Skip to content

Details

This is going to be an online meetup using Zoom. If you've never used Zoom before, don't worry — it's easy to use and free to join.

Here's the link to the event: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88957829354?pwd=NmJPWEh6Q0E3Y1VtUWZLV3Zvbzladz09

Meeting ID: 889 5782 9354
Passcode: 578147

----------------------------------------------
A SKEPTICAL TAKE ON THE ORIGINS & EVOLUTION OF CHRISTMAS

INTRODUCTION:

In this meeting, we'll examine some of the historical & mythological basis of the winter solstice holiday we've come to know as Christmas and try to separate fact from fiction... Along the way, we'll see several examples of how atheists & skeptics sometimes fall for certain forms of pseudo-history in an effort to "own" the Christian conservatives in the modern culture war over the Christmas holiday by emphasizing its pagan roots and its modern ties to capitalism & consumerism.

There's some historical fallacies we should be aware of for this discussion:

  1. Parallelomania - a phenomenon where authors perceive apparent similarities and construct parallels and analogies without historical basis. It's closely related to "apophenia" (false pattern recognition) and "hyperdiffusionism" (assuming that similar technologies or ideas must've originated with a single culture & diffused around the world rather than convergent evolution).
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallelomania

  2. Euhemerism - the assumption that myths have a real basis in historical persons and events, often with the idea that this kernel of truth became exaggerated or distorted over time.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euhemerism

  3. Astrotheology - a field that explores the role that the stars, sun, moon, and other celestial bodies have played in the formation of various religious systems, sometimes (esp. in 18th-19th century) in an effort to determine a “first”/“primitive” religion based on astrological allegories - this latter part is now mostly discredited.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Astrolatry

  4. Rosy Retrospection - the psychological phenomenon of judging the past disproportionately more positively than they judge the present. When it comes to history, this nostalgia is often related to the myth of the "happy peasant" (the medieval counterpart to Rousseau's "noble savage") and "declinism" (the belief that society is becoming worse).
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosy_retrospection

  5. Cui Bono Fallacy - the false assumption that whoever benefits from something must be causing it. It ignores the possibility that people can benefit from things they didn't cause. It's somewhat related to the "furtive fallacy" (assuming history is driven by elite conspiracies).
    https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Cui_bono
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Furtive_fallacy

In the 1st section, we'll look at some theories about the pre-Christian roots of Christmas in various pagan midwinter festivals such as the Roman festival of Saturnalia, the Germanic festival of Yule, the Celtic festival of Meán Geimhridh, and the Slavic festival of Koliada. We'll look at the origins of various Christmas traditions like decorating Christmas trees, burning the Yule log, and kissing under the mistletoe. We'll also consider various theories about some pagan European figures - such as Finnish shamans or the Norse god Odin - that were allegedly combined with the story of the 4th-century Greek bishop Saint Nicholas of Myra to form our modern image of Santa Claus.

In the 2nd section, we'll look at the debates over the historicity of the New Testament's story of the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem and how this event later came to be celebrated by Christians on December 25th. We'll also consider whether the elements of the Nativity story match up with many other Near Eastern dieties, as various critics of Christianity have alleged, and whether there might be a common astrological allegory that connects various "solar dieties" with the winter solstice.

In the 3rd section, we'll look at how Europeans celebrated Advent and the Christmas season in the Middle Ages, and we'll consider whether medieval peasants actually worked less than us in the winter - after all, they had twelve days of Christmas, not just one! We'll also consider the counter-argument that this is a bit of nostalgic myth-making from a later era, part of what's come to be called the "Merrie Olde England myth". We'll also look at how Christmas changed in some areas with the rise of Protestantism and the new focus of some sects like the Calvinists & Puritans on religious austerity & sobriety. We'll discuss how this precipitated the first real "War on Christmas" in Western history, which was in a sense a Protestant war on Catholicism and its saints days and feast days. We'll see how this relates to the theories of the "Protestant work ethic" and an "Industrious Revolution" between 1600 & 1800 when Northern Europeans began to work more hours.

In the 4th section, we'll look at how the traditions of Christmas shifted in England and the United States in the 19th century and consider the claim that Victorian elites took what was a rather rowdy Catholic holiday full of drunken carousing by the working class and transformed into a semi-secular holiday centered around respectable bourgeois family gatherings and gift-giving. We'll also consider whether modern Christmas was hijacked in the early 20th century by a "capitalist conspiracy" orchestrated by companies like Macy's and Coca-Cola that used Santa Claus to encourage holiday shopping sprees.

-----------------------------------------------

DIRECTIONS ON HOW TO PREPARE FOR OUR DISCUSSION:

The videos & articles you see linked below are intended to give you a basic overview of some of the major debates over the origins of various winter holiday myths & traditions. As usual, I certainly don't expect you to read all the articles prior to attending our discussion. The easiest way to prepare for our discussion is to just watch the videos linked under each section - the videos come to about about 43 minutes total. The articles marked with asterisks are just there to supply additional details. You can browse and look at whichever ones you want, but don't worry - we'll cover the stuff you missed in our discussion.

In terms of the discussion format, my general idea is that we'll address the topics in the order presented here. I figure we'll spend about 30 minutes on each section.

----------------------------------------------
I. VARIOUS THEORIES ABOUT THE ORIGINS OF CHRISTMAS TRADITIONS IN PAGAN MIDWINTER FESTIVALS:

  • DID ASPECTS OF THE ROMAN FESTIVALS OF SATURNALIA, SUCH AS GIFT-GIVING & WILD MERRYMAKING, GET INCORPORATED INTO CHRISTMAS? DID THE "LORD OF MISRULE" ELECTED AS PART OF THE "FEAST OF FOOLS" IN THE MIDDLE AGES ON TWELFTH NIGHT HARK BACK TO THE ROMAN KING OF SATURNALIA?

  • WAS THE ROMAN CULT OF "SOL INVICTUS" & ITS CELEBRATION ON THE WINTER SOLSTICE RELATED TO SATURNALIA & LATER TO CHRISTMAS? IF SO, WHY ISN'T IT CELEBRATED ON DEC. 21-22?

  • DO THE CUSTOMS OF BURNING THE YULE LOG, DECORATING CHRISTMAS TREES & WASSAILING (SINGING & OFFERING A DRINK IN EXCHANGE FOR GIFTS) STEM FROM GERMANIC YULE CELEBRATIONS?

  • DOES KISSING UNDER THE MISTLETOE HAVE ANCIENT CELTIC ROOTS, OR IS THIS A 19th CENT. ADDITION TO CHRISTMAS CELEBRATIONS?

  • HOW PLAUSIBLE IS IT THAT SANTA CLAUS IS BASED ON FINNISH SHAMANS WHO HERDED REINDEER & IMBIBED RED & WHITE CAPPED MUSHROOMS (AMANITA MUSCARIA) TO GO ON SPIRIT JOURNEYS WHICH FELT LIKE FLYING? OR WERE SANTA'S RED & WHITE SUIT & HIS REINDEER ONLY ADDED IN THE 19th CENTURY?

  • HOW PLAUSIBLE IS IT THAT SANTA CLAUS IS PARTLY BASED ON THE NORSE GOD ODIN, E.G. HIS ROLE AS THE LEADER OF THE "WILD HUNT", WHICH COULD BE ANALOGOUS TO SANTA'S FLIGHT AROUND THE WORLD TO DELIVER PRESENTS? COULD ODIN'S 8-LEGGED HORSE BE THE ORIGIN OF SANTA'S 8 REINDEER? OR ARE THESE MYTHS TOO DIFFERENT?

  1. Telltale Atheist, "Is Christmas A Pagan Holiday?" (video - 10:00 min.)
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzydj6-cLbg

.
II. THE HISTORICITY OF THE BIBLICAL NATIVITY STORY & THEORIES OF JESUS AS A SOLAR DEITY:

  • DO HISTORIANS THINK THE ROMAN CENSUS OF QUIRINIUS THAT SUPPOSEDLY LED MARY & JOSEPH TO RETURN TO BETHLEHEM WAS A REAL EVENT?

  • DO HISTORIANS THINK THAT KING HEROD ARCHELAUS MIGHT'VE ORDERED A "MASSACRE OF THE INNOCENTS" IN HIS BRIEF REIGN (4 B.C.E. - 6 C.E.)? IS IT TRUE THAT, BASED ON THE POPULATION OF BETHLEHEM & THE PROBABLE BIRTH RATE & INFANT MORTALITY RATE, THE "MASSACRE" MAY HAVE JUST BEEN 20 OR SO INFANTS, AS CATHOLIC SCHOLARS ARGUED? WHY WOULDN'T JOSEPHUS INCLUDE THIS INCIDENT IN HIS "ANTIQUITIES OF THE JEWS" (94 C.E.), DESPITE RECORDING MANY OF HEROD'S MISDEEDS?

  • HOW SHOULD WE EVALUATE THE VARIOUS THEORIES ABOUT THE BETHLEHEM STAR AS A REAL ASTRONOMICAL PHENOMENON (E.G. METEOR, SUPERNOVA, COMET, PLANETARY CONJUNCTION) AS OPPOSED TO A MIRACULOUS SYMBOL OF A DIVINE BIRTH? ARE THERE ANY NON-BIBLICAL SOURCES FOR AN ASTRONOMICAL ANOMALY SOMEWHERE BETWEEN 4 B.C. AND 6 A.D.?

  • HOW DID THE BIBLICAL PASSAGES ABOUT SEVERAL MAGI SEEING A BRIGHT STAR & BRINGING 3 GIFTS TO MARY & JOSEPH EVOLVE INTO LEGENDS ABOUT "THREE KINGS" NAMED CASPAR, MELCHIOR & BALTHAZAR FOLLOWING THE STAR TO BETHLEHEM FROM ASIA, EUROPE & AFRICA?

  • DO KEY ELEMENTS OF THE BIBLICAL STORY OF THE NATIVITY & THE LIFE OF JESUS MATCH UP WITH THE STORIES OF MANY OTHER NEAR EASTERN DEITIES (E.G. HORUS, DIONYSUS, ATTIS, MITHRA), AS CLAIMED IN PETER JOSEPH'S "ZEITGEIST" FILM, OR ARE THESE PARALLELS MOSTLY EXAGGERATED OR JUST WRONG?

  • DID MANY ANCIENT CULTURES USE MYTHS OF "SOLAR DIETIES" AS MERE ASTROLOGICAL ALLEGORIES FOR TRACKING SOLSTICES & EQUINOXES? OR DID THEY LITERALLY BELIEVE IN SUN GODS & USE THEM TO EXPLAIN DAY & NIGHT?

  • IS THE "SON OF GOD = SUN GOD" ETYMOLOGY THAT PETER JOSEPH USES IN HIS "ZEITGEIST" FILM VALID, OR DO THE TERMS FOR "SON" & "SUN" DIFFER IN MOST ANCIENT LANGUAGES?

  • WHY DID THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH DECIDE IN THE REIGN OF CONSTANTINE (C. 336 C.E.) TO CELEBRATE JESUS'S BIRTH ON DEC. 25th? WAS IT TO CANCEL OUT PAGAN FESTIVALS LIKE YULE & SATURNALIA, OR BECAUSE THEY THOUGHT JESUS WAS CONCEIVED ON THE ANNUNCIATION (MAR. 25) & THUS MUST'VE BEEN BORN 9 MONTHS LATER? WHY DO SOME ORTHODOX CHURCHES CELEBRATE CHRISTMAS ON JAN. 7th?

2a) Smithsonian Channel, "Did Historians Get Jesus' Birthdate Wrong?" (video - 3:08 min.)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvX4ZydvThk

2b) Aaron Adair, "The Star of Bethlehem & Zeitgeist - Is It True?" (video - 6:35 min.)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LUr0IFF6_48

.
III. SEPARATING HISTORY FROM MYTHS ABOUT XMAS IN THE MIDDLE AGES & THE EARLY MODERN ERA:

  • IS IT TRUE THAT MEDIEVAL PEASANTS ONLY HAD TO WORK 150 DAYS A YEAR AND GOT 12 DAYS OF XMAS VACATION? OR DOES THIS OVERLOOK THE WORK THEY HAD TO DO FOR THEIR OWN HOUSEHOLDS?

  • WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE CONDITIONS IN THE WINTER MONTHS FOR MEDIEVAL PEASANTS? WERE STARVATION, SICKNESS & FREEZING MAJOR CONCERNS?

  • TO WHAT EXTENT IS "MERRIE ENGLAND" A NOSTALGIC MYTH ABOUT PRE-REFORMATION ENGLAND?

  • WAS CATHOLICISM SO SUPPRESSED AFTER THE "ACT OF UNIFORMITY" (1559) THAT CATHOLICS HAD TO USE THE "12 DAYS OF XMAS" SONG AS A MNEMONIC DEVICE TO TEACH CATECHISM?

  • WHY DID OLIVER CROMWELL & THE PARLIAMENTARIANS TRY TO BAN XMAS IN THE 1640s? DID THE "PLUM PUDDING RIOT" (CANTERBURY, 1647) SHOW THAT THE HOLIDAY BAN MADE THE MASSES TURN AGAINST THEM, LEADING TO THE RESTORATION OF KING CHARLES I IN 1660?

  • DID PROTESTANTISM LEAD TO LESS HOLIDAYS & MORE WORK DAYS, TRIGGERING AN "INDUSTRIOUS REVOLUTION" IN THE 17th-18th CENTURIES? DID WORKERS CONSUME MORE AS WELL, THANKS TO COTTAGE INDUSTRIES & THE "COMMERCIAL REVOLUTION" THAT INCREASED TRADE?

3a) Timeline w/ Tony Robinson, "The Gruelling Medieval Jobs At Christmas Time" (video - 47:32 min, start at 9:50 & listen to 19:30)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b_autVoFg-0&t=9m50s

3b) Derek Van Hise, "Why the Pilgrims Hated Christmas" (video - 4:10 min.)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Osi5m58bas8

.
IV. THEORIES ABOUT THE VICTORIAN-ERA TAMING OF CHRISTMAS INTO A FESTIVAL FOR BOURGEOIS FAMILIES & CAPITALISM:

  • DID THE ANONYMITY CAUSED BY URBANIZATION CHANGE THE NATURE OF "WASSAILING" - I.E. CAROLING MIXED WITH DRUNKEN TRICK-OR-TREATING BY OUT-OF-WORK FARMHANDS - AND MAKE IT SEEM MORE THREATENING TO ELITES? WERE THEY AFRAID FESTIVALS THAT INVOLVED SOCIAL LEVELING COULD LEAD TO CIVIL UNREST?

  • WHY DID NEW YORK LITERARY ELITES LIKE WASHINGTON IRVING & CLARK CLEMENT MOORE APPROPRIATE THE DUTCH "SINTERKLASS" FOR AMERICAN USE AS "SANTA CLAUS"? WAS IT BECAUSE ST. NICHOLAS SEEMED TOO "PAPIST" & FATHER CHRISTMAS TOO "DIONYSIAN"?

  • DID IRVING & MOORE, ALONG WITH THE PHILANTHROPIST JONATHAN PINTARD, RECOGNIZE A NEED FOR THE WORKING CLASS TO ENJOY SOME LEISURE, BUT IN A TAMER WAY CENTERED ON THE FAMILY? IF SO, WERE THEY ABLE TO PULL OFF A "CONSPIRACY" TO TRANSFORM THE HOLIDAY, OR WERE THEY MERELY NOTICING WHAT BROADER SOCIAL & ECONOMIC FORCES WERE DOING?

  • WAS CHARLES DICKENS' DEPICTION OF SCROOGE IN "A CHRISTMAS CAROL" (1843) A CRITIQUE OF THE STINGINESS & "ALL WORK, NO PLAY" ASPECTS OF THE PROTESTANT WORK ETHIC & DOG-EAT-DOG CAPITALISM, OR MERELY AS A WAY OF URGING THE WEALTHY TO ENGAGE IN SOME CHARITY?

  • DID AMERICAN ELITES HOPE THAT XMAS TREES WOULD BE AN "ANTIDOTE TO CONSUMERISM" BY CONFINING GIFT-GIVING TO THE FAMILY & TEACHING CHILDREN RESTRAINT BY NOT LETTING THEM OPEN THEIR PRESENTS UNTIL XMAS DAY? DID THIS BACKFIRE WHEN THE XMAS TREE BUSINESS TOOK OFF IN THE 1890s?

  • HOW WAS SANTA CLAUS REIMAGINED IN AMERICAN ADVERTISEMENTS IN THE LATE 19th CENTURY? WAS THIS PART OF A "CONSPIRACY" BY RETAIL STORES TO TURN XMAS INTO A TIME OF SHOPPING SPREES & GIFT-GIVING TO BOOST THEIR SALES? OR WERE THEY JUST BENEFITING FROM THE INCREASED DISPOSABLE INCOME THE WORKING & MIDDLE CLASSES HAD BY THIS TIME?

  • DID COCA-COLA INVENT THE MODERN IMAGE OF SANTA CLAUS AS A JOLLY FAT MAN IN A RED & WHITE SUIT FOR THEIR ADS IN THE 1930s? OR WERE THEY DRAWING ON IMAGES ESTABLISHED IN THE 19th CENTURY?

4a) Discerning History, "History of Christmas Part 2: Charles Dickens to Christmas Trees" (video - 5:12 min, start at 0:43)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwLceKmO2Hc&t=43s

4b) This Is, "How Coke Invented Santa Claus" (video - 5:05 min.)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Vj_fD9zVVg

................................................................

Related topics

Freethinkers Humanists & Atheists
Critical Thinking
History
Mythology
Religion

You may also like