Parlour Series: Citizens' Assemblies
Details
Parlour series events are hosted in members' homes, so they work a little differently from our public events. The group size will be smaller, so we give preference to people who have recently attended another event. If you're interested in joining, please add yourself to the waitlist!
The address will be posted as a private comment below, visible only to attendees. It is near the location pin that is visible publicly.
Please note that for this event, we may sit out on a patio if the weather is nice, so please dress accordingly. Also, the hosts have a couple of friendly dogs!
Let’s consider:
- When someone acts or speaks "on behalf of" a group, what makes that act genuinely representative rather than merely a substitution of one person's judgment for another's—must the group have authorized it, resemble the representative, be able to revoke the arrangement, or something else?
- Is a representative supposed to enact what their constituents want, exercise independent judgment about what is good for them, or mirror what the constituents themselves would conclude if they had the time and information to deliberate—and are these the same thing?
- The framers of modern republics often defended representation not as a regrettable concession to size but as an improvement on direct rule—a way to refine and filter popular opinion. Is representation a second-best substitute for everyone deciding directly, or can it produce something direct democracy cannot?
- Direct democracy asks citizens to decide questions themselves; a republic asks them to choose who decides. What is gained and what is lost in that delegation, and does the answer change with the scale of the community or the complexity of the question?
- Sortition fills a role by lottery rather than by vote or appointment. In what kinds of decisions does randomness seem appropriate or even fairer than choice, and in which does it seem to abdicate a judgment we ought to make deliberately?
- The criminal jury is a familiar body of randomly selected ordinary people given real power over a consequential decision. Why do we trust lay citizens to decide guilt and innocence, and does whatever justifies that trust extend to deciding questions of policy?
- Can a body chosen by lottery can be as legitimate as one chosen by election? If so, what exactly is the source of its legitimacy—that it resembles the population, that anyone could have been chosen, that it deliberates well, or that it has no stake in being reelected?
- Elections give the losing side a reason to accept an outcome they dislike: they consented to the procedure and can contest the next one. Does sortition offer an equivalent source of legitimacy for those who disagree with an assembly's conclusion?
- Landemore argues, on epistemic grounds, that ordinary citizens deliberating together can reach better decisions than experts or elected elites, because cognitive diversity among the many outperforms the ability of the few. Under what conditions would you expect that claim to hold, and under what conditions might diversity fail to beat concentrated expertise?
- Landemore characterizes existing representative democracy as "closed"—structurally designed to keep ordinary people out of power, with elections serving as much to select an elite as to empower the public. Is that an accurate description of electoral systems, or does it understate what elections accomplish?
No homework required, but if you’d like to reflect ahead of time, you can listen to this podcast episode: The Ezra Klein Show - A Radical Proposal for True Democracy (link here and a backup link in the comments for attendees):
Shy Philosopher Night Procedure and Code of Ethics:
1. Discussion Style
We aim for a cooperative flow, like passing a ball among teammates rather than engaging in back-and-forth debates. Please share the “ball” so everyone has a voice.
2. Brief Points (2-3 Minutes)
Keep points concise so we can hear a variety of perspectives. Occasional exceptions may come up naturally, but our goal is inclusivity.
3. No Crosstalk
Respect the speaker’s time without interjecting or questioning mid-speech. If you’d like to add something, simply raise your hand and the facilitator will guide the flow.
4. Avoid Ad Hominem Remarks
Focus critiques on ideas, actions, or beliefs—not people. For example, say “This idea could have certain impacts” rather than “You’re wrong.” This ensures a respectful environment.
5. Respectful Engagement
As we are guests in someone’s home, let’s maintain a high level of respect for the space and one another. Mindfulness, patience, and courtesy are essential to making this gathering comfortable and enjoyable for all.
6. Cancellation Courtesy
If your plans change and you’re unable to attend, please let us know at least a day in advance by canceling your RSVP. Since space is limited, early notice helps ensure that someone else interested can join in your place. We really appreciate your understanding and help in making this a smooth, inclusive experience for everyone.
Looking forward to seeing you there!
