy watching shows that allow them to identify with characters [and] that raise their mood." This might suggest why a fantasy drama with lots of screen time for villains that often killed off the heroes may have appealed less to their tastes. There's also the issue that 'Game of Thrones' featured lots of graphic sex scenes, especially in its earlier seasons, which may have offended some religious conservatives, although (judging by critics' responses) it also offended some feminists.
In many cases, we'll have to make educated guesses about audience reactions by extrapolating from reviews by journalists & bloggers and online discussions in on sites like Reddit, Facebook & Twitter. We should probably keep our opinions on the social effects of movies & TV shows somewhat agnostic until we've got better empirical studies -- but that doesn't mean we can't have some fun speculating until then!
RELEVANT MATERIAL FROM PAST MEETUPS:
We had a meetup back in January entitled "Is Politics Downstream from (Pop) Culture?" where we reviewed some of the basic concepts from media effects theory, and then looked at the debates over the social effects of sex, drugs & violence in mass media, the Marxist argument that pop culture serves as an "opiate of the masses", and the recent debate over diversity in pop culture. We also looked at how the gatekeeping abilities of creators & critics may have weakened as online fandoms arose in the 21st century, allowing the public to reinterpret pop culture and even demand changes.
Back in Dec. 2022, we had a meetup on "The Implicit Politics of Xmas Films" where we discussed David Lowery's film "The Green Knight" (2021) as a quasi-religious fantasy film that employs some of the same elements of classic spiritual redemption stories set at Xmas time like "A Christmas Carol" and "It's a Wonderful Life". We also discussed Disney's "Frozen" (2013) & "Frozen 2" (2019) as Xmas romance stories for children that subverted traditional gender roles we typically see in fantasy films by casting the princesses as the protagonists, the handsome prince as the secret villain, and the loyal male sidekick as the true love.
***
DIRECTIONS ON HOW TO PREPARE FOR OUR DISCUSSION:
The material you see linked below are intended to give you a basic overview of some of the major debates over the political messages in the historical epics, period dramas, and fantasy movies of the 21st century. The easiest way to prepare for our discussion is to just watch the videos linked under each section - they come to about about 67 minutes total. The articles marked with asterisks are just there to supply additional details.
In terms of the discussion format, my general idea is that we'll address the topics in the order presented here. I figure we'll spend about 30 minutes on each section.
***
I. HOW AUDIENCES INTERPRETED WARS IN FANTASY & HISTORICAL EPIC FILMS AMID THE REAL-LIFE "WAR ON TERROR" (c. 2001-2014):
- WHY WERE THE TOP GROSSING FILMS OF THE 2000s FANTASY, SCI-FI & SUPERHEROES RATHER THAN WAR FILMS?
- HOW DID HIPPIES IN THE 1960s INTERPRET TOLKIEN'S WORK AS ANTI-WAR, BUT CONSERVATIVES IN THE 2000s SAW IT AS PRO-WAR?
- WAS THE INEPT MINISTRY OF MAGIC IN 'HARRY POTTER' A CRITIQUE OF ANTI-TERRORISM?
- WERE IRANIANS OVERREACTING WHEN THEY INTERPRETED '300' AS ANTI-PERSIAN? WAS THE MOVIE PRO-WAR & EVEN FASCIST?
- DID 'KINGDOM OF HEAVEN' FLOP DUE TO ITS SECULAR, ANTI-WAR MESSAGE?
- DOES THE DESTRUCTION OF KINGS LANDING IN 'GAME OF THRONES' REPRESENT THE IRAQ WAR, OR IS THIS AS FAR FETCHED AS PEACENIKS WHO THOUGHT SMAUG'S BREATH WAS A METAPHOR FOR NAPALM IN VIETNAM?
- DO 'HOUSE OF THE DRAGON' & 'RINGS OF POWER' REFLECT THE DISASTROUS END TO THE WAR ON TERROR & THE DECLINE OF THE AMERICAN EMPIRE?
1a) Tom Nicholas, "How the 'War on Terror' shaped Harry Potter" (video - 29:12 min, listen to 15:50)
1b) Charlie Rose w/ Viggo Mortensen, "The War on Terror and The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers" (video - 10:56 min, start at 1:55 & listen to 6:27)
- Rax King, "How Lord of the Rings Shaped a Hopeless Generation" (Mel Mag)
- Kayti Burt, "How 'Harry Potter' Became An Escapist Saga for Millennials in a Post-9/11 World" (Collider)
- Evan Thomas, "War Film: The Politics and Drama of '300'" (Newsweek)
- Andrew Saris, "Ridley Scott’s Kingdom of Heaven: The War on Terror’s Bloody Past" (Observer)
- John Haltiwanger, "People think 'Game of Thrones' season 8, episode 5 was a big metaphor for the US's disastrous Iraq War" (Business Insider)
- Darren Mooney, "The Rings of Power Explores the War on Terror Legacy of The Lord of the Rings" (Escapist)
- Darren Mooney, "[House of the Dragon's 2nd Episode] ‘The Rogue Prince’ Depicts a House in Decline" (Escapist)
II. THE DEPICTION OF RELIGION IN HISTORICAL & FANTASY FILMS IN OUR AGE OF SECULARIZATION:
- WERE MANY CHRISTIANS OPPOSED TO 'HARRY POTTER' AS A GATEWAY TO THE OCCULT? WHY DIDN'T THEY OPPOSE 'LORD OF THE RINGS'?
- WHY WAS THE FIRST 'NARNIA' MOVIE & 'THE PASSION' SUCCESSFUL WHILE THE NARNIA SEQUELS & THE EPIC 'NOAH' AND 'EXODUS' MOVIES FLOPPED?
- DID 'TROY' OMIT THE GREEK GODS BECAUSE THEY FIGURED MODERN AUDIENCES WOULDN'T UNDERSTAND THEM?
- DID 'THE GOLDEN COMPASS' HAVE TO VEIL ITS CRITIQUE OF CATHOLICISM IN 2007 MORE THAN THE 'HIS DARK MATERIALS' SERIES TODAY TO AVOID BACKLASH?
- DOES 'GAME OF THRONES' PORTRAY RELIGION AS MERELY ANOTHER CYNICAL TOOL FOR THOSE IN POWER, OR SOMETIMES A FORCE FOR GOOD?
- DOES THE POSITIVE PORTRAYAL OF SOME CHRISTIAN CHARACTERS IN 'VIKINGS' AND 'THE LAST KINGDOM' SIGNAL A SHIFT IN HOW MEDIA PORTRAYS MEDIEVAL CHRISTIANITY?
- IS THE MIX OF RELIGIONS WE SEE IN SOME FANTASY & MEDIEVAL SHOWS A GOOD ANALOGY FOR THE INCREASING RELIGIOUS DIVERSITY WE HAVE TODAY?
2a) Brett Martin w/ Nicole Kidman, Daniel Craig & Sam Elliott, "The Golden Compass. Is it anti-religion?" (video - 2:06 min.)
2b) Endeavor, "How Postmodernity Killed the Historical Epic: 'Kingdom of Heaven'" (video - 20:06 min, start at 11:30 & listen to 15:35)
2c) History, "Vikings: Clash of Religions" (video - 3:37 min.)
- Rev. Tom Emanuel, "Evangelicals saw their foes in Harry Potter and themselves in Lord of the Rings [in the wake of 9/11]" (Polygon)
- Meghan O'Rourke, "The Lion King: C.S. Lewis's Narnia isn't simply an allegory" (Slate)
- Nathan Smith, "'His Dark Materials' is Finally Getting Told Without (Much) Religious Backlash [unlike 'The Golden Compass']" (Syfy)
- Christopher Orr, "The Movie Review: 'Kingdom of Heaven' - Has a historical epic ever told us less about the milieu in which it is set, and more about that in which it was produced?" (Atlantic)
- Brent Land, "From ‘Noah’ to ‘Exodus’: How Hollywood Fared in its Year of the Bible" (Variety)
- Jana Riess, "What’s crazy about religion on Game of Thrones: It's not surprising that the state religion of the Seven is DOA. What's unexpected is that so many of the other religions have real power." (Religion News)
- Bishop Robert Barron, "3 Reasons Why 'Vikings' is the Most Religiously Interesting Show on TV" (Word on Fire)
III. HISTORICAL INTRIGUE, DECADENT COSTUME DRAMAS & DARK FANTASY AMID TV's "AGE OF THE ANTI-HERO" & OCCUPY'S CRITIQUE OF THE 1% (c. 2010-2018)
- WHY DID SO MANY TV SERIES IN THE 2010s SUBVERT THE HEROIC TROPES OF EPIC/FANTASY FILMS FROM THE 2000s? WAS IT A SIGN OF MALAISE & CYNICISM AFTER THE 2008 FINANCIAL CRISIS?
- DID RIDLEY SCOTT'S 'ROBIN HOOD' AND THE 'SPARTACUS' TV SERIES, REFLECT A GROWING SENSE OF CLASS CONFLICT & A FEAR OF "NEO-FEUDALISM"?
- WERE THE DECADENT ROYALS IN 'ROME', 'THE TUDORS', 'THE BORGIAS' AND 'GAME OF THRONES' CRITIQUES OF INEQUALITY, OR DID AUDIENCES IDENTIFY WITH THEM?
- DID THE DEPICTION OF SEX - INCLUDING GAY SEX - IN THESE RACY SHOWS SIGNAL A MORE LIBERATED & TOLERANT AGE? OR WAS THE INCLUSION OF RAPE & TENDENCY TO KILL OFF GAY CHARACTERS REGRESSIVE?
- IS THE DEPICTION OF SLAVEHOLDING IN 'GAME OF THRONES' & 'OUTLANDER' PROBLEMATIC, SINCE THE FORMER HAS A "WHITE SAVIOR" COME TO THE RESCUE WHILE THE LATTER SHOWS US A KINDLY SLAVEOWNER?
- WAS DISNEY'S 'MALEFICENT' AND ITS SEQUEL A LAME ATTEMPT TO JUMP ON THE ANTI-HERO BANDWAGON, OR A DEFT REIMAGINING OF 'SLEEPING BEAUTY' THAT HELPS KIDS UNDERSTAND WHY SOMEONE MIGHT TURN EVIL? IN THE LATTER CASE, IS THE VEILED DATE RAPE OF MALEFICENT STILL TOO HEAVY FOR KIDS?
- DID 'GAME OF THRONES' GAIN SOME OF ITS CULTURAL CURRENCY BY DRAMATIZING THE RIGHTEOUS ANGER OF WOMEN IN THE #YESALLWOMEN & #METOO ERA? DID IT SELL OUT THAT PROMISE WHEN IT KILLED OFF DAENERYS IN THE FINAL SEASON?
- IS THE "AGE OF THE ANTI-HERO" COMING TO AN END, OR WILL ANTI-HEROES REMAIN AN EFFECTIVE WAY TO KEEP PROTAGONISTS FROM FEELING TOO PERFECT & SELF-RIGHTEOUS?
3a) Robin Hood (2010) Movie Clip, "Power From the Ground Up" (video - 3:27 min.)
3b) Gil Kidron & Itamar Harel, "Why We Shouldn't Hate The High Sparrow [from 'Game of Thrones']" (video - 15:34 min, listen to 10:00)
3c) The Take, "Why Game of Thrones Already Feels Dated" (video - 20:58 min, listen to 2:30)
- Jared Keller, "Is Robin Hood a Tea Partier? Though 'rob from the rich, give to the poor' does sound awfully socialist..." (The Atlantic)
- Simon Howell, "Why Spartacus is Better than You Remember" (Goomba Stomp)
- Emily Nussbaum, "The Political Resonance of Game of Thrones" (New Yorker)
- Benjamin Breen, "Why 'Game of Thrones' Isn't Medieval—and Why That Matters" (PS Mag)
- Emmitt Rensen, "Game of Thrones’ High Sparrow didn’t rape, murder, or pillage — why did viewers hate him anyway?" (Vox)
- Amanda-Rae Prescott, "Outlander: We Need to Talk about Jocasta Owning Slaves" (Den of Geek)
- Ana Peres, "Explained: The Fantasy Genre Has a Problem With Sexual Violence" (Movie Web)
IV. THE DEBATES OVER INJECTING "WOKENESS" INTO FANTASY & HISTORICAL FILMS AND THE POSSIBILITY OF A "POST-WOKE" SYNTHESIS (c. 2014-TODAY)
- WERE COMPLAINTS ABOUT "WHITE-WASHING" & "WHITE SAVIORS" IN EPICS & FANTASY IN NON-EUROPEAN SETTINGS FROM THE 2000s & EARLY 2010s VALID? IF SO, IS IT HYPOCRITICAL TO FAVOR RACE-SWAPPING WHITE CHARACTERS IN MEDIEVAL EUROPEAN SETTINGS?
- WHY DID WRITERS RACE-SWAP WHITE CHARACTERS IN 'RINGS OF POWER', 'HOUSE OF THE DRAGON' AND 'THE WHEEL OF TIME' INSTEAD OF BRINGING IN BLACK CHARACTERS FROM THE FANTASY ANALOGUES FOR AFRICA (HARAD, SOTHYROS, SEA FOLK ISLES)? IS IT JUST LAZINESS, OR ARE THEY TRYING TO MAKE EVERY GROUP MULTIRACIAL TO AVOID SHOWING RACIAL CONFLICT?
- IS RACIAL DIVERSITY IN STEAMPUNK & URBAN FANTASY LESS JARRING BECAUSE THEY'RE BASED ON THE 19th & 20th CENTURIES? IS THIS AN ADVANTAGE OF "PORTAL FANTASIES" WHERE THE FANTASY WORLD IS CONNECTED TO OUR MODERN DAY WORLD & THUS RACIALLY DIVERSE CHARACTERS CAN ACCESS IT?
- IS IT PLAUSIBLE THAT SOME DIRECTORS ENGAGE IN "FAN-BAITING" IN ORDER TO STIR CONTROVERSY AND/OR TO BLAME THEIR FAILURE ON "TOXIC FANDOM"?
- HOW CAN HISTORICAL FILMS PORTRAY STRONG FEMALE CHARACTERS THAT ARE SYMPATHETIC WITHOUT BEING DISMISSED AS TOO-PERFECT "MARY SUES"?
- DOES THE FOCUS ON RACE & GENDER EQUALITY IN EPICS & FANTASY BELIE THE CLASS INEQUALITY WHICH IS APPARENTLY NOT AS PROBLEMATIC?
- DID 'NORTHMAN' AND 'THE LAST DUEL' - DESPITE BEING BOX OFFICE DISAPPOINTMENTS - SUGGEST A WAY TO CRITIQUE "TOXIC MASCULINITY" IN HISTORICAL EPICS WITHOUT SEEMING PREACHY?
- ARE "WOKE" SHOWS FAILING? IF SO, WILL THIS PUSH DIRECTORS TO CREATE "POST-WOKE" SHOWS THAT HAVE DIVERSE CASTS & STRONG FEMALES WITHOUT SEEMING HEAVY-HANDED (E.G. ARCANE, HOUSE OF THE DRAGON, THE WITCHER, NORTHMAN, THE LAST DUEL)?
4a) Seb Melmouth, "Diversity in historical dramas: empowering or jarring?" (video - 6:00 min.)
4b) Will Jordan (Critical Drinker), "Why Modern Movies Suck - They Hate Their Own Fans" (video - 14:23 min, start at 8:24)
4c) Taylor Ellis, "Arcane: How to write strong female characters" (video - 9:09 min.)
- Tyler Dean, "Game of Thrones complex relationship to racism and colonialism" (Tor)
- Henry Wong, "Has House of the Dragon Fixed Game of Thrones’ Sex Problem?" (Esquire)
- Tracy Brown, "It turns out ‘House of the Dragon’ is as homophobic as ‘Game of Thrones’" (LA Times)
- Ross Douthat, "‘House of the Dragon’ and ‘The Rings of Power’ Both Use Diverse Casting. One of Them Does It Better." (NY Times)
- Alexander Beiner, "Nazi Elves and Cockney Orcs: The Rings of Power, Class and Royalty: How Amazon's new series gives us a new lens on the culture wars" (Substack)
- Gary Younge, "Black Like Me? Bridgerton and the Fantasy of a Non-Racist Past" (The Nation)
- Elyse Martin, "Shadow and Bone Has a Bridgerton Problem" (Slate)
- Tyler Dean, "Carnival Row Is a Surprisingly Complex Take on Victorian Fantasy Tropes, Race, and Politics" (Tor)
- ..
