Skip to content

Details

SF Philosophy Club Monthly Meeting
Join us for another philosophy discussion at Ballast Coffee.

We'll be discussing the paper: "Attention, awareness and flexibility
in honeybees: divergent effects of distraction on delay versus trace
reversal learning"

https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rspb/article/293/2070/20252891/481626/Attention-awareness-and-flexibility-in-honeybees

When: Sunday, December 6, 2026, 1 PM - 3 PM.
Where: Ballast Coffee, 329 W Portal Ave, San Francisco, CA 94127

Newcomers welcome. Come prepared for thoughtful conversation and friendly debate.

Last month’s paper made a broad, theoretical case that insect brains may support the most basic form of subjective experience, because they integrate perception, memory, bodily state, and action in ways analogous to vertebrate midbrain systems. This paper takes a narrower and more technical behavioral approach: it asks whether honeybees show awareness-like processing of the relationship between a cue and its outcome.

Bees learn that one odor predicts sugar and another does not. In delay conditioning, the odor overlaps with the outcome. In trace conditioning, the odor ends before the outcome arrives, leaving a short gap, meaning that the bee must retain a “trace” of the odor across time. Then, they reverse the rules, testing whether bees can flexibly update what each odor means, and add a brief flashing-light to distract. Distraction disrupts reversal learning in both conditions, but in different ways. They argue that the difficulty of trace learning may reflect an additional awareness-like process. We can discuss whether that is the best explanation, or whether attention, task difficulty, or associative strength could account for the results without invoking consciousness.

Abstract: The question of whether awareness is required for trace but not for delay conditioning has recently been explored in the honeybee, a species renowned for its cognitive abilities. Distractors impair trace but not delay absolute olfactory conditioning, suggesting that bees, like humans, rely on awareness of the conditioned stimulus–unconditioned stimulus contingency during trace learning. Here, we extend this approach to reversal learning, which requires learning an initial discrimination (A+ B−) and subsequently learning the reversed contingencies (A−B+). Bees mastered olfactory reversal learning under both delay and trace protocols but acquisition was slower and less robust under trace than under delay conditioning. Introducing a visual distractor during the reversal phase impaired performance in distinct ways. Delay-conditioned bees increased responsiveness, adopting an A+B+ response profile, whereas trace-conditioned bees decreased responsiveness, adopting an A⁻B⁻ profile. To our knowledge, this is the first study in any animal species investigating reversal learning under a trace-conditioning regime, and the first assessing distractor effects in this paradigm. The contrasting outcomes indicate that the distractor disrupted attentional reallocation in both protocols, but additionally interfered with awareness in trace learning. These findings provide evidence that bees engage awareness-like processes during trace reversal learning, highlighting cognitive processing in an insect.

Related topics

You may also like