Skip to content

Details

This is going to be an online meetup using Zoom. If you've never used Zoom before, don't worry — it's easy to use and free to join.

Click on the link below to join the Zoom discussion at the scheduled time...

***

***

THE IMPLICIT (AND EXPLICIT) POLITICS OF POLICE & CRIME DRAMAS

INTRODUCTION:

As I mentioned earlier this year, I plan to occasionally take a break from the quantitative, social science topics we usually cover and focus instead on more qualitative types of pop culture analysis. And since criminal justice reform has been a hot topic for the past few years, I figured we could look at films & TV shows that feature policing, courtrooms, the criminal underworld, and prisons. We'll focus on portrayals of these themes over the last 20 years, and we'll omit the older movies & TV shows except to briefly touch upon precedents they set and tropes they established.

There's a few questions worth considering before we dive into this topic:
(1) How do average American view criminal justices issues, and how this differs from insiders like police officers? We can partly answer this by looking at Pew Research Center polls...

(2) What level of contact does the average American have with police and the criminal justice system, so that the representations in pop culture can be put into some realistic perspective? Since there's about 800K police officers in the U.S. and 123.6 million households, this suggests less than 1% of Americans have a police officer in their immediate family. In our previous meetup on "The Implicit Politics of War Movies/Games" we noted that declining rates of military service in America has led to increased distance between most civilians and the military, which in turn has led to media stereotypes of veterans as either macho heroes or ticking time-bombs. A similar phenomena may be affecting the public's view of police. And not surprisingly, polls show a significant decline in the general public's trust in police in 2020 which has only partially rebounded, although almost half (47%) of Americans also say spending on policing in their area should be increased.

Even if most Americans don't have a police officer in their family or personally know one, that doesn't mean they have no contact with the criminal justice system. A 2020 study found that about 20-25% of Americans have some contact with police during a given year, and these contacts are divided roughly evenly between police-initiated contacts (e.g. traffic stops, arrests) and civilian-initiated contacts (e.g. calling to report a crime or emergency). There was no significant difference in the percentage of whites (12%) and blacks (11%) who experienced police-initiated contact, although a higher percentage of blacks (4%) and Hispanics (3%) than whites (2%) or other races (2%) experienced threats or use of force. About a third of Americans have an arrest record (although not necessarily a conviction), and 45% of Americans have had an immediate family member incarcerated, in the sense of at least spending a night in jail - if not prison, although this varied by race (i.e. 63% for blacks, 48% for Hispanics, 42% for whites).

(3) Can we infer anything about the general public's underlying beliefs by looking at box office receipts for movies or Nielsen ratings for TV shows about police, courtrooms, criminals, prison, etc.? The general assumption we'll make is that the larger the audience of a film or TV show, the more it connected with people on an emotional level. This doesn't necessarily mean the audience agreed with the director's intended message, but it suggests something spoke to them - even if it was unintended. However, some films with a weak message may have still attracted large audiences due to the star power of some A-list actors and impressive special effects. Other films with a stronger message may have flopped merely due to bad timing in their release date or some bad editing that got fixed with a director's cut, so we may want to look at streaming numbers for older films that have reemerged as "sleeper hits".

(4) Given that audience reactions to films & TV shows and fan theories can vary quite a bit even among those who saw the exact same story, how can we determine which messages the audience took away from a particular work of fiction? This is the hardest question to adequately answer, although I've linked some studies under each section below that try to address this question. We can often find empirical studies that delve into the demographics of who watches different TV shows... A 2018 study found that some police procedurals like 'Criminal Minds' and 'Bones' are popular with both conservatives & liberals although they report different reactions to events - conservatives were more likely to report anger & disgust, while liberals were more likely to report sadness & fear. There was also a divergence on some police procedurals - e.g. liberals tend to watch 'Law & Order: SVU' (which focuses on sex crimes) while conservatives tended to watch 'NCIS' (which focuses on military crimes). Respondents who considered race among their most important issues were more likely to say that their favorite shows included the prison drama 'Orange is the New Black', whereas respondents who ranked race among their least important issues preferred 'NCIS' and/or 'Law & Order: SVU'.

We should note that since social scientists don't typically run randomized control trials with movies, we're often left with a "chicken & egg problem" - i.e. it's often not clear whether watching COPS, Law & Order SVU, Making a Murderer, Breaking Bad, Orange Is the New Black, etc., changed people's minds, or whether specific types of people tend to prefer certain types of content. In many cases, we'll have to make educated guesses about audience reactions by extrapolating from reviews by journalists & bloggers and online discussions on social media. We should probably keep our opinions on the social effects of movies & TV shows somewhat agnostic until we've got better empirical studies -- but that doesn't mean we can't have some fun speculating until then!

RELEVANT MATERIAL FROM PAST MEETUPS:

We had a meetup back in January entitled "Is Politics Downstream from (Pop) Culture?" where we reviewed some of the basic concepts from media effects theory, and then looked at the debates over the social effects of sex, drugs & violence in mass media, the Marxist argument that pop culture serves as an "opiate of the masses", and the recent debate over diversity in pop culture.

Way back in Dec. 2018, we had a meetup entitled "Crime & Theories of Punishment" and in the 1st section we looked at the psychological research on what factors influence how people think about crime & punishment. Links between personality traits and views on punishing criminals is hard to pin down. Among men, Openness is a significant predictor of anti-death penalty attitudes but not for women, and the opposite was true of Conscientiousness. Punitiveness appears to be higher in people with more group-oriented moral concerns which promotes a view of crime as being perpetrated against society, while endorsement of individual-oriented moral concerns reduces punitiveness by directing attention toward the welfare of offenders as well as victims.

***

DIRECTIONS ON HOW TO PREPARE FOR OUR DISCUSSION:

The videos & articles you see linked below are intended to give you a basic overview of some of the theories about the ways police & crime dramas shape the way the public thinks about law enforcement & the criminal justice system. As usual, I certainly don't expect you to read all the articles prior to attending our discussion. The easiest way to prepare for our discussion is to just watch the numbered videos linked under each section - the videos come to about about 68 minutes total. That's a bit longer than I usually ask people to watch, so if you're pressed for time just watch 1 video from each section - that only comes to about 30-35 minutes.

The articles marked with asterisks are just there to supply additional details. You can browse and look at whichever ones you want, but don't worry - we'll cover the stuff you missed in our discussion.

In terms of the discussion format, my general idea is that we'll address the topics in the order presented here. I've listed some questions under each section to stimulate discussion. I figure we'll spend about 30 minutes on each section.

***

I. THE IMPLICIT POLITICS OF "COPS" & POLICE PROCEDURALS:

  • WHY ARE POLICE PROCEDURALS SO BROADLY POPULAR ACROSS POLITICAL LINES? IS IT DUE TO "SYSTEM JUSTIFICATION"?
  • DO CITY OFFICIALS USE FILMING PERMITS TO PERSUADE PRODUCERS TO MAKE POLICE SHOWS INTO "COPAGANDA"?
  • DO SHOWS LIKE "THE WIRE" & "THE SHIELD" AND MOVIES LIKE "TRAINING DAY" & "THE DEPARTED" THAT SHOW POLICE ABUSING THEIR POWER GET AUDIENCES TO DESIRE REFORM, OR DOES IT JUST MAKE THEM CYNICALLY THINK "SOMETIMES COPS HAVE TO GET THEIR HANDS DIRTY"?
  • IF THERE'S "NO SUCH THING AS AN ANTI-WAR FILM" DUE TO AUDIENCE FASCINATION WITH THE SPECTACLE OF WAR, DOES THIS SUGGEST THERE'S ALSO NO TRULY ANTI-COP TV SHOWS?
  • ARE REALITY SHOWS ABOUT POLICING MORE ACCURATE, OR DOES POLICE CONTROL OVER FILMING & EDITING JUST MAKE IT INTO MORE EFFECTIVE PROPAGANDA?

1a) Sean Malone (FEE), "American Cop Shows Are Brainwashing You" (video - 8:21 min)

1b) Michael Moore w/ Dick Herlan, "Bowling for Columbine (2002) - 'COPS' scene" (video - 4:05 min.)

II. THE IMPLICIT POLITICS OF COURT-TV & LEGAL DRAMAS:

  • TO WHAT EXTENT DOES WATCHING COURTROOM DRAMAS DISTORT THE PUBLIC'S UNDERSTANDING OF REAL COURTROOM PROCEDURES?
  • DOES THE CHEAPER DECOR OF MANY LOCAL COURTS & LESS ELOQUENT ARGUMENTS FROM LAWYERS MAKE THE REAL-WORLD JUSTICE SYSTEM SEEM LESS LEGITIMATE THAN IN THE MOVIES?
  • IS THE "CSI EFFECT" REAL - I.E. DO JURORS WHO'VE WATCHED FORENSICS DRAMAS EXPECT AN UNREALISTIC AMOUNT OF FORENSIC EVIDENCE? CONVERSELY, DOES IT MAKE THEM OVERLY CREDULOUS WHENEVER "FORENSICS" IS MENTIONED?
  • ARE PEOPLE WHO'VE WATCHED REAL COURT CASES ON TV BETTER INFORMED THAN THOSE WHO MERELY WATCHED COURTROOM DRAMAS? ARE THEY ALSO BETTER INFORMED THAN THOSE WHO'VE WATCHED NEWS SUMMARY OF CASES?
  • DOES THE RIGHT TO A "PUBLIC TRIAL" MEAN IT SHOULD BE TELEVISED, OR DOES PUTTING CAMERAS IN THE COURTROOM DISTORT THE CASE BY INTIMIDATING WITNESSES & FORCING ATTORNEYS TO PLAY TO THE TV AUDIENCE?

2a) Keith Stuart, "The Reason You're Obsessed With Courtroom Dramas" (video - 9:28 min)

2b) GBH News w/ Steven Brill, "Court TV Founder Has New Netflix Show That Focuses On Sensationalized Media Coverage Of Cases" (video - 9:58 min.)

III. THE IMPLICIT POLITICS OF TRUE CRIME & ANTIHERO CRIME DRAMAS:

  • HOW DID "THE SOPRANOS" PAVE THE WAY FOR TV CRIME DRAMAS LIKE "WEEDS", "BREAKING BAD" & "OZARKS"? IS TV'S "AGE OF THE ANTIHERO" A SIGN OF DECLINING PUBLIC MORALITY OR GROWING MATURITY?
  • WHY DO AUDIENCES EMPATHIZE WITH CRIMINAL PROTAGONISTS DESPITE THEIR IMMORALITY? DOES IT DEPEND ON THEM BEING WHITE?
  • DO LIBERALS ACCEPT IMMORAL BEHAVIOR FROM CRIMINAL CHARACTERS BECAUSE THEY'RE SEEN AS "VICTIMS OF SOCIETY" OR "ROBIN HOODS"?
  • CONVERSELY, DO CONSERVATIVES TEND TO PREFER DIRTY COPS OVER ANTIHERO CRIMINALS?
  • DO TRUE CRIME DOCS GIVE VIEWERS A MORE ACCURATE UNDERSTANDING OF CRIME, OR DOES THEY CULTIVATE "MEAN WORLD SYNDROME" BY FOCUSING ON UNCOMMON CRIMES LIKE SERIAL KILLERS?
  • WHY ARE MANY TRUE CRIME FANS WOMEN? DO THEY WANT TO LEARN HOW TO AVOID PREDATORS & SUPPORT VICTIMS, OR IS THERE SOMETIMES AN ILLICIT ATTRACTION TO VIOLENT MEN?

3a) Thomas Flight, "Why The Wire is one of the Most Brilliant TV Shows Ever" (video - 18:43 min, start at 1:00 & listen to 10:30)

3b) Sarah Burton w/ Sheila Isenberg, "Why Women Are So Fascinated By Murderers" (video - 7:22 min.)

IV. THE IMPLICIT POLITICS OF PRISON DOCUMENTARIES & DRAMAS:

  • HOW DID FILMS LIKE "THE SHAWSHANK REDEMPTION" (1994), "DEAD MAN WALKING" (1995), "AMERICAN HISTORY X" (1997) & "THE GREEN MILE" (1999) HUMANIZE PRISONERS? HAVE ANY RECENT FILMS DONE THIS?
  • DO JOKES ABOUT PRISON RAPE IN POP CULTURE NORMALIZE IT & MAKE IT SEEM JUSTIFIED?
  • ARE RECENT FILMS/SHOWS BETTER AT RESISTING RACIST STEREOTYPES OF BLACK & HISPANIC PRISONERS?
  • IN WHAT SENSE WERE 'OZ' & 'OITNB' REALISTIC PORTRAYALS OF PRISON LIFE, AND HOW WERE THEY UNREALISTIC?
  • DO PRISON DOCS GIVE VIEWERS A MORE ACCURATE UNDERSTANDING OF THE PENAL SYSTEM, OR DO THEY TEND TO FOCUS TOO MUCH ON VIOLENT, GANG-RIVEN MAX SECURITY PRISONS?
  • CAN PRISON DOCS HAVE A "SCARED STRAIGHT" EFFECT ON JUVENILE DELINQUENTS, OR IS THIS LIKLEY TO BACKFIRE?

4a) S.E. Komack, "Depictions of Prisons on Popular TV: Analysis of 'OITNB'" (video - 32:52 min, start at 15:57 & listen to 26:55)

4b) Jonathan McIntosh, "Sexual Assault of Men [in Prison] Played for Laughs" (video - 28:52 min, start at 15:09 & watch to 23:24)

..............

Related topics

Books and Movies Discussions
Law Enforcement
True Crime
Criminal Justice
Restorative Justice

You may also like