Skip to content

Details

This is going to be an online meetup using Zoom. If you've never used Zoom before, don't worry — it's easy to use and free to join.

Click on the link below on the designated date/time...

***

***

THE IMPLICIT (AND EXPLICIT) POLITICS OF COMIC BOOKS & SUPERHERO FILMS

INTRODUCTION:

As I mentioned earlier this year, I plan to occasionally take a break from the quantitative, social science topics we usually cover in this meetup and focus instead on more qualitative types of pop culture analysis. And since we're coming up on the "National Comic Book Day" (Sept. 25th), I figured we could look at superhero stories, particularly films & TV shows.

There's a few questions worth considering before we dive into this topic:

(1) How should we define the "superhero" genre? Genres tend to have fuzzy edges, but for this discussion, we're talking about stories featuring costumed crime fighters who often possess superhuman powers. The genre primarily falls between "urban fantasy" and "soft science fiction" in the spectrum of scientific realism, and the twin focus on crime-fighting and heroic deeds means they often draw upon some tropes from pulp detective comics & action-adventure movies. Films & TV shows that feature super-powered protagonists that diverge sharply from the tropes of comic books - e.g. movies like Wanted and Hanna and TV shows like Sense8 and Paper Girls - are often considered science fiction or action-thrillers rather than "superhero" shows. Sometimes the dividing line is rather arbitrary - e.g. movies & shows featuring non-powered, non-costumed characters like The Punisher and Agent Carter are often still considered part of the "superhero" genre merely because they came from Marvel comics, whereas most films & shows featuring vigilantes or government agents that didn't come from comic books are not.

(2) How can superhero films possibly relate to contemporary politics? Some of these stories may be consciously intended by their authors & directors to be metaphors for contemporary political issues, such as debates about war, religion, gender, race, etc. However, even superhero stories that are more fantastical still have an implicit morality and often follow Joseph Campbell's "hero's journey", and the archetypal nature of these sorts of stories can encourage more suspension of disbelief and arguably connects more with our deeper psychology, e.g. our sense of what constitutes heroism & villainy, our desires for adventure & meaning, our longing for a "re-enchantment of the world", etc. One can argue that these archetypal stories are "implicitly political" since politics is downstream from our deeper intuitions about ethics, aesthetics & meaning.

(3) Can we infer anything about the general public's underlying beliefs by looking at box office receipts for superhero films and Nielsen ratings for superhero TV shows? The general assumption we'll make is that the larger the audience of a film or TV show, the more it connected with people on an emotional level. This doesn't necessarily mean the audience agreed with the director's intended message, but it suggests something spoke to them - even if it was unintended. However, some films with a weak message may have still attracted large audiences due to the star power of some A-list actors, impressive special effects, and audience buy-in to an existing franchise. Other films with a stronger message may have flopped merely due to bad timing in their release date or some bad editing that got fixed with a director's cut, so we may want to look at streaming numbers for older films that have reemerged as "cult classics", particularly those not affiliated with either the Marvel or DC cinematic universes (e.g. Unbreakable, Sin City, Jumper, Hancock, Push, Watchmen, Kick-Ass).

(4) Given that audience reactions to films & TV shows and fan theories can vary quite a bit even among those who saw the exact same story, how can we determine which messages the audience took away from a particular work of fiction? This is the hardest question to adequately answer, although I've linked some studies under each section below that try to address this question.

We can often find empirical studies that delve into the demographics of who watches different film genres - e.g. a Morning Consult study from 2021 found that Marvel movie fans are mostly white (69%) but only slightly more likely to be male (53%). A plurality of the fan base are Millennials (40%), a quarter are Baby Boomers, another quarter are Gen Xers, but Gen Zers account for just 9% of Marvel fans -- suggesting the youth may be suffering from "superhero fatigue". Among political identifications, Marvel fans are most likely to be Democrats (41%), ahead of independents (33%) and Republicans (27%). There's also a 2015 study of "geek culture" - which includes comic book fandom - found an association with narcissism & escapism, and noted that while geeks tend to "have high trust in the government, [they] show less political knowledge and are markedly less involved in the political process (campaigns, voting, etc.)."

We should note that since social scientists don't typically run randomized control trials with movies, we're often left with a "chicken & egg problem" - i.e. it's often not clear whether watching superhero films changed people's minds, or whether specific types of people tend to prefer this genre. In many cases, we'll have to make educated guesses about audience reactions by extrapolating from reviews by journalists & bloggers and online discussions on social media. We should probably keep our opinions on the social effects of movies & TV shows somewhat agnostic until we've got better empirical studies -- but that doesn't mean we can't have some fun speculating until then!

RELEVANT MATERIAL FROM PAST MEETUPS:

We had a meetup back in January entitled "Is Politics Downstream from (Pop) Culture?"where we reviewed some of the basic concepts from media effects theory, and then looked at the debates over the social effects of sex, drugs & violence in mass media, the Marxist argument that pop culture serves as an "opiate of the masses", and the recent debate over diversity in pop culture. We also looked at how the gatekeeping abilities of creators & critics may have weakened as online fandoms arose in the 21st century, allowing the public to reinterpret pop culture and even demand changes (e.g. Zack Snyder's cut of "Justice League").

In August, we had a meetup entitled "The Politics of Police & Crime Dramas" as discussed to what extent movies & TV shows shape the general public's views of policing, the criminal underworld, justice system & prisons. In the 1st section on policing, we looked at whether shows like "The Wire" and "The Shield" that show police breaking the law & abusing suspects in order to make arrests ends up motivating viewers to understand the need for policing reforms, or whether it just makes them think "sometimes cops have to get their hands dirty." This also applies to the crime-fighting in superhero movies, since it's almost inevitably a portrayal of vigilantism.

Back in May, we had a meetup on "The Implicit Politics of Sci-Fi" where we discussed the ways the science fiction films of the 21st century offer a dystopian critique of authoritarian governments & powerful mega-corporations, reflect a growing interest in alternative spirituality & environmental concerns, and help us think about the risks & benefits of new technologies. Some scholars have pointed out how both science fiction & superhero films appear to cater to a form of post-Christian spirituality. Many superheroes bear a surprising resemblance to pagan heroes & deities from Greco-Roman & Norse mythology, albeit with sci-fi origins for their powers.

Back in March, we had a meetup on "The Implicit Politics of Historical Epics & Fantasy Films" where we discussed the ways the fantasy & epic films of the 21st century have reflected ongoing debates about the War on Terror, religious conflict, Occupy-era class conflict, and the "woke" vs "anti-woke" fight over identity politics. Both fantasy & superhero films are often accused of catering to the public's taste for juvenile escapism in a critical period of history when adults should've been paying more attention to the hard questions of politics.

Back in Oct. 2022, we had a meetup on "The Implicit Politics of Horror Films" where we discussed the ways horror films of the 21st century have reflected post-9/11 anxieties about terrorism & invasion, conservative fears about secularization & immorality, and progressive fears about misogyny & racism. In the 4th section, we discussed the black identity crisis around "staying black" versus "acting white" inherent in Jordan Peele's films "Get Out" and "Us", and a version of this also appears in some superhero films where black protagonists face down black villains, e.g. "Black Panther" and "Luke Cage".

DIRECTIONS ON HOW TO PREPARE FOR OUR DISCUSSION:

The videos & articles you see linked below are intended to give you a basic overview of some of the major debates over the implicit social & political ideologies in comic books & superhero films of the 21st century. As usual, I certainly don't expect you to read all the articles prior to attending our discussion. The easiest way to prepare for our discussion is to just watch the numbered videos linked under each section - the videos come to about about 51 minutes total. The articles marked with asterisks are just there to supply additional details. You can browse and look at whichever ones you want, but don't worry - we'll cover the stuff you missed in our discussion.

In terms of the discussion format, my general idea is that we'll address the topics in the order presented here. I've listed some questions under each section to stimulate discussion. We'll do our best to address most of them, as well as whatever other questions our members raise. I figure we'll spend about 30 minutes on each section.

***

I. IS THE POPULARITY OF SUPERHEROES A SIGN OF WIDESPREAD IMMATURITY - OR JUST ANOTHER "GENRE CYCLE"?

  • DID A TREND TOWARDS DELAYED ADULTHOOD AND/OR THE SHOCKS OF 9/11 & THE 2008 FINANCIAL CRISIS LEAD AUDIENCES TO SEEK ESCAPE INTO THE JUVENILE POWER FANTASIES & MORAL SIMPLICITY OF SUPERHERO & FANTASY FILMS? IS THIS UNLIKE THE MORE SERIOUS FILMS ENJOYED BY ADULTS IN THE 20th CENTURY, OR DOES THIS OVERLOOK THE ESCAPIST MUSICALS, COMEDIES, EPICS & WESTERNS ENJOYED BY AUDIENCES IN THE 1940s-50s?
  • SHOULD WE BE CONCERNED ABOUT FORMULAIC, I.P.-DRIVEN "CINEMATIC UNIVERSES" SQUEEZING OUT MID-BUDGET MOVIES THAT WERE MORE EXPERIMENTAL & HAD MORE SERIOUS "HIGH ART" THEMES? CAN SUPERHERO FILMS INCORPORATE SERIOUS THEMES (E.G. WATCHMEN, DARK KNIGHT, JOKER)?
  • DO SUPERHERO FILMS SIGNAL THE PUBLIC'S DANGEROUS DESIRE FOR A POPULIST STRONGMAN, OR DOES THE RISE OF CAUTIONARY TALES INVOLVING SUPERHEROES (E.G. WATCHMEN, BATMAN VS SUPERMAN, CAPTAIN AMERICA: CIVIL WAR, THE BOYS, INVINCIBLE) SUGGEST THE PUBLIC HAS BECOME MORE CRITICAL OF THIS CONCENTRATION OF POWER IN THE HANDS OF ONE PERSON?

1a) Wisecrack, "Did Marvel Kill Cinema?" (video - 16:50 min, start at 2:01 & listen to 9:32)
.
1b) The Take, "Superhero Movie Tropes, Explained" (video - 25:14 min, start at 7:30 & listen to 11:00)
.

II. IS THE ELITISM & VIGILANTISM OF MANY COMICS & SUPERHERO MOVIES IMPLICITLY CONSERVATIVE OR REACTIONARY?

  • CONSIDERING MOST COMIC BOOK WRITERS (OTHER THAN STEVE DITKO & FRANK MILLER) & MOST SUPERHERO FILM DIRECTORS ARE LIBERALS, WHY DO THEY STILL OFTEN VALORIZE WHITE MALE BILLIONAIRES, VIGILANTES & SUPER-SOLDIERS?
  • ARE MOST SUPERHEROES EFFECTIVELY "GUARDIANS OF THE STATUS QUO" THAT WON'T USE THEIR POWERS TO IMPROVE THE WORLD? ARE SUPERVILLAINS (E.G. BANE, VULTURE, ULTRON, KILLMONGER, GORR THE GOD-BUTCHER, FLAG-SMASHER) GIVEN REVOLUTIONARY MOTIVES AS A WAY OF COVERTLY CASTING ASPERSION ON THEIR REAL-LIFE COUNTERPARTS?
  • ARE COMIC BOOK PLOTS WHERE THE GOV'T ATTEMPTS TO "REGISTER" & REIGN IN SUPERHEROES (E.G. X-MEN, CIVIL WAR) COMPARABLE TO FASCIST ATTEMPTS TO SINGLE OUT MINORITIES OR LIBERAL ATTEMPTS AT GUN CONTROL & NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT?
  • WHY DID MANY LIBERAL FILM CRITICS INTERPRET "JOKER" AS PANDERING TO INCELS & THE ALT-RIGHT? HAS IDENTITY POLITICS BLINDED THEM TO WHITE MALE VICTIMS OF CLASSISM?

2.) Pop Culture Detective, "Marvel's Defenders of The Status Quo" (video - 21:58 min, listen to 13:45)
.

III. HAVE SUPERHERO FILMS POPULARIZED FEMINIST IDEALS OR ANNOYED AUDIENCES WITH TOO-PERFECT "MARY SUES"?

  • DID 'CATWOMAN' (2004) & 'ELEKTRA' (2005) FLOP DUE TO AUDIENCES NOT APPRECIATING FEMALE SUPERHEROES - AND WAS THERE A SHIFT THAT ENABLED 'WONDER WOMAN' (2017) & 'CAPTAIN MARVEL' (2019) TO BE HITS? OR WAS IT MOSTLY DUE TO IMPROVE WRITING?
  • DO FEMALE SUPERHEROES HAVE TO BE SEXY & FEMININE TO BE LIKED BY AUDIENCES, OR DOES CAPTAIN MARVEL DISPROVE THAT?
  • DID PLOTLINES WHERE PHOENIX & SCARLET WITCH GO CRAZY (OR HARLEY QUINN IS ALWAYS CRAZY) SUGGEST OUTDATED STEREOTYPES, OR WERE THEY MERELY TRYING TO MAKE THEM MORE COMPLEX?
  • ARE FEMALE SUPERHEROES NEEDED FOR YOUNG GIRLS TO HAVE ROLE MODELS, OR DOES THIS PRESENT AN UNATTAINABLE GOAL?

3.) The Take, "Why Superheroine Movies Don't Empower Us All" (video - 20:22 min, listen to 8:45)
.

IV. HAVE SUPERHERO FILMS AVOIDED TOKENISM & PROMOTED RACIAL TOLERANCE OR JUST REINFORCED STEREOTYPES?

  • DID IT TAKE BLM & THE "GREAT AWOKENING" TO MAKE BLACK SUPERHEROES ACCEPTABLE TO WHITE AUDIENCES, OR DID THE MODEST SUCCESS OF SPAWN (1997) AND THE BLADE TRILOGY (1998, 2002, 2004) SUGGEST IT WAS POSSIBLE MUCH EARLIER?
  • IS WAKANDA AN ETHNO-NATIONALIST FANTASY COMPARABLE TO TRUMP'S AGENDA THAT WAS POPULAR WITH LIBERAL AUDIENCES MERELY BECAUSE IT WAS RUN BY NON-WHITES, AS SOME CONSERVATIVE CRITICS ALLEGED?
  • DID BLACK PANTHER'S CONFLICT WITH KILLMONGER & FALCON'S CONFLICT WITH THE FLAG-SMASHERS IMPLICITLY DRAW A LINE BETWEEN 'RESPECTABLE' RACIAL REFORMS & 'DANGEROUS' REVOLTS?
  • DID HBO'S 'WATCHMEN' SERIES & NETFLIX'S 'LUKE CAGE' SERIES TAP INTO A DESIRE BY BLACK AUDIENCES TO "POLICE THEIR OWN COMMUNITY"?
  • DOES THE LACKLUSTER RESPONSE TO 'ETERNALS' (2021) & 'BLUE BEETLE' (2023) & THE CANCELLATION OF 'BATGIRL' (2022) SUGGEST BOTH MARVEL & DC ARE STARTING TO "GO WOKE & GO BROKE" BY OVER-HYPING NON-WHITE LEADS, OR IS THIS DISPROVED BY THE SUCCESS OF 'SHANG-CHI' (2021) & 'WAKANDA FOREVER' (2022)?

4a) Buzzfeed, "The Historic Rise Of Black Superheroes" (video - 6:38 min.)
.
4b) Nasu, "You DON'T Want Diversity: Ms Marvel and Miles Morales" (video - 15:04 min, listen to 12:11)
.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Related topics

Geek Culture
Movies & Discussions
Comic Books
Social Issues
Superheroes

You may also like