Skip to content

Details

(Scroll down for topic intro)

THE VENUE: Caffè Nero

It is now autumn, so we will meet indoors for the next few months.

When we meet indoors, we run the same event in two locations: Caffè Nero and Starbucks, so as to provide capacity for as many people who would like to attend, without overwhelming any one venue. Thus, there will be two events published, and you can choose which one to attend. Please don't sign up for both. This event is for the Nero location.

Note that we may combine the events if one location attracts too few signups. Look out for updates nearer the time. The locations are only 2 minutes apart.

We meet upstairs at Caffè Nero. An organiser will be present from 10.45. We are not charged for use of the space so it would be good if everyone bought at least one drink.

An attendee limit has been set so as not to overwhelm the venue.

Etiquette
Our discussions are friendly and open. We are a discussion group, not a for-and-against debating society. But it helps if we try to stay on topic. And we should not talk over others, interrupt them, or try to dominate the conversation.

There is often a waiting list for places, so please cancel your attendance as soon as possible if you subsequently find you can't come.

WhatsApp groups
We have two WhatsApp groups. One is to notify events, including extra events such as meeting for a meal or a drink during the week which we don't normally put on the Meetup site. The other is for open discussion of whatever topics occur to people. If you would like to join either or both groups, please send a note of the phone number you would like to use to Richard Baron on: website.audible238@passmail.net. (This is an alias that can be discarded if it attracts spam, hence the odd words.)

THE TOPIC: The Generation Study: How much should we know about our genetic future?

Thank you Zee for suggesting this week's topic and preparing this introduction.

Every year hundreds of babies are born in the UK with rare genetic conditions. Early intervention can enhance the health and quality of life of many of these babies. But these conditions can be hard to diagnose, leading to delays in care.

The Generation Study is a research programme being delivered by Genomics England in partnership with the NHS. It aims to recruit 100,000 newborn babies and screen them for over 200 genetic conditions. Recruitment began in 2024 and the study is currently scheduled to run until March 2027. The study aims to facilitate the earlier identification of rare genetic conditions in babies, to gather genomic data for wider research purposes and to explore the risks and benefits of storing an individual’s genome over their lifetime.

So far, over 20,000 participants have joined the study and more than 60 ‘condition suspected results’ have been returned by Genomics England to the NHS for confirmatory testing

Success Stories
Baby with rare eye cancer diagnosed and receiving lifechanging treatment earlier after genomic sequencing at birth

Freddie is one child who has benefitted from being part of the study.
Four weeks after being born at the Jessop Wing at Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust in April and having his genome sequenced, Freddie was diagnosed with hereditary retinoblastoma, caused by a change in his RB1 gene. Freddie was a normal little baby and had passed all his eye tests in the hospital. Very shortly after his diagnosis, Freddie was able to start treatment. This gives doctors the best chance to minimise the impact on his vision.

The Generation Study – medical breakthrough or the beginning of a new ethical dilemma?

If we can identify a child's potential health problems through their DNA before they are even old enough to understand what DNA is, should we do it?

The positive arguments – why this could be a major breakthrough

  • Saving lives and preventing suffering: Gives children access to treatment earlier
  • Better medical research: Scientists can learn more about rare diseases and develop better treatments for future generations
  • Helping families: Families can prepare for medical challenges
  • Better healthcare for the future: Better understanding of diseases could improve NHS services

The negative arguments – what should make us cautious?

  • Can we really trust the government with our DNA?
  • Our DNA is perhaps the most personal information we possess. It can reveal information not just about us, but about our biological relatives.
  • We might trust the people running the study today, but governments change.
  • What if a future government decides to use this information for something different?
  • What if the information gets into the wrong hands?
  • Imagine someone finding out that you have a higher chance of developing a serious illness. Could an insurance company charge you more? Could an employer decide not to give you a job? Even if these things are restricted by today's rules, what about in the future?

Finally: Imagine you are expecting a baby tomorrow.
You are offered a free genetic test. It could identify serious illnesses early and potentially help save your child's life. However, your child's genetic information could be stored and used for medical research over many years. Would you agree to the test?

Related topics

Events in Cambridge, GB
Critical Thinking
Intellectual Discussions
Philosophy
Conversation
Self Exploration

You may also like