The Buzz Lightyear Delusion: A Crisis of Identity & Purpose

We will be meeting at Southeast Regional - Room C!

Join us for a trip "to infinity... and beyond!" as we explore the fascinating themes behind Toy Story (1995), featuring the iconic duo Woody and Buzz Lightyear!

Please note: We will not be watching the movie during the event, nor is viewing it beforehand required.

## Brief Summary

Woody, a classic cowboy doll and the long-time favorite toy, has his world turned upside down by the arrival of Buzz Lightyear, a shiny new space ranger. A bitter rivalry born of jealousy leaves them stranded in the outside world, forcing them to cooperate to survive. To get back to their owner Andy before he moves, they must escape a destructive neighbor and confront what it truly means to be a toy.

***

## Philosophical Discussion Questions:

### Questions on Toy Story

#### 🤠 Theme 1: The Favorite (Jealousy, Status, and Leadership)

1. At the start, is Woody a good leader for the toy community, or is he just a benevolent dictator who enjoys his status as "the favorite"?
2. Woody's jealousy causes him to (accidentally) push Buzz out the window. Are his actions forgivable? Is deep jealousy a "villainous" emotion?
3. The other toys turn on Woody instantly, led by Mr. Potato Head. Was this mob mentality, or was the community justified in casting him out?
4. Woody has "Andy" written on his boot, which gives him immense value and status. How much of our own "specialness" or self-worth is based on being "chosen" by someone else (a boss, a partner, a parent)?
5. To regain his place, Woody has to team up with his rival and adapt. What does the movie say about how established leaders should (or must) react to change?

#### 🚀 Theme 2: The Shattered Mirror (Buzz's Crisis of Identity)

6. Buzz Lightyear begins with a strong, but false, identity (a "Space Ranger"). Woody has a "real," but simpler, identity (a "toy"). Which character is happier or better off at the beginning of the movie, and why?
7. When Buzz sees the TV commercial, his entire reality breaks. Is it always better to know the truth, even if that truth is devastating and shatters your purpose?
8. After his crash, Buzz goes into his "Mrs. Nesbitt" phase. Is this scene just a joke, or is it a surprisingly accurate portrayal of a genuine mental breakdown?
9. Woody tells Buzz: "Being a toy is a lot better than being a Space Ranger." What does he mean by this? Is he correct?
10. By the end, Buzz has accepted he is a toy and finds a new purpose. Is this new, "real" identity better or worse than his original, "false" one? Did he gain something or lose something by accepting reality?

#### 👽 Theme 3: The Outsider (Community vs. "The Other")

11. The toys are terrified of Sid's "mutant toys," assuming they are monsters or cannibals. What does this reaction tell us about how we treat those who look "broken" or different from us?
12. The "mutant toys" turn out to be helpful, kind, and masters of fixing things. What does it take for a community to overcome its prejudice against those it doesn't understand?
13. When Buzz first arrives, Woody sees him as a threat. Buzz sees Woody as an obstacle. Why is the "newcomer" so often seen as a rival in an established social group?
14. Sid is the "villain." But is he evil, or is he just a creative, curious (and maybe destructive) kid who doesn't know the toys are alive? What is his actual "crime"?
15. The "mutant toys" build a new, functional society from broken parts. Are they "damaged," or have they simply found a different kind of purpose than Andy's toys, who wait to be played with?

#### 📦 Theme 4: The Purpose of Play (Consciousness and "Enlightenment")

16. The toys' greatest fear is being replaced or "obsolete." Is a life defined entirely by someone else's approval (Andy's love) a fulfilling life?
17. What do you believe is the true purpose of a toy's life in this movie? Is it just to be played with, or do they have a higher calling to each other?
18. Andy is essentially a "god" to the toys. Is he a good god? What kind of "theology" do the toys seem to practice (e.g., fear of the "move," salvation by being "chosen")?
19. The toys "come alive" only when humans aren't looking. Why do you think this "rule" exists? What does it say about having a private self or a "secret life"?
20. At the very end, the toys use a "Magic 8-Ball" to guess their new presents. Have they truly learned anything, or are they doomed to repeat the same cycle of anxiety and jealousy every Christmas?