Skip to content

Details

The Deobfuscating State Surveillance project aims to map out state surveillance capabilities in Canada and the laws that govern them (or do not). Initially started during the COVID-19 pandemic with collaborators in Canada and the UK, the research has been a slow and gradual process, like much research initiated during the COVID-19 pandemic. Taking advantage of Canada’s access-to-information system, we spent three years diving into government procurement and requested over $750 million worth of federal contracts with manufacturers of a wide array of surveillance technology. To date, only 45% of our requests have been fulfilled. That said, the information which has been given to us is extraordinary.

Among the variety of contracts we have been provided with are a series of contracts with manufacturers of mobile forensic devices (MFDs) – tools shown to be pervasively used by police forces across the United States which can be used to circumvent any security feature on a modern smartphone, tablet or computer. Often used as a software/hardware apparatus, a hardware device can be used to make a copy of, for instance, a smartphone, and any information on or connected to that phone (social media, cloud storage accounts, email, contacts, GPS history, search history and more) can be later extracted. While it may not be surprising to see tools such as these being used by police forces in Canada, we were struck by the unusual diversity of federal agencies who had purchased and were ostensibly using these devices. What could the CRTC, the Competition Bureau, Fisheries and Oceans Canada and as number of others (13 in total) possibly be doing with what is essentially military-grade cellphone hacking tools?

In the summer of 2023, we shared a recent subset of these contracts with a trusted investigative journalist at Radio-Canada who then picked up the investigation and published a series of explosive stories on both Radio-Canada and CBC. As shown in this reporting, these tools have been used in violation of a 2002 directive of the Treasury Board stating that if agencies were using privacy-invasive tools, these tools had to be subjected to a Privacy Impact Assessment (PIA) before they were put into use. PIAs are crucial tools for determining if the use of such a tool is necessary and proportional. The reporting also showed that many agencies stated that they used this technology on their own employees.

On November 30, 2023, Radio-Canada and CBC ran stories on this situation on radio, television and online in English and French. One week later, House of Commons Standing Committee on Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics voted unanimously to conduct a study on the use of this technology and to call before it the heads of the 13 agencies involved to testify. As a result of this study, the Treasury Board changed their policy regarding privacy-invasive technologies by federal government agencies, requiring them to now develop Privacy Impact Assessments. According our more recent research, though, the majority of the agencies we found to be using mobile device forensic tools have still not done so. How, then, do we convince government to regulate itself?

Evan Light
https://ischool.utoronto.ca/faculty-profile/light-evan/
Associate Professor
Faculty of Information & Schwartz Reisman Institute for Technology and Society
University of Toronto

About the Speaker:

Evan Light’s research centres on democratizing technology and policy for positive social change. A researcher, artist, and translator, his works have been exhibited in Europe, the UK and North America. His original writings and translations have appeared in peer-reviewed journals and books in Africa, Latin America, Europe and North America. His research on the use of cellphone hacking tools by federal agencies in Canada led to a series of parliamentary committee hearings, changes to Treasury Board policies on privacy-invasive technologies and proposed changes to the Privacy Act and Access to Information Act. He is also engaged in collaborative research on facial recognition, emerging forms of biometrics and technology regulation, and indoor air quality.

Light received his PhD from the Université du Québec à Montréal in 2013 and was a post-doctoral fellow at Concordia University’s Mobile Media Lab (2014-2016). He was previously an associate professor and director of the communications program at York University’s Glendon campus as well as director of the Deobfuscating State Surveillance project.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

This is a talk with audience Q&A presented by the University of Toronto's Centre for Ethics that is free to attend and open to the public. Free refreshments will be provided at the event. The talk will also be streamed online with live chat here [to be posted].

About the Centre for Ethics (http://ethics.utoronto.ca):

The Centre for Ethics is an interdisciplinary centre aimed at advancing research and teaching in the field of ethics, broadly defined. The Centre seeks to bring together the theoretical and practical knowledge of diverse scholars, students, public servants and social leaders in order to increase understanding of the ethical dimensions of individual, social, and political life.

In pursuit of its interdisciplinary mission, the Centre fosters lines of inquiry such as (1) foundations of ethics, which encompasses the history of ethics and core concepts in the philosophical study of ethics; (2) ethics in action, which relates theory to practice in key domains of social life, including bioethics, business ethics, and ethics in the public sphere; and (3) ethics in translation, which draws upon the rich multiculturalism of the City of Toronto and addresses the ethics of multicultural societies, ethical discourse across religious and cultural boundaries, and the ethics of international society.

The Ethics of A.I. Lab at the Centre For Ethics recently appeared on a list of 10 organizations leading the way in ethical A.I.: https://ocean.sagepub.com/blog/10-organizations-leading-the-way-in-ethical-ai

Related topics

Events in Toronto, ON
Artificial Intelligence
Intellectual Discussions
Ethics
Technology
Political Science

You may also like