Comprehensivist Wednesdays: Keeping the Judgment, Losing the Resolve
Details
In this meetup we will explore what happens when someone keeps their judgment and loses their resolve anyway. Our starting point is Richard Holton's article "Intention and Weakness of Will," which argues that philosophy has spent centuries studying the wrong failing. The tradition, from Plato through Davidson, defines weakness of will as knowingly doing what you judge to be worse. Holton points out that this is not what anyone outside philosophy means by the phrase. Ask ordinary people and they describe irresoluteness: not sticking to plans, being too easily knocked off course. On this view weakness of will is not a broken judgment at the moment of action but giving up on a resolution too easily. "I'll quit on January first" is not a claim about what is best. It is a commitment made in advance, precisely to beat the desires you know are coming.
Our conversation focuses on the gap this leaves open. Holton's examples pull the two failings apart. A friend who thinks every argument favors vegetarianism and eats meat anyway attracts no charge of weakness. But catch him at the pit roast a day after he announces he is quitting, and the word fits. Nothing in his beliefs changed. If weakness of character is a failure of commitment over time rather than a failure of moral vision, the real question is no longer how judgment and action come apart, but what it takes to keep a promise made by an earlier version of yourself, when breaking it feels entirely reasonable at the moment you do.
Intention and Weakness of Will
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1hnNGeqIGDCMvbRALeYzIS8znyCzFaA0O/view?usp=sharing
*****************************************************************************
CJ Fearnley's book "Collaborating for Comprehensivity," is a unique exploration of comprehensive thinking, inquiry, and collaboration, is now available on Amazon in paperback, Kindle, and free PDF formats.
- The free PDF version can be downloaded here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1bapsUhFtRDSPdAW6zRBe7omBlcghz-yi/
- Available on Amazon Kindle for the lowest price Amazon allows of $0.99 here: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CW1K18B5/
- Available as a paperback on Amazon for the lowest price Amazon allows of $8.31 here: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0D11GHC9V/
************************************************************
Welcome to the series "Comprehensivist Wednesdays." Transdisciplinarity, Renaissance humanism, homo universalis, and Polymathy are some of the ways of describing this approach which Buckminster Fuller called Comprehensivity and described as “macro-comprehensive and micro-incisive.”
See the calendar at https://www.meetup.com/52LivingIdeas/events/calendar/
We record all our Meetups and post them on YouTube. Feel free to keep your video on or off as you prefer. Watch Past Meetups here.
Welcome to "Comprehensivist Wednesdays"
Explore transdisciplinarity, Renaissance humanism, homo universalis, and polymathy in ways Buckminster Fuller described as “macro-comprehensive and micro-incisive.”
A Meetup Every Day, Every Week, For Everyone!
Join us every weekday at 8 pm or 9 pm ET. We record all our meetups and post them on YouTube. Feel free to keep your video on or off as you participate.
Watch Past Meetups here.
