Auckland Deep Thinkers Sunday Lunch Book Club "An Enemy of the People"

A new venue and a new style for the new season. Let's get together once a month to discuss a book that has relevance in today's world.

This month's book is "An Enemy of the People" - an 1882 play by Henrik Ibsen that explores the conflict between truth and societal pressure, focusing on Dr. Thomas Stockmann's struggle against the community's denial of a public health crisis.

The play centers on Dr. Thomas Stockmann, a medical officer who discovers that the water in the public baths of his small Norwegian town is contaminated. This contamination poses a serious health risk to the townspeople, and Stockmann is determined to expose the truth. However, when he attempts to publicize his findings, he faces fierce opposition from local authorities, including his brother Peter Stockmann, who is the mayor. The community prioritizes economic interests over public health, leading to a dramatic conflict between individual integrity and collective denial.

Points for discussion:

1. Is the majority always right?
   Dr. Stockmann’s discovery of contaminated water is rejected by the townspeople, who prioritize economic interests. Should truth be subject to popular opinion, or does it stand independent of democratic consensus?
2. The tyranny of the majority
   The play questions whether democratic systems can suppress inconvenient truths. Can democracy become oppressive when driven by self-interest?
   Personal conscience vs. public pressure
3. Stockmann refuses to retract his findings, even when ostracized. Is moral integrity worth sacrificing social acceptance and livelihood?
4. Science vs. politics
   The play pits empirical evidence against political expediency. Should scientific truth ever be compromised for economic or political stability?
5. Role of the press
   Initially supportive, the local newspaper turns against Stockmann under pressure. Should media serve truth or reflect public sentiment?
6. Economic interests vs. public health
   The town fears losing revenue from its spa if the contamination is revealed. How should governments balance economic prosperity with ethical responsibility?
7. Freedom of speech
   Stockmann is denied a public platform to share his findings. Is free speech truly protected when it threatens the status quo?
8. Mob mentality and scapegoating
   The town brands Stockmann “an enemy of the people” to preserve unity. How do communities decide who to silence or vilify?
9. Family loyalty vs. civic duty
   Stockmann’s conflict with his brother, the mayor, underscores personal vs. public allegiance. Should family ties influence political decisions?

CUSTOMS:
You must register and be on the “Attendees - Going” list to attend.
Please bring $2 to cover Meetup costs.

RSVP POLICY:
RSVPs and cancellations will be accepted up until 6 hours before the start of the meetup so that people who feel unwell on the day have time to change their RSVP and allow someone else to attend.

Please only click 'attend' if you are going to come, and remember to change your RSVP if you need to change plans.

No-shows will be removed from the group; i.e. being registered to attend and not attending OR cancelling your attendance after 11:00am on the day will be considered a 'No Show'.
This RSVP policy has become necessary due to the high number of last-minute withdrawals and non-attendance. This unfairly causes people on the Waiting List to miss out. Thanks for your cooperation.