About us
You may sometimes wonder about fundamental things. Philosophers incline to it non-stop. At their best, they make trouble in the world of ideas. They open worm cans. Bring your can openers!
We have explored — or will (or will again) — age-old topics like God's existence, the nature of people and things, truth, justice, knowledge, free will, determinism, fatalism, birth, death, the right way to live or die... as well as theories in the major divisions of philosophical thought such as logic, metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, and aesthetics. Exploring these core areas can help with understanding what is at stake in the more concrete topics we also address, which include controversies around abortion, infanticide, capital punishment, suicide (physician-assisted and otherwise), economic and social equality, criminality, genetic engineering, neuroscience, artificial intelligence, technology, over-population, depopulation, war, terrorism, racism, sexism, feminism, transhumanism, antinatalism, procreation ethics, speciesism, sexuality, human "rights," animal rights, the "rights" of (or to) anything whatsoever!,... as well as important issues in medical ethics, political philosophy, environmental ethics, bioethics, philosophy of law, of art, of literature, of religion, of science and its methods; and the nature, history, and methods of philosophy itself... not to exclude philosophical topics as yet uninvented.
In fact, "inventing topics" is a side effect of asking hard questions, which inevitably lead to still harder questions. Often enough, "new" topics are not really "new" but old, even ancient, unsettled concerns resurfacing. And it is those unsettled issues that are the real philosophical problems. As one philosopher once said, "If it has a solution, it was probably just science anyway." Any important subject whose fundamental ideas invite critical examination is ripe for our can opener... eventually we may work our way up to the really big can: the point of it all! (But don't expect pat answers — we don't do self-help.)
This club is open to serious approaches to philosophy — analytic, "Continental," and otherwise. Philosophy in the anglophone world (for better or worse) is still dominated by some form of conceptual analysis. What characterizes the analytic approach to philosophy is attention to clarity and as much rigor as we can muster in our concepts and arguments — while, hopefully, keeping one foot in reality. (It's not "clear" that "reality" has anything to do with "clarity" or "rigor.") We ply "belief systems" with questions framed against such values. But you may know better! Philosophical traditions, no less than individual philosophical views, are error prone. Any "philosophy" worthy of the name should be comfortable with this.
We will try to stay focused on the topics under discussion, realizing that this is difficult. If one thing doesn't connect with another, it can't be that important. We draw on the insights of some of the brightest thinkers we know, both living and dead. Celebrated authority is no guarantee of being right. In fact, we already know at least half of the great philosophical thinkers must be wrong because the other half disagrees with them. But which half? (Even to assume only half are wrong is being more than a little optimistic. Why would any of them be right?)
Though we range widely in the topics we cover, we try not to let anything go in our discussion. The point is to rise above the level of BS that too often passes in informal discussions for philosophy. Beyond a certain respect for clarity and rigor, we do not have an axe to grind. You may bring your own axe, we may sharpen it for you... or we may grind it to a stump. We mostly open worm cans, remember? You decide what to do with the worms!
Skepticism and disagreement are to be expected, even encouraged. We should try to make the best case we can for our side and attend to what others say. We should expect that expressions of conviction may be forceful and that’s fine, as long as they are respectful of others and rational, which, in the context of a philosophy club, means to attempt to offer reasons to believe — reasons that are thought out and not themselves more controversial than the claims they are meant to support. These are aspirations, of course, not actual descriptions of what happens in even earnest philosophical discussions. We should nevertheless try...
A word about etiquette, again: philosophy, by its nature, is contentious. Expect disagreement and treat each other respectfully. Failure to do so may be cause for removal.
See the collection of archived writeups for perspective on the topics we have and may cover. Check out recorded sessions.
The group is international and mostly online. Formal membership is not required to attend and participate. Contact us for the video link if you just want to try it without membership. Our meetings and resources are free and open to the public. Auditing is perfectly fine.
Finally, if you know something about a topic and would like us to address it or you would like to present and host it yourself, let us know. You don't have to be an expert. We will work with you. So long as we can make out a philosophical angle — it addresses fundamental questions about an important subject, we would love to explore it.
Recording policy
Online meetings hosted by me may be recorded but will not be publicly shared except by request to club members who could not attend or wish to review an event. However, if an attendee has any concerns about this, please let me know, and either the recording will not be shared at all or your participation edited out. You are free, of course, to attend anonymously or without your mic and/or camera on. Other hosts may set their own policies.
Contact us with any questions.
— Victor Muñoz, organizer
Upcoming events
4

The Philosophy of Trust in the Age of AI
·OnlineOnlineWhat is the difference between a used car salesman and ChatGPT and similar large language models?
Trust has always been problematic, but trust has taken on renewed importance as we advance (or plummet) headlong into the age of artificial intelligence.
What is trust, and why would we extend it to algorithms and silicon?
Join us for this important discussion.
Reference materials for discussion:
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy trust articleWoman trusted ChatGPT for medical advice
Paper by Dr Kristin Thorisson: Better Machine Intelligence — A Vision for Nordic AI Leadership
This is a joint event with the Northwest AGI Forum
8 attendees
Philm | Le vieux fusil / The Old Gun (1975 – Robert Enrico)
·OnlineOnlineOn the psychic cost of killing even when arguably justified – especially then.1
All ethical theories from Divine Command Theory to Utilitarianism condemn killing. They give different reasons but they all agree it is a bad – except when they are busy justifying it in “special cases.” All species kill, especially, ours: the species that is compelled to come up with theories to condone or condemn it. Not content to be determinists, we attribute responsibility when we do it. Exceptions are carved out from imperatives against killing because abstract justice sometimes wants to insist that it can be understandable in some circumstances, even beyond that, legitimate. The idea that it is, in principle, wrong and there can be no exceptions offends our animal instincts. The worry that it is always wrong, no matter our instincts, is hard to let stand unresolved.
In Robert Enrico’s classic WW II revenge thriller, principled pacifism is put to the test. It follows the transformation of a surgeon in the midst of the carnage of war, disgusted by the human-inflicted horror he tries to mitigate everyday around him in his hospital. He is transformed from saver of lives to literal serial killer.2
But this is not a Rambo-style spectacle of violence… The film explores the clash between principled, comprehensible pacifism and a visceral sense of justice. It illustrates why “an eye for an eye” reasoning will not go away. It should, maybe, but won’t.
Can it ever be moral to kill? This can be related to the legal question but it is different. The moral question is not looking for answers in cultural or institutional practices. It is asking for an ultimate justification rooted in the fact that we commonly regard ourselves as rational creatures, and not merely animals. Various moral theories attempt to offer such justifications. The theories have at times served to both justify and condemn killing. The impulse to kill challenges the distinction between animal and human. The strain comes from trying to mediate between these.
In light of current events (when is killing not a “current event”?), we will explore what makes people think (or feel) killing may be justified. In particular, we will discuss if, and how, execution may be morally defended in light of philosophers who have weighed in on the topic, including J. S. Mill, Immanuel Kant, and Simone de Beauvoir. I will also review my “modest proposal” from one our earliest topics 10 years ago on the question.
...
Watch Le vieux fusil here with Philippe Noiret and Romy Schneider, in French with English subtitles. There is one particularly horrific scene, but it is central to the film. Be aware.
Resources
- “Americans Love The Death Penalty,” attorney Leeja Miller sums up the absurdity: the case of Christa Pike.
- “Capital Punishment: to 'blot out from the catalog of the living',” (2016) Victor Muñoz, writeup for one of our first meetups ten years ago.
- From a review of Le vieux fusil:
"A film you absolutely must see at least once in your life.
"Philippe Noiret embodies the staunch pacifist, the humanist bourgeois who has accumulated years of happiness alongside his wife and daughter, brutally murdered by desperate Germans on the eve of liberation. Devastated and numb by this gratuitous act of barbarity, he decides to take revenge with an old rifle kept in a corner of the chapel and kills the Germans one by one, Rambo-style, in a variety of deaths that would make him green with envy.
"The extremely understated yet violent direction succeeds in bringing out a raw power that allows us to share the emotions driving the poor man better than many more recent and far more expansive films. The flashbacks to happiness, which sometimes slow the film’s pace, are by no means saccharine or corny. The simplicity of the flashbacks, devoid of special effects or fanfare, perfectly complements the relentless, blind, and calculated revenge plot carried out by the protagonist, whose heart is already dead. Everything is filmed with a simplicity and starkness that nonetheless reveals a high level of quality in the direction, the choice of images, the dialogue, and, of course, the legendary actors."
The full review in French is here.
Notes
1. I say “especially” because “justification” in the face of “psychic costs” may not be relevant for a psychopath.
2. The film is loosely based on the massacre at Oradour-sur-Glane in Nazi-occupied France on 10 June 1944.8 attendees
Intelligence | natural and otherwise
·OnlineOnline“If a lion could speak, we could not understand him.”
– Ludwig Wittgenstein1On Wittgenstein’s famous remark, Luke Gibbons writes, “The point here is that even if the same sounds are emitted, or are formally indistinguishable, a capacity to understand their meaning requires a shared way of life.”2 Similarly, AI cannot understand us because it doesn’t eat, drink, defecate, urinate, procreate, bleed… unless, of course, we confess ourselves as simple-minded as things less talented in these ways.3 The biological constraints make us vastly more sophisticated. For this reason, if a lion could speak, we would have an easier time with mutual comprehension because at least the lion also does those things.
Intelligence
“the thing nobody talks about that changes everything”
– AI slopBefore we get to the artificial part, what is intelligence? The thing that is aware, manipulates, adapts, and passes judgment. Why should it bother? The short answer is because it is mortal. It dies, is finite, has just so much time. Has an end – both in the sense that it will stop being and in the sense of a goal. Things that are not driven by awareness of finitude have no place, in particular, to go.
The universe has no place it is going. It is one thing after another. It will go in a straight line, in circles, backwards, sideways, nowhere, all at once... ad infinitum. The best word to describe it is “process.” A development of a sort. Event A followed by event B. We may project onto processes goals because we have them. Naturally, in order to make sense of them, projecting makes them cognitively palatable. That things "make sense” is a need we have, not shared by the objects of projection. We are intelligent. All else we call “intelligent” is so because it reminds us of some aspect of ourselves or something we do.
I assume here, for the sake of argument, that we are intelligent. (I am not certain we are... even by natural standards. We’ll have to wait and see about that...) I surmise that intelligence is one tool, among others, that evolution has equipped some life forms with to enable their survival. But, as such, it has had hardly been around long enough to prove itself particularly good at enabling perdurance. It is still very much in beta form. Intelligence should not be confused with survival.4 Recognizable cockroaches have been found preserved in amber from 99 million years ago. If species longevity is what counts, we have a long way to go to prove our knack superior to theirs. If AI survives us, we shouldn’t feel too bad about it. It will only prove that intelligence may be overrated, and that AI itself may have a brief time of it, too. Moreover, if perdurance is the goal, it can only pickup bad habits from studying our behavior.
But again, assuming we are intelligent, what does it mean to be intelligent? In 2007, Shane Legg and Marcus Hutter compiled a list of seventy odd definitions of intelligence from reference works, psychologists, AI researchers, and others.5 Legg and Hutter thought they saw an underlying theme in their survey, and conclude with a kind of consensus definition. Given that their agenda was to pin a target for AI to emulate, it helped to spell intelligence out as clearly as possible. They came up with: intelligence...
• Is a property that an individual agent has as it interacts with its environment or environments.
• Is related to the agent’s ability to succeed or profit with respect to some goal or objective.
• Depends on how able the agent is to adapt to different objectives and environments.
Putting these key attributes together produces the informal definition of intelligence that we have adopted,
“Intelligence measures an agent’s ability to achieve goals in a wide range of environments.”6
We rephrase Legg and Hutter:
An intelligence is aware of, and can interact with, its environment toward some end, and is able to adapt its interaction as its environment changes.
For humans, at least, this comes down to a fairly proprietary knack for enabling their survival. But we must add a normative element missing from the tentative Legg and Hutter definition as it applies to humans: we are not happy merely surviving, we want it enhanced, which means supplementing bare competence at perdurance with demands that it have a certain character. This is where judgment or normativity enters. Not just any participation in the animate world will do, we have feelings about it: we give a damn about its being a certain way. Otherwise, being in a coma would be acceptable. But that things be “a certain way” opens the door to other knacks humans have such as one for self-destruction when the going gets unbearable, either because they practiced too successfully being rational, or because of a major lapse in intelligence.7
What does AI give a damn about? Having a goal, a programmed purpose, a set of marching orders is not enough. Why this goal and not that? Why even bother with survival in the first place?8 Nature (with no transparency as to motive) has instilled in us both an imperative to survive and perennial misgivings about the conditions of survival. Our behavior illustrates both. The first alone is not enough to sum up natural intelligence. An intelligence that didn’t question its own survival would be alien. Maybe that’s what the “A” in AI should stand for…
Extended writeup with more discussion and resources.
1. Philosophical Investigations 4th ed.
2.“The Other Side of the Sky,” World Literature, April 2018.
3. It may very well understand everything about you, but not you. Whether everything (the totality of every factual statement) about you is the same as you is an ancient epistemological question. Epistemology distinguishes different kinds of knowledge: knowing that (propositional, e.g., that water is H2O), knowing how (skill, e.g., riding a bike), knowing what or who (acquaintance knowledge as in recognizing someone in a lineup), etc. To the extent we feel there is something to know not captured by these cognitive forms of knowledge, they may not exhaust what there is to know. There are more semantically laden or existential forms of knowledge such as that gestured by the Biblical sense of knowing someone, for example.
4. I think this happens too often. Just because it has been useful to us in that way does not grant it some elevated or advanced status among survival traits. I has worked (so far) for us, as wings have for birds, fins for fish… Their size worked for dinosaurs for vastly longer than intelligence has worked for us – until one day it didn’t.
5. Legg and Hutter, “A Collection of Definitions of Intelligence.”
6. Ibid, 9.
7. As in rational suicide, on the one hand, or Darwin Award laureate level stupidity, on the other. (“Stupidity” will merit its own upcoming topic.)
8. To say, as some have, that survival is a necessary condition for achieving any goal whatever is not very informative. It just shifts the question to why a need for having a goal? It’s not obvious that the universe needed us as participants or witnesses. The unborn and dead don’t seem to be troubled by goals. “The world was made for the dead. Think of all the dead there are... There’s a million times more dead than living and the dead are dead a million times longer than the living are alive…” – Flannery O’Connor, The Violent Bear It Away.Resources
“The History of AI and the Future of Human Knowing,” Molly Crockett on what we can learn, and not learn, from DEAD (i.e, Decontextualized, Engineered, Anonymized, Disembodied) cognition.Image from Business Insider | Throne One, “Throne’s AI coach asks users about food, stress, travel, and sleep, and suggests correlations with their bowel habits.”
9 attendees
Philm series
·OnlineOnlineThis is not a post for a specific future event but a follow up to suggestions about scheduling film discussions. Here is a list of proposals from me and others. Feel free to add your own suggestions in the comments. The idea is to settle on a film, each of us watch it independently, then come together online to discuss it. The film should be engaging and provocative. Of course, each of us may have different ideas of what that means. And pretty much all great films can be that...
I think another requirement is that it be freely accessible online. The ones listed below, I think, are. (If they are not where you are, let us know. We may find another way to make them accessible.)
You are invited to vote for or give a rating (say, 1 to 10) on any of these films in the comments to help us choose. This could be a regular ongoing series, depending on interest, so it might not be either/or, we may do all of them eventually. (This is not the first time we have had a film discussion. A number of years ago, just before the pandemic, when the club was still meeting in person is Seattle, we did Dogville, Lars von Trier's cinematic provocation.)
The Last Man on Earth (1964) with Vincent Price [interesting in light of the recent pandemic]
Russian Ark [a cinematic tour de force]
Lars von Trier's Dancer in the Dark [Bjork's performance is legendary in this musical tragedy]
Carlos Reygadas' Silent Light [I think this is one of the most powerful and sublime films I have ever seen but I am still looking for a free version with English subtitles]
Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? [Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton show how to do dysfunctional relationships right]
19 attendees
Past events
155


